A Conversation for Ask h2g2
Last Ditch Effort
Mr. X ---> "Be excellent to each other. And party on, dudes!" Started conversation Aug 21, 2009
Last Ditch Effort
taliesin Posted Aug 21, 2009
Possibly refers to trench warfare. Soldiers being forced to retreat to the 'last ditch' (trench) may be inspired to greater effort, since they have no more trenches to fall back on
Last Ditch Effort
Icy North Posted Aug 21, 2009
It precedes WWI (just). The OED has 'last-ditcher' (one who fights until the last ditch) from 1909.
'Last-ditch' only appears from 1951 (last-ditch stand). 'Last-ditch effort' is from 1971 (in a football report) and 'Last-ditch attempt' from 1973. So the phrase in its current sense appears to be quite modern.
Last Ditch Effort
Orcus Posted Aug 21, 2009
The American Civil war demonstrated the use of trenches in warfare. So 1909 is perfectly in concert with the original answer.
Last Ditch Effort
Orcus Posted Aug 21, 2009
Having said that, armies have been digging ditches as temporarty fortifications since antiquity.
Last Ditch Effort
~ jwf ~ scribblo ergo sum Posted Aug 21, 2009
The idea of the 'moat' has been terribly romanticised by novelists and filmmakers in the past century or so, but such 'ditches' (whether flooded or not) were indeed a major part of defenses since antiquity.
There might be several concentric 'rings' dug around a castle. And they were actually called ditches. The 'last ditch' would be the innermost ring, closest to the defensive walls.
The 'effort' can reasonably be seen as coming from both defenders and attackers. Grenadiers were often involved in much effort to dig tunnels under the walls and place explosive charges (called 'petards' upon which many were often 'hoist').
Petard Origin:
1590–1600; < MF, equiv. to pet(er) to break wind (deriv. of pet < L pēditum a breaking wind, orig. neut. of ptp. of pēdere to break wind) + -ard -ard
~jwf~
Last Ditch Effort
Mr. X ---> "Be excellent to each other. And party on, dudes!" Posted Aug 23, 2009
The American Civil War was in 1861-65, not 1909.
~*~The 'last ditch' would be the innermost ring, closest to the defensive walls.~*~
Ahhh........ That may explain it.....
Last Ditch Effort
Cheerful Dragon Posted Aug 23, 2009
jwf, you don't actually explain what a petard was. Just to fill in the gaps, it was a kind of metal grenade filled with gunpowder set off by a fuse. Sappers would dig a tunnel and attach the device to a door or drawbridge to set it off. The name 'petar' or 'petard' probably came from the sound of the muffled explosion at the end of a long tunnel.
Last Ditch Effort
Orcus Posted Aug 23, 2009
> The American Civil War was in 1861-65, not 1909.<
I'll double that
Yes indeed, therefore the phrase could easily have been well established by 1909.
Last Ditch Effort
Mr. X ---> "Be excellent to each other. And party on, dudes!" Posted Aug 23, 2009
Certainly true. The context of the sentence made it seem like you had your dates mixed up though. *shrug*
Last Ditch Effort
Clive the flying ostrich: Amateur Polymath | Chief Heretic. Posted Aug 23, 2009
>>The American Civil War was in 1861-65, not 1909..., therefore the phrase could easily have been well established by 1909.<<
If the show 'Balderdash and Piffle' is anything to go by, isn't it not enough that a phrase may have been 'in use' at a point of recollection, but that it has to have been written down or printed?
(It's been a while since I watched, and I can't recall what the OED's rules are on changing the known etymology.
Last Ditch Effort
Cheerful Dragon Posted Aug 23, 2009
The rules are that the word must appear in print, or be used on film or audio, in something to which a firm date can be attached. So the following are acceptable: a newspaper or magazine article where the date of the publication is known, a book with the date of publication, a film with a known release date, a TV programme or radio programme with a known broadcast date, any printed matter with an issue date or copyright date.
Last Ditch Effort
Orcus Posted Aug 23, 2009
Yes but my point was that there was trench warfare *before* 1909.
Someone said that it may have originated from trench warfare, ergo WWI. Then the 1909 reference was brought out in essence to refute this... at least that's how I read it.
Blimey it's hard to get one's point across in text talk sometimes.
Last Ditch Effort
Just Bob aka Robert Thompson, plugging my film blog cinemainferno-blog.blogspot.co.uk Posted Aug 24, 2009
Huh.
Key: Complain about this post
Last Ditch Effort
- 1: Mr. X ---> "Be excellent to each other. And party on, dudes!" (Aug 21, 2009)
- 2: taliesin (Aug 21, 2009)
- 3: Icy North (Aug 21, 2009)
- 4: Mr. X ---> "Be excellent to each other. And party on, dudes!" (Aug 21, 2009)
- 5: Yvonne aka india (Aug 21, 2009)
- 6: Orcus (Aug 21, 2009)
- 7: Orcus (Aug 21, 2009)
- 8: ~ jwf ~ scribblo ergo sum (Aug 21, 2009)
- 9: taliesin (Aug 21, 2009)
- 10: Mr. X ---> "Be excellent to each other. And party on, dudes!" (Aug 23, 2009)
- 11: Cheerful Dragon (Aug 23, 2009)
- 12: Orcus (Aug 23, 2009)
- 13: Mr. X ---> "Be excellent to each other. And party on, dudes!" (Aug 23, 2009)
- 14: Clive the flying ostrich: Amateur Polymath | Chief Heretic. (Aug 23, 2009)
- 15: Cheerful Dragon (Aug 23, 2009)
- 16: Orcus (Aug 23, 2009)
- 17: Menthol Penguin - Currently revising/editing my book (Aug 23, 2009)
- 18: Just Bob aka Robert Thompson, plugging my film blog cinemainferno-blog.blogspot.co.uk (Aug 24, 2009)
- 19: Menthol Penguin - Currently revising/editing my book (Aug 24, 2009)
More Conversations for Ask h2g2
- What can we blame 2legs for? [19024]
8 Hours Ago - Radio Paradise introduces a Rule 42 based channel [1]
17 Hours Ago - For those who have been shut out of h2g2 and managed to get back in again [26]
4 Days Ago - What did you learn today? (TIL) [274]
2 Weeks Ago - What scams have you encountered lately? [10]
Sep 2, 2024
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."