A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Why does this work?

Post 1

Cheerful Dragon

My husband has just phoned with an odd question. Apparently, if you fill some clear plastic bag with water and hang them round a room, it will keep flies away. One of his colleagues saw this being done at a butcher's. When the butcher was asked why he did it, the butcher said he was given the tip when he went to Portugal. It does work - there were no flies in the butcher's shop. The question is, why (or how) does it work?


Why does this work?

Post 2

Xanatic

Hmm, I´ll have to try that. Maybe they´re afraid of water? I really can´t come up with anything better.


Why does this work?

Post 3

Mikey the Humming Mouse - A3938628 Learn More About the Edited Guide!

Maybe it raises the humidity in the room?

-- mikey


Why does this work?

Post 4

Xanatic

I thought about that one as well, but it doesn´t seem to affect them usually.


Why does this work?

Post 5

Elfkin [181711]

Maybe they're like cats and they don't like their own reflection? smiley - winkeye


Why does this work?

Post 6

Mikey the Humming Mouse - A3938628 Learn More About the Edited Guide!

One of my smiley - cat adores looking at her reflection in the mirror -- she'll sit there and talk to the mirror like a toddler does.

smiley - smiley
Mikey


Why does this work?

Post 7

Blatherskite the Mugwump - Bandwidth Bandit

Maybe they think that someone in the room has a serious illness, and they stay away to avoid contracting it. Since they are unfamiliar with the human concept of insanity, they probably don't have any other hypothesis for why someone would deliberately hang up water.


Why does this work?

Post 8

Ommigosh

I reckon that they fly off in search of missing goldfish.





smiley - smiley


Why does this work?

Post 9

Mikey the Humming Mouse - A3938628 Learn More About the Edited Guide!

I did a quick websearch, and one website claimed that the ways in which light reflected off of the hanging bag of water (which is probably moving slightly), freaks out the flies because it makes it look like there's a lot more movement going on in the area than there really is.

Who knows....

smiley - aliensmile
Mikey


Why does this work?

Post 10

Clelba

that sounds most like it to me
^. .^
= ' =


Why does this work?

Post 11

I'm not really here

Bottles of water around the garden are supposed to help keep cats and even dogs away, so I suppose it's the same thing.


Key: Complain about this post