A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 301

Amy: ear-deep in novels, poetics, and historical documents.

But that could just be me. My throat is sore and I feel of poo. Going to doctor's in a bit... I bet you anything they shrug at me and tell me to get more sleep. smiley - cross


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 302

Saturnine

Or that its a virus.

That's why I don't go to see doctors.


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 303

Amy: ear-deep in novels, poetics, and historical documents.

I'm something of a hypochrondriac... but when I see spots on my tonsils... I know I'm not imagining things. smiley - erm So I go - but normally I'll wait it out and hope I get better within a week or so. I'm just sick of being sick (I was ill the entirety of last semester) and it's making me moody. smiley - erm

*thus driving the thread totally off topic*

smiley - winkeye


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 304

Saturnine

Ah, just go. Will at least ease your mind!


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 305

Amy: ear-deep in novels, poetics, and historical documents.

Going, going... smiley - tongueout


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 306

Saturnine

...gone?


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 307

Amy: ear-deep in novels, poetics, and historical documents.

You wish. smiley - winkeye Appointment's not for another 30 minutes.


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 308

Saturnine

Ok. So...um...what shall we talk about now?


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 309

Amy: ear-deep in novels, poetics, and historical documents.

I... have no idea. Wait for someone else to come by with some angry opinions perhaps?


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 310

Saturnine

Hmm. Well. That's boring.

I wonder how many people take their resentments outside of threads? smiley - erm


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 311

Amy: ear-deep in novels, poetics, and historical documents.

Probably a lot. I wonder how many people really and truly get worked up over all this. smiley - erm


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 312

Saturnine

I get worked up, but that's not a bad thing in itself. But I try not to take stuff outside the thread. Hence why I always make a point of not wanting to offend people.

However, some researchers *are* on my black list simply for their undesirable attitudes. But that's the same with anything in Life.


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 313

RMF Art Vandelay: Missing- Presumed Fed[Hero], Join DISF at A925391!

Like being an unimaginative bore?


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 314

Saturnine

Oh, you didn't take that seriously did you?


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 315

RMF Art Vandelay: Missing- Presumed Fed[Hero], Join DISF at A925391!

smiley - nahnah

I rarely take any attack of my personality online seriously.


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 316

Little Mischief

This has been an interesting and thought-provoking conversation that has taken me awhile to catch up with. That said, there have been a few points raised that I would like to comment on. Please bear with me, I've just read the thread in it's entirety.

On the initial subject: bashing Christianity. I wouldn't say that it's "trendy" to do so much as it is human nature to defend one's position from perceived attack. Most people do not easily accept criticism of something so deeply personal to them, leading to the reception of any negative comments as bashing. Perhaps Christians would do better to take the high road and turn the other cheek. You cannot control how others think or what they have to say about your chosen lifestyle, but you can control your own reactions. "I only know that I can change, everything else just stays the same."

In post 188 kea said (in reference to conformity of the Christian religion) "its not whim based and has a lot of support from the church as a whole. one of the high profile anglican bishops in nz is a woman. if chritianity had never been revised she wouldn't be in that position"

So as a result of equal rights movements it was decided that after a few hundred years it would be perfectly okay for women to join the clergy even though it had been previously unheard of. Granted society has changed in the past few hundred years, but what fundamental part of the word of God had changed that suddenly made it okay for previously banned women to then join the clergy?

Consider this (not necessarily) hypothetical situation:
In the next hundred years the popularity of the Christian church will dwindle to an almost miniscule following. For fear of the religion dying out altogether the church decides that perhaps premarital sex isn't the demon it was once thought, so it's suddenly okay to have sexual relations outside of marriage with intent to conceive for the purpose of propogating the tradition of Christianity. For that matter, if a married couple are unable to conceive after years of attempting to do so, in this special circumstance it will even be okay for either partner to go outside of their marriage to attempt to conceive.

These decisions have not been made by a high-ranking church official on a whim, but have the full backing of the majority of the church for the purpose of it's continued existence. Thoughts?

In post 202 Amy said "Overall I think it's what is held in common that's more important, especially among the non-cultist denominations."

But exatly how much is held in common? Given all the denominations and sub-denominations of Christianity what basic principles define them all as Christian? If Christians can't agree on what it is to be Christian, how can they possibly expect to be taken seriously by others *in the respect of their chosen faith*? And if Christian A has so little in common with Christian B aside from a basic belief that there is a God, why not identify with denomination (since that's what makes all the difference) instead of the "blanket" identity of Christianity?

And (finally! smiley - winkeye) in post 248 RMF said "I don't Like atheist who campaign Anti-religion, it is why people despise us a lot more than they should"

Turnabout is fair play. I don't like *anyone* who feels it's their right to intrude upon my time with their propaganda, regardless of what they're in favor of or against. But if Christians feel it's their duty to stand on street corners or in shopping malls and "witness", and if Jehova's Witnesses feel it's their duty to knock on a door and interrupt someone's otherwise peaceful day to share their views, then I don't see why Athiests shouldn't be able to do the same thing. I daresay a majority of them wouldn't be bothered, but it's their right all the same. I can tell them to take a hike just as easily as I can tell anyone else the same thing.


Sorry for the obscene length of my responses.

Cheers!


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 317

RMF Art Vandelay: Missing- Presumed Fed[Hero], Join DISF at A925391!

"And (finally! winkeye ) in post 248 RMF said "I don't Like atheist who campaign Anti-religion, it is why people despise us a lot more than they should"

Turnabout is fair play. I don't like *anyone* who feels it's their right to intrude upon my time with their propaganda, regardless of what they're in favor of or against. But if Christians feel it's their duty to stand on street corners or in shopping malls and "witness", and if Jehova's Witnesses feel it's their duty to knock on a door and interrupt someone's otherwise peaceful day to share their views, then I don't see why Athiests shouldn't be able to do the same thing. I daresay a majority of them wouldn't be bothered, but it's their right all the same. I can tell them to take a hike just as easily as I can tell anyone else the same thing."

Yes but the problem with Campagining atheists is that people don't ignore them Like they do Jahovas Witnesses or Mormons because Atheists tend not to do the same things, such as going door to door. They get noticed and usually are succesful in Imposing their will on other people. Like bout a year ago, that one man who got invoulentary stating of the national anthem because he "claimed"(it was later found out this wasn't true) that his daughter was having religion pushed on her. I have never been threatned by the words "Under god"

*Its ok if you went a bit long, we encourage people to state their opinions smiley - ok*


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 318

DA ; Simply Vicky: Don't get pithy with me!

Ah, what do I mean? I was just being flippant...I was thinking of 'Wolfram and Hart' (if you know Angel...)


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 319

DA ; Simply Vicky: Don't get pithy with me!

Amy, it's good that he knows how to think for himself...smiley - hug


Is it trendy to bash Christianity?

Post 320

Saturnine

RMF - So it's not OK, because people are listening to what they have to say?

Sounds a little jealous, and more than a little odd.

In fact, I am confused. Am I wrong in being reminded of the Section 28 thing in this country, where speaking about being gay is forbidden in schools because it would be "promoting" homosexuality?

If people want to set up an Anti-religion organisation, that's up to them. I certainly don't think they are doing any damage. Doesn't sound like they are exhibiting the same behaviour as a lot of Chrisitians. Just sounds like they are saying something that people are interested in listening to.


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more