A Conversation for The Quite Interesting Society

QI - Once more with pictures

Post 121

Vip

Indeed! I never thought we were going to get it!

smiley - fairy


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 122

Malabarista - now with added pony

Good team work. I'll have to see how I divvy up points. smiley - laugh

But that'll have to wait till I get back to my other computer next week. So for extra points, does anyone want to tell me why so many Greek cyclopses are blacksmiths?


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 123

KB

They can shoot beams of heat from the eye to melt metal?


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 124

Malabarista - now with added pony

smiley - laugh Creative, but no.


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 125

KB

smiley - laugh I take it the eye-beams were a later fantasy invention.


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 126

Malabarista - now with added pony

Y'think? smiley - raisedeyebrow


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 127

KB

smiley - shrug


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 128

Malabarista - now with added pony

smiley - laugh


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 129

Br Robyn Hoode - Navo - complete with theme tune

Is it to do with *either* their size *or* something to do with how humans were given fire? Do they have some kind of heirarchichal role with regard to fire which is, of course, necessary for smithing?


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 130

KB

Is it because they've a good eye for detail? smiley - run


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 131

Taff Agent of kaos

because humans are forward facing bi-focal(2 eyes at the front) we have good distance vision, for closer work we focus with one or the other eye turning our heads as we do this, like blacksmiths would, so cyclopi having one eye at the front would have very bad depth and distance perception, and being giants would be very strong, thus making them ideal blacksmiths

smiley - bat


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 132

toybox

It is a trade which runs in the family, and they are all related to each other?

Because it was standard Greek stereotyping at the time (like 'all Portuguese are masons')?

Because they were friends of (or, better still, created by) Hephaistos?

Well done btw Taff smiley - batsmiley - applause


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 133

A Super Furry Animal

Were they the children of Vulcan?

RFsmiley - evilgrin


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 134

KB

Are they all named Smith?


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 135

~ jwf ~ scribblo ergo sum

Were they all black?


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 136

gandalfstwin OGGMSTKMBGSUIKWIATA

This has to have some connection to Promethius, who first gave humans fire, according to legend.......

Was Promethius a cyclops????

If so, then all cyclops were related to Promethius, and as punishment, had to serve humans as Blaksmiths.....

smiley - erm
smiley - wizard
GT


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 137

toybox

Prometheus was a titan if my memory serves.


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 138

Malabarista - now with added pony

Not quite, though Taff is closest - but still far off.


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 139

Taff Agent of kaos

like odin they gave up an eye, in this case for the knowledge of metalworking hense they are all smiths

smiley - bat


QI - Once more with pictures

Post 140

toybox

Because blacksmithing is an activity which requires only dedication, which can be symbolised by a single eye?

smiley - erm


Key: Complain about this post