A Conversation for The Good Life:The TV series (aka Good Neighbours)

Peer Review: A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 1

DNA lives!

Entry: The Good Life - A2239832
Author: Solongandthanks - U557587

Finally time for a serious one about a show I absolutely ADORE!


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 2

Teasswill

A sound idea, but I think it needs more content.

Was it called 'Good neighbours' anywhere? If not, leave that out, if yes, explain.

Avoid making judgemental statements - better to say something like 'popular with a large proportion of viewers'

You could add more detail about some of the plots, how Tom & Barbara made the scheme work and how Margot & Jerry were involved.

What about the writers, film location, dates, number of episodes, any other peripheral information?

I'm sure you can work this up to be a suitable entry. smiley - goodluck



A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 3

Zarquon's Singing Fish!

Teasswill's right. This needs more. It also needs some structure.

See these examples:

A687945

A272567

or any of these: Search?searchstring=TV+series&searchtype=goosearch&go.x=24&go.y=9&go=Go

smiley - fishsmiley - musicalnote


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 4

Zarquon's Singing Fish!

Oh, that didn't work! Let's try another way:

<./>Search?searchstring=TV+series&searchtype=goosearch&go.x=24&go.y=9&go=Go</.>

smiley - fishsmiley - musicalnote


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 5

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

Very sound advice from Teaswill there smiley - ok

The Good Life was one of my favourite television programmes when it was initially shown, and I still enjoy watching it whenever it's (rarely) shown smiley - biggrin

With entries about TV shows it's usual to have one section listing the main character along with a brief description of each one, and the name of the actor who played them. An episode guide would be good, along with other prime movers in the show - primarily the writers.

In most shows there are one or two episodes or moments which stick in people's minds - in The Good Life I'd say that two of these would be the one where all four of them get drunk and Margot announces to Tom that she has no sense of humour, while Gerry asks Barbara not to do 'that thing' with her hair (whilst the two of them are in the kitchen) because it "brings out the beast in me", and the one where Margot, all dressed in yellow, slips in the mud.

It was called 'Good Neighbours' when shown in the US (usually on PBS).

Here are some edited entries which will give you an idea of what the Editors are looking for in an entry about a sitcom:
Fawlty Towers - A751745
Father Ted - A425783
The Young Ones - A780275
Drop the Dead Donkey - A637887
Porridge - A713882

And one which you need to link to in this entry:
John Esmonde and Bob Larbey - A513578

Some BBC links:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/comedy/guide/articles/g/goodlifethe_7772855.shtml
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sitcom/advocate_goodlife.shtml

smiley - geeksmiley - online2longsmiley - stiffdrinksmiley - hangoversmiley - ok
Scout


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 6

Smij - Formerly Jimster

In my book, this is one of *the* all-time best sitcoms ever. Charming, yet surprisingly subversive and racy at times (in one episode, after Margo's attempts at seducing her husband fail, she roars at him 'Thankyou very much Jerry. That's the last time I play the whore for you!').

'Good Neighbours' was the show's name in its screenings in the USA, to avoid confusion with another, American, show of the same name.

I would imagine this website would be very useful if this entry is to be explanded a little:

http://www.valdefierro.com/neighbors.html


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 7

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

Are you following me around today Jims? smiley - tongueout


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 8

Teasswill

Gosho, BBC2 shows episodes of 'The Good Life' quite often about 6.30pm.
Funny how the same ones keep cropping up - presumably the ones BBC considers the best/most popular.


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 9

Smij - Formerly Jimster

Gosho asked:
>> Are you following me around today Jims? <<

That depends. Look behind you. If you can't see me waving, then I've been following the wrong person smiley - biggrin


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 10

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

*Looks behind, sees no-one waving* ::PHEW::

Last time I saw any TV in the UK it wasn't on - how long have they been showing it on BBC 2? And it never gets shown in the US any more smiley - sadface


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 11

Number Six

Is anyone going to mention Vyvyan's famous rant on 'The Young Ones', or am I going to have to? smiley - smiley

smiley - mod


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 12

McKay The Disorganised

I liked the one where Tom and Barbara rent themselves out to Margot and Jerry as gardeners and housekeepers. Though again there are lots one could pick from - the mere mention of the rant shows what an iconic programme it was.

smiley - cider


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 13

Smij - Formerly Jimster

I think you're going to have to, Six, if only because it's partly (and entirely unjustifiably) responsible for the show's diminished reputation. I've been rewatching it recently and am now a major fan. smiley - cheers

As with any TV-related entry, I'd be willing to pitch in to get this into shape, so long as I wasn't writing it myself, but first... are you still there, Solongandthanks?


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 14

Number Six

Well, in the interests of balance, there is Rik's reply to it...

"If you're going to say anything nasty about Felicity Kendall, you can just about bloomin' well say it to me first. You're talking about the woman I love!"

smiley - mod


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 15

frenchbean

Oh I love the Good Life: second only to Dad's Army smiley - ok

I hope Solongandthanks is still around, cos this *should* be a Guide Entry smiley - smiley

If you are still reading along: nobody's here to slam you, but to help. We all get (and give smiley - winkeye) constructive critisism in PR and it's to make the Entry more readable, more thorough etc... smiley - oksmiley - smiley

smiley - cheers
Fbsmiley - starsmiley - starsmiley - star


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 16

scrumph

Also popular with the Queen, who attended a recording of one of the episodes - sorry don't know which.


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 17

Smij - Formerly Jimster

It was, not surprisingly, the Royal Command Performance episode from the final series. smiley - smiley


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 18

Kerr_Avon - hunting stray apostrophes and gutting poorly parsed sentences

Bagsie me if it goes to FM smiley - winkeye

Meanwhile-

A comment about the (percieved) undertones of wife swapping wouldn't go amiss, along with the classic "it's not got as far as Surbition, but it's already reached Escher [or wherever it was]" quote.

I believe the series also inspired a few attempts at living "The good life", as well.

The series also hit a surprisingly serious and defiant tone at the end, when Tom and Barbara's house is wrecked by vandals, and after a few depressed minutes, they voew to keep on and go dancing in the Ledbetter's pond.

smiley - ale


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 19

Zarquon's Singing Fish!

I like that one too, Jims, plus the one where Margo's Harrod delivered Christmas is cancelled because the tree is six inches too short, they have a home-made Christmas, and get drunk on Tom's home-made (was it pead-pod?) wine!

smiley - fishsmiley - musicalnote


A2239832 - The Good Life

Post 20

frenchbean

Pea pod I think ZSF smiley - laugh That was the one when they made Xmas hats out of newspapers and Margo refused to wear anything but The Times smiley - rofl And Tom was telling her how nice her neck was, when Jerry and Barbara came back into the room: Tom 'shushed', looked conspiratorial and then fell sideways off the sofa smiley - somersault

Wonderful stuff!

Fbsmiley - starsmiley - starsmiley - star


Key: Complain about this post