A Conversation for Ask h2g2

help settle an argument

Post 21

Gnomon - time to move on

It looks brown to me.

Green/brown colour blindness is very common, affecting about 1 in 10 of males and 1 in 100 of females. Many people are amazed when they find out that the reason they've been arguing about colour all these years is the fact that they really are colour blind.


help settle an argument

Post 22

AEndr, The Mad Hatter

green (browny green)


help settle an argument

Post 23

Seamus...the forbidden


Red 109
Green 93
Blue 70

But shirts are dyed with pigment, and green is not primary in pigment, yellow is. So with pigments I think we would get something like...

Red 45%
Yellow 20%
Blue 35%

Now blue and yellow make green, and green and red make brown, but there's 10% more green than red which gives greenish brown, and, surprise, surprise, that's what it looks like to me.

Seamussmiley - artist


help settle an argument

Post 24

Queeglesproggit - Keeper of the evil Thingite Avon Lady Army and Mary Poppins's bag of darkness..

it's bloody brown, and a reddy brown at that smiley - tongueout

I don't think what it's called makes a blind bit of difference, I've got a top called 'aubergine', when it's actually almost lilac smiley - erm

Q
smiley - planet


help settle an argument

Post 25

Coniraya

I say brown, with a yellow hue rather than blue.

I have done the tests and am not colour blind, but it could all be in the monitor. smiley - winkeye


help settle an argument

Post 26

Cloviscat

I'm an art historian, daahlings smiley - winkeye, and I'd say brown, but:

My husband once had a shirt exactly this colour:

Under artificial light it was brown, going to chocolate brown under fluorescent light

Unter natural light it was quite definitely green!

And my baby has a pair of butter-yellow shows that go acid yellow under shop lights....

So, maybe the cloth makers looked at the dyelots by natural light (very likely) when they named the shade, but the picture you see, which has been through how many processes? was photographed under heavy artificial light.

Just call me Sherlock smiley - tongueout

order the shirt, look at it in a variety of lights - then let us know what you think!


help settle an argument

Post 27

Coniraya

Or it could have been named for the colour of thyme stems, which are definitely brown at this time of year. smiley - winkeye


help settle an argument

Post 28

egon

it looks khaki to me.

Clothes shopping, Nyssa?


help settle an argument

Post 29

Stephen

Everyones eyes are different; if it looks green to you then, to you, it is. Whatever scientific analysis says!

Looks green to me too but I'm constantly having arguements about what colour is what.


help settle an argument

Post 30

Just Justin... (ACE)

it looks like a cross between poo brown and khaki...
*apologies for being so graphic* smiley - silly
J.J


help settle an argument

Post 31

AEndr, The Mad Hatter

Sorry, but that "graphic" description isn't really very clear because poo comes in lots of different shades, depending on recent diet and health.

I'm going into the department, so I'll look at the shirt again on a different computer (with rather different colour interpretation) and see what colour I see there.







help settle an argument

Post 32

njan (afh)

I make eleven distinct 'brown's and five greens. I think that means I win. smiley - winkeyesmiley - run


help settle an argument

Post 33

Otto Fisch ("Stop analysing Strava.... and cut your hedge")


This hasn't settled an argument at all! It's just spread it!


help settle an argument

Post 34

Just Bob aka Robert Thompson, plugging my film blog cinemainferno-blog.blogspot.co.uk

I say definitely green, but on the brownish side of green. I can see how some might see brown in it, but it's definitely got a lot of green to it and, in my opinion, more green than brown.
A problem shared may be a problem halved, but an argument shared is an argument quadrupled!


help settle an argument

Post 35

sdotyam

Bob, get your eyes checked! I think you might be colour-blind!


help settle an argument

Post 36

Just Bob aka Robert Thompson, plugging my film blog cinemainferno-blog.blogspot.co.uk

I suppose I will next time I go to the optician, but I don't think so. A few people here seem to agree with me.


help settle an argument

Post 37

Wampus

Cloviscat, I have a shirt that's just the opposite. It's green under flourescent light, and brown under natural light. smiley - huh

As for the shirt in question, I would definitely say it's brown.


help settle an argument

Post 38

Lady in a tree

I say it is green. A sort of khaki green.

What's the score now?


help settle an argument

Post 39

egon

well, I think "khaki"'s got a few votes...


help settle an argument

Post 40

Just Bob aka Robert Thompson, plugging my film blog cinemainferno-blog.blogspot.co.uk

Our family had an argument for years about a vase. We couldn't agree on whether it was green, blue or grey.


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more