A Conversation for How to Fake an English Accent in a Chatroom
offensive
Primord Started conversation Jun 22, 2002
actually-I find the comment about Scots people really quite offensive-I suggest that it is dropped.
I don't think anyone of a different nationality should be treated in this way-either in life or on h2g2.
offensive
Jimmy "The Fish" O'Conner Posted Jun 22, 2002
I've considered dropping this line, but have actually recieved some of the best compliments on it. I find it to be quite funny and do not feel it is truly an insult to the Scottish people. I am not a racsist, and do not feel this way personally about any race, and I feel the article makes this quite clear. All I can offer you are my apologies, because unless I recieve a flood of comments saying it should be out, I will keep it.
offensive
Primord Posted Jun 23, 2002
well that is your decision-but I still do not see how anyone can not see this as racism-perhaps
you have not had the type of experience I have had.
offensive
Jimmy "The Fish" O'Conner Posted Jun 23, 2002
The whole peice is of a satirical style. If you take this seriously, then you would have to take the whole thing seriously. Its making fun of stereotypes the whole time, and is a lot rougher on the English than on Scots. The style clearly dictates it as not to be racist, and, though I can see how some MAY take it seriously, I do not personally see it this way, nor does anyone else who has read it.
offensive
Jimmy "The Fish" O'Conner Posted Jun 23, 2002
By the way, I am almost positive that I have not had the experiences you have, but if I had, I believe I still would have included it. Satire is one of the best ways to oppose a problem, and I would have been even rougher still. Read Swift's "Modest Proposal" and see what I mean. This is not biting political satire, but is satirical, none the less.
offensive
Primord Posted Jun 24, 2002
yep-but like I said on the other thread-some people just use that sort of thing as an excuse!
I just don't think your entry needs that line.
Key: Complain about this post
offensive
More Conversations for How to Fake an English Accent in a Chatroom
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."