A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Different from Wiki?

Post 1

artificialbiology

I'm new here so please be nice, maybe. I didn't feel like doing a search so if you reply with, "STFU, nobb!!!!111!!!!" I'll ignore it.

My questions: how does this differ from Wikipedia and how has the development of Wiki affected this site and its users?


Different from Wiki?

Post 2

Andy

We are not like that on here smiley - smiley

there is a entry on it

http://www.bbc.co.uk/dna/h2g2/alabaster/A918434


Different from Wiki?

Post 3

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

You'll never get a 'STFU noob!' on here. Anybody that went around saying things like that would get pretty short shrift. This is a BBC site don't ya' know! We're right cultured are us lot.


Different from Wiki?

Post 4

artificialbiology

Thank you much!smiley - biggrin


Different from Wiki?

Post 5

Andy

smiley - ermit may sound stupid i have never come accross that term before what dose it mean smiley - erm


Different from Wiki?

Post 6

Edward the Bonobo - Gone.

It's better in some ways than W***pedia in that a single person/ group is responsible for each entry and is entitled (encouraged?) to give things their own quirky slant. Like this one of mine: A4113811

It'd not as good as W***pedia because the process of getting anything published is long and soul destroying.

But on the whole the people are friendly and occasionally intelligent.

Enjoy!


Different from Wiki?

Post 7

LL Waz

There's a section on "The Edited Guide vs Wikipedia" in the community written "What is h2g2's Place in Internet-land?" at A3764063.

If you click on the archive link at the end there's another three articles, if you've got the stamina.

Welcome to h2g2 smiley - smiley.


Different from Wiki?

Post 8

Mu Beta

**puts hand up**

Am I still allowed to be rude?

B


Different from Wiki?

Post 9

artificialbiology

STFU is text language for "shut the 'F' up"

Noob is s term for those who are new or newbies.

And, yeah, you can still be rude. Just don't be surprise if I'm rude back


Different from Wiki?

Post 10

Andy

smiley - ermi see


Different from Wiki?

Post 11

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

'STFU noob' turns up on a lot of other forums, the sort of places with post counts. It's proliferation on Harmony Central stopped me going there.


Different from Wiki?

Post 12

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

Argh! Errant apostrophe.


Different from Wiki?

Post 13

Edward the Bonobo - Gone.

There's all the various forums and conversations on topics ranging from the intelligent to the inane that you can join in. Feel free to click on my 'PS' (personal space) and join in any with interesting titles.

You know - I honestly can't remember how to get to the main 'Forums' or 'Ask' pages. User friendliness is not h2g2's strong suit. smiley - winkeye

Still - you're amongst friends.


Different from Wiki?

Post 14

A Super Furry Animal

If you can't remember how to get to "ask" you can type "ask" into the "Search h2g2" box...and guess what? Top entry! smiley - biggrin

RFsmiley - evilgrin


Different from Wiki?

Post 15

Edward the Bonobo - Gone.

smiley - blush

RTFM, eh? smiley - winkeye

In my defence...one of the principles of user interface design is that users should have, where possible, more than one way to get to where they're going. And you can quote me on that: A3213127

And answer me this: How would a new user get to Ask or Forums? Remember, this user doesn't even know that there are things called Ask or Forums. If you have to rely on someone telling you, can the site be considered usable?


Different from Wiki?

Post 16

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

Front page, right side, two thirds of the way down...smiley - whistle


Different from Wiki?

Post 17

laconian

It took me a *long* time to find my way around the main areas of the site. I think I've found them all now. But the ACEs do a pretty good job of introducing you to the big bits you need to know about.


Different from Wiki?

Post 18

Edward the Bonobo - Gone.

My word! So it is! Right behind the door marked 'Beware of the Leopard'. I feel sooo stupid now! Precisely how users are meant to feel, eh? smiley - winkeye

Some kind of roadmap would be...nice.



Jaysus, thank F it's not a revenue-earning site is all I can say. It would be on a fast road to bankruptcy.


Different from Wiki?

Post 19

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

I think that the problem probably stems from the Guide being the focal point and all the conversations/forums etc. ostensibly being secondary.

Note that I did say *ostensibly* secondary! This would be a frightfully tepid venture without the banter!


Different from Wiki?

Post 20

Edward the Bonobo - Gone.

Well, yes...that's where it *stems* from...


Key: Complain about this post