A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Out of our Ideolect.

Post 41

Secretly Not Here Any More

I despise the way London-based journalists have decided that Mancunians say "foo king*". I've never in my life heard anyone say "foo king".

It's f'ing ridiculous.

(*minus the space - the filther is also f'ing ridiculous)


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 42

Hoovooloo


I find the Mom/Mum/Mammy thing is an excellent and pretty reliable indicator of the true source of text, lacking other clues.


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 43

Edward the Bonobo - Gone.

Every time I objected, someone would say 'It sounds more friendly.' smiley - steam It wasn't the time or place to sound friendly.


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 44

Mrs Zen

smiley - steam It's not friendly, it's patronising as shit.

A million years ago my Pa was a clergyman and I was 10. Someone came to the front door and rang the bell and I answered it. She was clearly disconcerted but grinned toothily at me and said "is Daddy home?" I stared in amazement (my Pa was not this woman's "daddy") and muttered that "the vicar is out",and we both recoiled from the encounter in horror.

25 years later she recounted the same story to my Ma; it was clearly etched as firmly in her mind as it was in mine.

Poor woman; I must have looked like the snootiest young bitch in the world. If I'd been only a little older I'd have gone straight for the pronoun and said "no, he's out" and left it at that.

B


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 45

Sol

A friend once gave me her back catalogue of Baby and Toddler magazine (or somesuch), with the apologetic rider, 'You have to just ignore the fact they call children 'tots'.'

Babies get called 'baby' too. That irritates me.

And what I want to know is why babies are always female in leaflets, baby magazines and so on too.


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 46

Icy North

I'm happy calling a gender-unspecified baby "it", but it seems to upset other people.


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 47

Hoovooloo

"I'm happy calling a gender-unspecified baby "it", but it seems to upset other people"

I'm happy calling anything under sixteen and/or with an apparent IQ less than 90 "it", but that really seems to upset practically everybody.


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 48

Effers;England.


Yes that could be problematic if you ever went for a job working as a support worker working with people with learning difficulties....can't see you in that sort of job though smiley - winkeye

I've done it...but I wouldn't recommend it.


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 49

Edward the Bonobo - Gone.

Of course IQ is a pretty poor way of judging someone's humanity. A much better way is...humanity. smiley - winkeye


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 50

Effers;England.


Yes sarr. Hadn't ocurred to me. smiley - winkeye


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 51

Mol - on the new tablet

Dr Spock refers to the baby as 'he' because (he tells us) he needs the female personal pronouns for the mother.

'Toddler taming' (another great classic, but this time aimed at both parents) uses male and female pronouns for the children in alternate chapters.

So perhaps now we are halfway round the circle, if babies are generally 'she'.

We use 'mum' when we're *talking* about cases but never in anything written.

My daughters say 'lol' when they find something funny. I don't. Well, I mean *they* don't sit in front of Live At The Apollo saying 'Lol. Lol. Lol.' - they do actually laugh. But ... well, what a weird world.

Mol


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 52

Sho - employed again!

I left a consultation with #1 once because they kept referring to me as "mama" (German equivalent of mum)

I hate Tots or similar or Baby when they mean The Baby. etc etc

so you will never hear me use them smiley - winkeye

I'd have to think about words & phrases I don't use - I like to use Youth Speak which has just gone out of fashion to annoy my daughtes, but that's a whole other story.


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 53

Edward the Bonobo - Gone.

I keep asking my children's friends if they're one of these hoodies I've been warned about. smiley - smiley


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 54

Sol

Dr Spock uses the pronoun 'he' even when it is clear he is talking about a female baby. It's quite disconcerting, but I make allowances for the age.

I suppose using 'they' would be seen as too impersonal for babies. But then using 'she' instead is both twee and bloddy minded, since it not only depersonalises but also ignores half the population of babies completely.


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 55

Sho - employed again!

it's easy in German. Das Kind. They call them "it".


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 56

Sho - employed again!

I don't mind he or she for babies (or generalisations) as long as it's consistent. if I'm the writer I tend to use s/he. smiley - smiley


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 57

Secretly Not Here Any More

They say lol... Out loud? Wow.


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 58

Gnomon - time to move on

My daughters say "lol" as well, but only in an ironic way.


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 59

Sol

ell oh ell or actually lol?


Out of our Ideolect.

Post 60

Gnomon - time to move on

Actually lol.


Key: Complain about this post