A Conversation for Ask h2g2

May I conduct an experiment?

Post 281

vogonpoet (AViators at A13264670)

<./>RandomEditedEntry</.> and my personal favourite <./>RandomEntry</.> look like they are working to me... maybe you got a cache problem?


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 282

Traveller in Time Reporting Bugs -o-o- Broken the chain of Pliny -o-o- Hired

Traveller in Time smiley - tit checking Classic and Alabaster
"It is the links on the frontpage playing up again . . .
< F47997?thread=4938263 > 'EF Front Page' smiley - zen"


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 283

Traveller in Time Reporting Bugs -o-o- Broken the chain of Pliny -o-o- Hired

Traveller in Time smiley - tit checking
"They seem to be smiley - ok again. "


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 284

KB

A508286 - Not Quite Traditional Music: I didn't really like this one. It took me a while to pin down exactly what the Researcher was talking about, and there were too many references which seemed to be either in-jokes or pet peeves. 2/5

A597305 - Molly Pitcher: It was interesting, but I'd like to know a bit more - a lot of the Entry consists of what telling us about what wasn't true about her. Still, if the purpose of an entry is to stimulate interest and lead to further reading, it did work on that level. 3/5


A416305 - The Peak District, Derbyshire, UK: An interesting start. I'm sure that lots of the ramblers, walkers and climbers we have on site could provide lots more information and bring a lot to it. Same as last - 3/5 for the potential.


A1304957 - Mozart's Death - Murder, Accident or Disease? 4/5. A few small internal inconsistencies which don't spoil the reading of it too much.


A994737 - 'Waiting for Godot' - the Play: While the play might seem boring, it's one of the most enjoyable ones I've ever gone to watch. The entry gives a good introduction and avoids the Emperor's New Clothes syndrome or automatic rejection that is often common when people talk about it. 4/5


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 285

benjaminpmoore

Hey guys, sorry to interrupt the flow here, but I've been pitching an idea to the post team and I'm just looking to see if any of you lot are interesting in being involved. Basically, the idea is an ongoing, derveloping story based on the guide. Each week an author will write a story based on five randomly generated guide entries. They will then produce five more random entries and the next week another author will pick up the story will the new entries as a basis. Anyone interested?


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 286

U168592

might be...


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 287

Danny B

Sounds intriguing smiley - smiley


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 288

Icy North

Ben - are you talking about a piece of creative writing inspired by 5 random entries, or an expanded review of them?


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 289

U168592

I do believe it's creative writing for the post...

F127405?thread=5115995

or read here: A32762856


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 290

Icy North

Thanks, Matt smiley - cheers


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 291

U168592

Further to your suggestion ben, why not get one person to choose 5 Random Entries (like yourself), then people can make up their own stories for the five if they like, then submit them all to the Post? That way you get exposure of 5 EG Entries but also bulk out the Post smiley - ok


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 292

McKay The Disorganised

Sounds like hell to me....

A590339 - Floccinaucinihilipification ~ floccinaucinihilipilificatious 3/5

A653429 - Carl Gustav Jung - the Man ~ Not light reading but if it's what you were after - 3/5

A447266 - Band Aid and Live Aid ~ A bit listy with all the acts involved, but what else can you do ? 4/5

A1051543 - Bombay Dream - The Musical ~ Somewhat garbled, and not very informative. 2/5

A2788653 - Showaddywaddy - Rick 'n' Roll Revivalists ~ Nice little number. 4/5

Hmm - 3 music related entries - a bit of froth and a 'serious' piece for an average of 3.2 smiley - ok

I suppose I'd come back.

smiley - cider


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 293

benjaminpmoore

Actually Matt, my plan was to write an initial post article explaining the idea, outlining a couple of rules and then giving five opening random entries. It would then be up to the first person to start the story off, based on the five entries. At the end of their offering (we might set a word limit?) they would then list five more random entries for the next person to use as their basis for picking up and continuing the story. I'm not yet sure how long we should expect the story to last, but I was hoping for a continual developing plot. On the other hand, if people generally prefer your idea, we could do that instead.


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 294

U168592

oh!

No, that sounds much better...

My idea sounds naff.


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 295

aka Bel - A87832164

The only problem with this idea is, that you'd maybe have two unfinished stories and nothing more.
As far as I know, the current Post policy is not to accept a series of stories that's not finished, because the experience seems to be that otherwise they stop, leaving the plot in mid-air.
So you'd have to make sure to have enough contributors right from the start, and once all the sories are in, they'll be published in chronological order.


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 296

benjaminpmoore

Fair enough Bel, that seems reasonable. So we line up one contributor per episode for, what- five? Ten? However many people we can get I guess. Unless people reckon they want to do more than one. How many parts would be good?


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 297

benjaminpmoore

Okay so can I put anyone down as a contributor? Also, Bel, any chance of putting an entry in the post to tap the readers for contributions in advance?


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 298

aka Bel - A87832164

If you want tpo send one in, deadline for the next issue is Sunday (23rd) at midnight GMT. smiley - ok


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 299

benjaminpmoore

I'll get writing. smiley - biggrin


May I conduct an experiment?

Post 300

aka Bel - A87832164

smiley - ok


Key: Complain about this post