A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 21

Icy North

Actually, the list is:

****
****
********
****
********
****
******
*******
****
************
****-******
***
***
******
and
*****


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 22

azahar

<>

Gaaaaaaaa! And then we'd all fall down and dieeee!!!!! smiley - run



Truer was what kelli said - the list is being added to daily, if not hourly, so the LIST only exists for a moment or two at a time.


az


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 23

kelli - ran 2 miles a day for 2012, aiming for the same for 2013

I doubt it is being changed hourly - or even daily by now, but I doubt it is now static.


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 24

azahar

*prone to exaggeration* smiley - winkeye

az


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 25

Ferrettbadger. The Renegade Master

Not particuarly....

However I have to say that I am not offended by *any* swear words. I always think that they are just words.

See you next Tuesday is deffo my fave smiley - evilgrin....


Removed

Post 26

Mrs Zen

This post has been removed.


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 27

azahar

Funny you should say that, Ben. I sometimes feel a bit embarrassed to translate 'mierda' for my students, but not when I translate 'joder'.


az


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 28

You can call me TC

I don't use it, well, in my life I've used it less perhaps than half a dozen times. I don't like hearing it either.

It's not a nice word, the conjunction of such unpleasant and hard consonant sounds and the short, barked vowel.

It is not necessary as a verb or a noun - there are perfectly good and acceptable alternative words, and using it as an expletive just displays a limited vocabulary.

Having said that, I don't feel very strongly about the whole thing. And I've not come across anything affected by the profanny filter yet, as far as I know. Still trying to work out what the fuss is about.


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 29

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

This is getting very tiresome.

Lil's right - all you need is one thread, and the profanity filter thread on the Community Soapbox is such a discussion. I believe I'll concentrate my attemtion there. Whether or not SoRB might claim that he's asking a serious and valid question, this thread is already turning over the same tired remains of the other thread and is likely to continue to do so, ad nauseum, with little new content.

You should run a couple of sweepstakes - one on how long it will be before Ferretbadger comes along and bangs on once again about Father Jack's favourite word, and another one on which post kelli will reiterate that her Polari entry now fails the filter.

We know.

Of course, now that I've said that, I've completely banjaxed the odds of either of those two things happening smiley - winkeye


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 30

Alfster

Not offensive but I have realised I do not use it that much I prefer to use crap or shite they sound better. I just don't lke the word particularly from a linguist point of view. smiley - geek

I can certainly see why people do not like it it has got the old hard sylable and letter T at the end giving it some aural force.


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 31

Ferrettbadger. The Renegade Master

smiley - yawn

If it so boring and tired and meaningless BH why post?


Removed

Post 32

Mu Beta

This post has been removed.


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 33

Mrs Zen

>> Yeah, well. Which would you rather do in bed?

Quite.

Or the bathroom, for that matter.

B


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 34

LL Waz

Trillian's Child, I sympathise in a way and a lot of the reaction and repetition of reaction is irritating, but if kitboyes tried to write this entry A4177280, exactly as it is, with the *'s, now, he'd be told 'This entry has been blocked as it contains a word which other users may find offensive. Please edit your entry and post it again.' and would be unable to post it.

I think it's an entry well worth having here, it's a great read and needs the banned words, imo. The UnderGuide entry on the Front Page today was the better, imo again, for the extra colour added by the couple of swear words originally in it.

Now Kelli's been told the eds will look at her Polari entry which has banned words also, but would a newish researcher know the ropes enough to request that, would they bother, and outside the EG will the staff have time to consider any such requests.

I don't know. That side of this concerns me. The other side of this that bothers me is that when you take responsibility away from people there's a tendency to react by feeling, being and acting less responsibly.

Apologies for offtopicness, and if I say anymore on either thread I'll be repeating myself so I leave things at that.
Waz




Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 35

Trin Tragula

Offtopicness it may be, but it's been bothering me too ...

F3719964?thread=2838952?thread=&post=32760007#p32760007


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 36

Traveller in Time Reporting Bugs -o-o- Broken the chain of Pliny -o-o- Hired

Traveller in Time smiley - tit
"smiley - shhhT (still trying to lower the noise)"


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 37

kelli - ran 2 miles a day for 2012, aiming for the same for 2013

Thanks gosho, sadly the filter is preventing from expressing the depth of my feelings towards you.


Is the word "shit" offensive?

Post 38

Mu Beta

**sigh**

Women never say that to me.

B


Removed

Post 39

equestrian_statue

This post has been removed.


Removed

Post 40

Hoovooloo

This post has been removed.


Key: Complain about this post