A Conversation for Old Announcements: January - September 2011
This thread has been closed
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
pheloxi | is it time to wear a hat? | Posted Nov 4, 2002
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
pheloxi | is it time to wear a hat? | Posted Nov 4, 2002
and now a suitable pushishment...let me think...mmm
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
Marjin, After a long time of procrastination back lurking Posted Nov 4, 2002
pheloxi*, the suitable punishment for a violation of the houserules is yikesing of the concerned posting. As you seem to be the one being offended, you have the honour of pushing the complaint button
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
pheloxi | is it time to wear a hat? | Posted Nov 4, 2002
I rather tease Ashley a bit with it...still thinking about punishment
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
Jim Lynn Posted Nov 4, 2002
Don't know if this is the right place to say it, but if you want this project to succeed, it would probably be a bad thing if you all went round yikesing any and every post that *might* *possibly* break the rules. This would generate a lot of extra complaint traffic which might suggest that the pilot isn't working.
What would be far better would be for everyone to *stick to the rules*. Don't swear, defame, post copyright stuff or be offensive. And if you see people behaving badly, tell them they're behaving badly and they might actually stop.
If, at the end of this pilot, we can show editorial policy that the number of complaints hasn't significantly risen then it should continue indefinitely.
But if they see ten times the number of complaints simply because you're all trying to be diligent and yikesing anything that *might* be offensive or break the rules, then that might look like a failure.
So, the complaints button should only be used for its original purpose - complaining about things the you genuinely find offensive (or that you are pretty sure break the rules in a big way).
We won't be giving out any prizes for the most complaints submitted.
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
pheloxi | is it time to wear a hat? | Posted Nov 4, 2002
....generate a lot of extra complaint traffic which might suggest that the pilot isn't working
Jim that was one of reasons not use the yikes button.
plus that is more fun to hold something above a one of pisa people.
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
Yes,I am the Lady Lowena!Get with the programme... Posted Nov 4, 2002
Thanx for posting this on my space...I have never complained about any conversation,thread or posting,though. If I might make one suggestion,it would be nice to know what you were getting moderated for..it isn't always obvious. 'Hidden for language content' Some of the views put forward in this posting could be deemed to be offensive' ,that sort of thing.Also one mans irony is another mans deeeeply offensive comment...difficult job moderating I imagine(creep,creep)
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
Mina Posted Nov 4, 2002
Anyone who has content hidden receives an email Lady Lowena - so they will know why they have been moderated.
Deciding what is offensive and what isn't, isn't always an easy job. If we're unsure if something will offend, we leave it up to the readers to decide - which they can do by using the complaints button.
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
Robert Wall [Undead] Posted Nov 4, 2002
*unsubscribes*
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
E G Mel Posted Nov 4, 2002
So if we find something that breaks the house rules would it be polite to put a post after it saying to the effect that your post broke the rules, we are a self policing community so I felt it necessary to 'yikes' it. Point to the rules and ask them not to be disheartened we all make slip ups occasionally and that we hope they will continue to post in the spirit of h2g2?
Mel
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
Kerr_Avon - hunting stray apostrophes and gutting poorly parsed sentences Posted Nov 4, 2002
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
E G Mel Posted Nov 4, 2002
We have been discussing here <./>F55683?thread=221214</.> about the importance of making a definate difference between the volunteers and the italics as it is possible that some newbies may be confused, I'm not sure whether my last suggestion would add to this confusion or not.
Mel
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
egon Posted Nov 4, 2002
"Anyone who has content hidden receives an email Lady Lowena - so they will know why they have been moderated."
the other day I had quite a few postings hidden for libel- or at least I assume they were all for libel, I only received about three or four emails but had more than that hidden. Not complaining, just making a point.
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
egon Posted Nov 4, 2002
His initials are A.D. and he used to present a popular news related comedy panel game...
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
E G Mel Posted Nov 4, 2002
Well it was either him or the tv presenter who has had rape accusations made against him If he did Nasty Nasty man, if he didn't, mean publicity stunt for a certain young female, either way his career is ruined.
Mel
Key: Complain about this post
1 November 2002: Peer Moderation Pilot Project
- 121: Ashley (Nov 4, 2002)
- 122: pheloxi | is it time to wear a hat? | (Nov 4, 2002)
- 123: Ashley (Nov 4, 2002)
- 124: pheloxi | is it time to wear a hat? | (Nov 4, 2002)
- 125: Marjin, After a long time of procrastination back lurking (Nov 4, 2002)
- 126: pheloxi | is it time to wear a hat? | (Nov 4, 2002)
- 127: Whisky (Nov 4, 2002)
- 128: Whoami - iD dislikes punctuation (Nov 4, 2002)
- 129: Jim Lynn (Nov 4, 2002)
- 130: pheloxi | is it time to wear a hat? | (Nov 4, 2002)
- 131: Yes,I am the Lady Lowena!Get with the programme... (Nov 4, 2002)
- 132: Mina (Nov 4, 2002)
- 133: Robert Wall [Undead] (Nov 4, 2002)
- 134: E G Mel (Nov 4, 2002)
- 135: Kerr_Avon - hunting stray apostrophes and gutting poorly parsed sentences (Nov 4, 2002)
- 136: E G Mel (Nov 4, 2002)
- 137: egon (Nov 4, 2002)
- 138: E G Mel (Nov 4, 2002)
- 139: egon (Nov 4, 2002)
- 140: E G Mel (Nov 4, 2002)
More Conversations for Old Announcements: January - September 2011
- Thursday 20 October 2011: Bug Fixing Update: you have your names back. [204]
Dec 21, 2011 - Announcements [172]
Dec 11, 2011 - Friday 30 September, 2011: H2G2 Moves to its New Home [155]
Oct 21, 2011 - Announcements from the new h2g2! editors. Small bug with the yikes button. [86]
Oct 20, 2011 - Wednesday 07 September, 2011: Jane Belson has Passed Away [74]
Sep 16, 2011
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."