A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 1

The Groob

Anyone know this? My dictionary is not up to the task.


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 2

Otto Fisch ("Stop analysing Strava.... and cut your hedge")


I don't think it has one, does it?

I thought it translated as "Gods from the machine" and came from Greek drama where the Gods would appear from above and magically fix everything. Sort of unsatisfying, really. Bit like Popeye cartoons - deus ex spinachina....

Otto


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 3

Gnomon - time to move on

But Deus tranlates as God or a God, rather than Gods. So it should be possible to make a plural by changing Deus into its plural form. If it is standard 1st Declension, then it is Dei, but I think Deus might be an exception. The rest of the phrase should stay the same.


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 4

Cheerful Dragon

"Deus ex machina" means "God from the machine" (or a machine. The Romans didn't have 'the' or 'a'.) So the plural would depend on whether you want God or Machine (or both) to be plural. So here goes:

Dei ex machina - Gods from the machine
Deus ex machinis - God from the machines
Dei ex machinis - Gods from the machines

smiley - geeksmiley - dragon


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 5

Madent

The plural of "machina" could be "machinae" if it's used in the nominative form. It becomes "machinis" if the form is ablative, which is quite possible here, since the sense if from a place.

"Deus" definitely becomes "dei" in the nominative plural.

I can't remember all the rules and it's twenty years since I gave up Latin, so I'd go with Cheerful Dragon. She went to a good school smiley - winkeye

(How did it go? "Amo, amas, amat, amamus, amatis, amant ...)


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 6

Otto Fisch ("Stop analysing Strava.... and cut your hedge")


.... remembers a certain scene from the Life of Brian....


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 7

Gnomon - time to move on

"Romanes Eunt Domus" smiley - biggrin


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 8

Beatrice

amo, amas, amatitagain!


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 9

Cheerful Dragon

Madent, amo is a verb, mensa is a noun. You're right about the conjugation of amo, though. Mensa (being feminine) goes:

Mensa (nom), mensam (acc), mensae (gen), mensae (dat) mensa (abl)
Mensae, mensas, mensarum, mensis, mensis.

'ex' takes ablative, meaning from a place.

Yes, I did go to a good school. (How did you know, BTW?) I also have a very good... er... um... Oh, yes, memory. I almost forgot! smiley - winkeye

smiley - geeksmiley - dragon


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 10

Cheerful Dragon

Oops! Mensa should have been machina, but the endings are the same. Mensa was the first noun I learned in Latin... more years ago than I'm prepared to admit!


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 11

a girl called Ben

Hoo tells a fabulous story about a commedian, it could be Barry Cryer, who said he had been to a rugby match where the supporters were so posh they chanted "'ere we go, 'ere we gas, 'ere we gat!" smiley - laugh

B


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 12

The Groob

Thanks for your input on this folks smiley - ok


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 13

BobTheFarmer

*Flashes of -i, -isti, -it, -imus, -istis, -erunt*


And believe it or not, that(apart from a few English word roots) is all I can remember of two years of latin


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 14

IctoanAWEWawi

Was it Jasper Carrot who did the brummie as latin thing? Vaguely remember it having something to do with the 'hark at him' phrase for various pronouns(?) which became
arkatim
arkater
arkatem

Or summats. Any one remember?


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 15

The Groob

I know that many words have latin origins, but is there really any point in teaching latin in schools?


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 16

IctoanAWEWawi

Well, not many do, but I guess if you want to go on to study the classics or work within certain periods of history then knowing the latin language would be a definite requirement. My school stopped it about 5 years before I went there so I never did learn it. My father did, but remembers little and all I know from that really is the nil illegitimus thingy and 'tempus don't half fuggit' (pronounced temp-us fugg-it with hard 'g' smiley - smiley )


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 17

BobTheFarmer

I thought it was a total waste of time, two years compulsory latin, and I cant remember a thing, and even if I did what would be the point?


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 18

Madent

Cheerful Dragon

Our paths have crossed before and when we compared notes we found that while I went to one half of the foundation, you went to the other (but not at the same time)!

Like I said, I gave up Latin and would go with your version cos it seems right smiley - ok

When we did nouns, I remember declining Nom, Voc, Acc, Gen, Dat, Abl and then the same for the plurals.

I must confess, I had watched the Life of Brian the night before I posted smiley - laugh


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 19

Madent

Bob

That's why I gave it up too smiley - ok

Having said that, I can see that studying Latin does give an advantage with modern languages as a lot of modern languages borrow so much from Latin. A consequence of the Roman Empire I'm sure.

It also provides a useful vehicle to teach grammar.


Deus Ex Machina..what's the plural?

Post 20

PQ

I did a whole year of latin (and dropped it and german as soon as possiblelanguages) All I can remember is ego sum canis smiley - erm and sniggering at a story about the slave girl *pleasing* grumio and grumio *pleasing* the slave girlsmiley - laugh

My school was *not* a good school (we made the front page of the Telegraph when I was in 2nd yr for a stabbingsmiley - oksmiley - winkeye and came 2681 of 3571 in the GCSE league tables) - but we did have a good latin teacher (also taught history and was a deputy head and head of sixth form and careers adviser) and we had the option of taking latin during the 3rd yr (instead of doing an extra hour of PE a week) most people did it for a yr and then dropped it when gcse options came up but there were always a few who took it through to a level and they did surprisingly well.


Key: Complain about this post