A Conversation for Ask h2g2

But is it art daaahlink?

Post 1

swl

Saw this on youtube - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OwCoSxi9TJU&oref=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fresults%3Fsearch_query%3Dsadler%2527s%2Bwells%26aq%3Df

Now, I've seen a lot of modern dance and experimental theatre in my time. But this?

Anybody care to give an interpretation?


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 2

drt

Choreographer on drugs?


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 3

Witty Moniker

Yes, it is art, in my opinion.

I don't necessarily need to interpret it, experiencing it is often pleasurable in itself. If I had to, though, I'd say the choreographer was experimenting with props that are concerned with augmenting mobility. An interesting exercise.


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 4

anhaga

Not only is it art, it's quite stunning and beautiful art!

smiley - erm I'm a little surprised (disappointed) the question was asked.smiley - erm

But then, I'm also glad it was asked -- I wouldn't likely have seen it otherwise.


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 5

aka Bel - A87832164

It told me I had to sign in or confirm I'm old enough to watch this content, so I passed.


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 6

HonestIago

Bel it just had a few bare-chested ladies, nothing more salacious than that. Worth watching just for the sheer smiley - huh-ness of it all

I agree with drt - whatever the choreographer was on, I want some of it because it must be amazing. I'd say yes, it's art but that doesn't mean it's any good.


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 7

anhaga

I'd say it's bleeding brilliant!

And I'm more than a little shocked that some would think it's smiley - huh and/or the product of a drugged choreographer.

Being as the clip does not include the whole piece, interpretation would necessarily be tentative (like interpreting Hamlet after viewing only the opening scene), but . . .


I was immediately struck by it being a statement about 'dis'ability in the modern world, and concepts of beauty, and, indeed about concepts of what constitutes art itself (so maybe some of the smiley - huhs are desirable responses). But that all seems sooo obvious.smiley - erm


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 8

drt

-'Of course it's art Dud, it's got bare chested ladies in it. That's your proper art that is. That's how you tell, by the bare chested ladies.' -'What, like page three, Pete?'
-'That's right Dud.'smiley - smiley

Flippancy apart, it is actually a beautiful bit of dance. Pretentious, confusing and odd, but beautiful.


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 9

drt

Anhaga, the drugged choreographer suggestion was me being facetious. It does look like something of a dream sequence. But I freely admit to knowing very very little about art. And nothing about dance.smiley - smiley


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 10

anhaga

seems neither odd nor pretentious to me.smiley - erm

But then, this was the ordinary dance of my youth: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8q876pJ0tWE


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 11

~ jwf ~ scribblo ergo sum

It is fresh, original and innovative!
Not a hint of the usual pretensions one often
encounters in brave new works of art. It is done
with taste, style and bravura presentation.

Not sure I'd go see it if it played locally.
Not sure I want to even consider its deeper meaning.
But it is art and it's quite dynamic.

Thanks for sharing.
smiley - ok

~jwf~


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 12

Rudest Elf


That's brilliant, anhaga.

Bel, I didn't want to sign up either, but managed to find another way in.

Campagnie Marie Chouinard body remix - goldberg variations: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AeGPUyCEhrk

La La La Human Steps 'Human Sex' http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l2ORZCdazM0

smiley - reindeer


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 13

8584330

smiley - applause That's anything but ordinary. If sports were that smiley - cool I'd get ESPN.


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 14

Beatrice

Wow, that's fabulous!

The changes in body movement with an extra limb, or extended limb, moving into a sort of spidery encounter. Absolutely marvellous, I'd definitely go to see that. And what skill from those performers - bravo!


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 15

Milla, h2g2 Operations

I was also amazed at how well you can dance with crutches and ballet shoes. It made me think of gracious antelopes or something, except antelopes don't walk that way either.
Not so sure about the man on the wheeley-board, but, mainly because of the lightsaber he was chomping on.
Interesting, quite beautiful, and widens horizons.

Of course, there is other art that others adore but I don't. Such is life. And art. smiley - biggrin

smiley - towel


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 16

Effers;England.


When people ask me what Art is..the daftest question imaginable (because there is no art without context)..I always say, 'She is a very cruel mistress'...

(And she bloody well is smiley - laugh).


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 17

Mr. Dreadful - But really I'm not actually your friend, but I am...

Well... I don't get it. Does absolutely nothing for me. But if you like it, fair enough. smiley - ok

Beauty is entirely subjective, despite what the media would have us beleive.


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 18

Effers;England.


smiley - huh What does beauty have to do with Art?

Except one tiny aspect to do with what some call aesthetics...which is not entirely subjective. Different cultures arrive at different ideas of beauty.

What is always totally silly to me is people who like to oversimplify the incredibly complex and interesting.

I don't get vast amounts of geeky stuff that lots of people seem to like. Yeah it's fair enough.


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 19

Mr. Dreadful - But really I'm not actually your friend, but I am...

Which I think proves how subjective beauty is. To me it's a very broad and complex thing, to you it's such a small part of one aspect of 'art' that you assume I'm oversimplifying.


But is it art daaahlink?

Post 20

Beatrice

Art doesn't have to be beautiful, in my opinion.

But both art and beauty are, indeed, very broad, and in the eye of the beholder.


Key: Complain about this post