A Conversation for Ask h2g2

To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 41

Geggs

I thought Lancre was meant to be Lancashire. Well, it certainly begins and ends the same way.


Geggs


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 42

Tavaron da Quirm - Arts Editor

Oh, and Überwald is not Germany.

Über-wald = behind-forest = Trans-sylvania

Transylvania was once inhabited by German speaking people.


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 43

You can call me TC

Glad we got that cleared up. I was basing my thing about Klatsch=France on the expression "Pardon my Klatschian". Tenuous, I'll admit. Quirm I always had marked off as Italy because Leonard of Quirm was a sort of Leonardo da Vinci.


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 44

Mol - on the new tablet

Where does Vimes end up when he pilots the boat down the river on the wave? Because that gave the impression of being French ... the cooking.

Mol


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 45

TRiG (Ireland) A dog, so bade in office

I think Klatch *is* France in terms of its relationship with A-M. That is, which Klatch is Middle-eastern (and Quirm is France), the Klatch/Ankh-Morpork relationship is the same as the French/British relationship. They talk about each other the same way, and have a rivalry which is usually fairly friendly. Up as far as, indeed, "pardon my Klatchian".

Admittedly, the fact that educated Klatchians are fluent in Morporkian, and even in Latatian, while educated A-M citizens are not usually fluent in Klatchian means that this slips a bit, but I do think there's some truth to it. Alternatively, Klatch plays different roles in different books.

(I was once in an Indian take-away and I actually thought of it as "going for a Klatchian", not in any humorous way: that's just what I was thinking.)

TRiG.smiley - book


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 46

TRiG (Ireland) A dog, so bade in office

Überwald is Transylvania as interpreted by Hammer Horror films, isn't it?

I don't think I've ever seen a Hammer Horror film.

TRiG.smiley - silly


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 47

fords - number 1 all over heaven

Hammer Horror films are great. Watch some over the weekend, you'll love them smiley - biggrin


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 48

quotes

From early on, I was surprised that Ankh-Morpork was supposed to be London, simply because it's described as being hot. I've lived in London; hot it is not.

And is there a pun I'm missing with the name? I feel there must be a pun in there somewhere.


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 49

fords - number 1 all over heaven

The Tube does get pretty grotty in the summer. Maybe that's the inspiration?


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 50

Tavaron da Quirm - Arts Editor

Talking of the tube... did you know that 'The Long Dark' symbol of the dwarfs is based on the signs of the London tube?


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 51

fords - number 1 all over heaven

I did! smiley - biggrin


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 52

Sho - employed again!

how do you lot know all this stuff?


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 53

Bluebottle

I suspect reading might be involved... smiley - winkeye

<BB<


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 54

Bluebottle

The Chalk seems based on the Vale of the White Horse.

<BB<


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 55

fords - number 1 all over heaven

Because I bloody love the Discworld and hoover up factoids smiley - biggrin


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 56

Tavaron da Quirm - Arts Editor

smiley - laugh so do I, you can find a lot of things online. lspace.org is very interesting for isntance and there is a discworld wiki.

http://www.lspace.org/books/apf/index.html


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 57

Sho - employed again!

thanks - I mean I recognise a lot of the references, but some things just pass me by smiley - smiley


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 58

You can call me TC

Sto Lat, by the way, means "a hundred years" in Polish (in this world) and it#s the name of their version of "Happy Birthday"


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 59

paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant

"If you have the same map that I have Quirm has number 24. It's a bit north of A-M, at the Circle Sea." [Tavaron da Quirm]

I have the same map, but there's no index, so I don't know what the numbers refer to. I see 24, and it's where you said it would be, so now I know it's Quirm. Quirm is not written on the map itself.

"I always thought Lancre was the West Country of England, especially as they all have oo arr gerroff moi laaaaaand accents in the Wyrd Sisters animation." [Fords]

You may be right.

"I think Klatch *is* France in terms of its relationship with A-M." [TRiG]

At the risk of reading too much into Pratchett's spatial arrangements, the Circle Sea is probably the Mediterranean. Rome is situated on the Mediterranean as Ankh Morpork is situated on the Circle Sea. Quirm is somewhat to the northwest, as the French Riviera and its Italian neighbors would be northwest of Rome. Ephebia is to the east of Ankh-Morpork, just as Greece is to the east of Rome. Egypt's position south across the Mediterranean from Rome is taken by Djelibehbee and Klatch, which are south across the Circle Sea from Ankh-Morpork.

If Klatch is France, then it has more curries than you would expect France to have. Curries and tagines have a lot of the same spices in them. A tagine from Morocco, for instance, would be quite hot, just as a curry from India would be. [Tagines are often served over couscous]


To what extent is Ankh-Morpork based on real cities?

Post 60

Pink Paisley

I have always been torn by Lancre.

I always thought of it as sort of Lancashire / Cumbria or Wales.

It's all the rain. And the mountains.

And Klatch, I took to be sort of Persia kind of thing.

PP.


Key: Complain about this post