h2g2 The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy: Earth Edition

I think I bagged Light Fantastic, but then I completely failed to do it, so I suppose I should make it up for grabs again really.

Your choice.

Oooh, I liked the Last Continent, think I might reread that one in the bath later. Still not writing a book review though, they're evil.

It's only a paragraph or two that you could finish in five minutes.

But it's the principle of the thing.

There's only one thing to say to that... !

Rincewind, the inept wizzard who cannot spell [in either sense of the word]has fallen off the disk. Or more precisly, he was falling off the disk, but isn't any more. A completly different prospect.

Rincewind has a spell within him, that has scared all other spell away. Its brothers need it. For the time for the mighty spells of the Octavo has come. But before the big finale - of course the spells are the big finale, big spells have to be big finales - Rincewind encounters Death, the wonders of the silicon chunk, the oldest barbarians on the disk and trolls. Big trolls - but they don't need a big finale.

And your rating out of 5 stars?

Oh. Sorry. ****, because it's a direct sequel and only Feet of Clay gets *****.

But Feet of Clay got 3 stars.

In my personal opinion, and as it's the only one I've reread in the last week, it gets *****.

You can't change the rating! It goes against all precedent!

Unless you want to give Men at Arms the fifth star is so sorely deserves.

That was my personal rating - it does not, in any way shape or form, reflect the views of anyone else.

It's the only one I reread, and I don't know why.

I don't think it's anything special myself.

Neither do I... but I still reread only it.

And that makes it deserving of 5 stars?

Well, if any do to me - which might not to you, or anyone else, it would be one I could reread.

Well I've reread them all (Except Going Postal, A Hat Full of Sky, Strata, Dark Side of the Sun, Good Omens, The Unadulterated Cat, Nanny Ogg's Cookbook and Science of Discworld III. That's quite a bit, actually. ) so that system wouldn't work for me.

Ha! Found it at last!

Can I join?

No.

Thanks, always wanted to join this