A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Up the Pole(s)

Post 5721

You can call me TC

That's the point I was trying to make. Perhaps I pronounced it wrong.

Can anyone recommend a recording of dialects - just out of interest? Preferably a funny one.


Up the Pole(s)

Post 5722

Gnomon - time to move on

and most of us think you are kidding half the time.


Up the Pole(s)

Post 5723

Munchkin

Well you asked for it http://www.bbc.co.uk/scotland/entertainment/chewinthefat/neds/neducation.shtml the always funny Chewing the Fat and their take on the West of Scotland dialect.


Up the Pole(s)

Post 5724

You can call me TC

Gnomon - you overestimate me. I'm not clever enough to kid you lot.


Up the Pole(s)

Post 5725

Gnomon - time to move on

Sorry, TC. My remark about kidding was aimed at jwf. It was in reply to something he said in his posting.


Up the Pole(s)

Post 5726

You can call me TC

smiley - puff (relief)

smiley - biggrin


Up the Pole(s)

Post 5727

typolifi

Here's a quite accurate index to languages of the world. Not actually funny, though:
http://www.ethnologue.com/country_index.asp


Up the Pole(s)

Post 5728

Gnomon - time to move on

I remember hearing that Europe (with all its different languages) has the least language diversity of any of the continents. Except Antarctica, of course. The American Indians, for example, had over 500 different languages and I believe the was a similar diversity in Australia.


My father's duaghter

Post 5729

Wand'rin star

For me father is pronounced the same as farther - about as long a vowel as you can get

Darling Pa, the jar of lard in the larder will guard against the haar if you are going farther than the end of the rather hard tarmac in that car. See you after for darts in the bar. smiley - star


My father's duaghter

Post 5730

You can call me TC

'ow's yer father, argy-bargy - what a palarver.

This is fun smiley - smiley


My father's duaghter

Post 5731

Teasswill

Father Christmas? Bah, humbug!


My father's duaghter

Post 5732

Gnomon - time to move on

jwf, the distinction between long and short vowels existed in Old English (ANglo-Saxon). The long vowels were pronounced with almost the same sounds as the short ones, but for a longer time. Then came the great vowel shift. THe sounds all changed and the long/short distinction became one of sound rather than duration, but for some reason linguists continued to use the names long and short.

So we have the short vowels as in pat, pet, pit, pot and put. The long vowels would by the same scheme be pate, pete, pine, pole and pool. But there are lots of other vowels in English, some of them long and some of them short. The a in father is not pronounced the same as the a in pat in the UK or Ireland. The a in father is long. The words b
pat and path have a short and a long a respectively in UK/Irish pronunciation, but I believe that they are pronounced the same in some American dialects. I can't speak for Canadian.


My father's duaghter

Post 5733

typolifi

Gnomon, it is perfectly true that Europe is the continent with the less live dialects. I find two reasons to account for it: it's by very far the smallest continent and it has a long history of 'nation-states', trying to unite their citizens by spreading the use of one standard version of their language.
Wandrin'star: Poles do indeed tend to learn English eagerly, though no more than in many pther countries, but certainly the French side of me must have spoilt it. smiley - winkeye


My father's duaghter

Post 5734

plaguesville

Yeah.

That's the French for you.
smiley - bigeyes


My father's duaghter

Post 5735

plaguesville

Gnomon,

"The words pat and path have a short and a long a respectively in UK/Irish pronunciation"

In Northwest England (possibly excluding Scouseland) the a in "pat" is indistinguishable from the one in "path".


Eastern European States

Post 5736

Stealth "Jack" Azathoth

It's my understandng that German is now favoured in Eatern Europe with coming of EU expansionist policy...


Eastern European States

Post 5737

Wand'rin star

My lengthy experience in Poland and Bulgaria would suggest otherwise. My German is infinitely better than my Polish, but conversations in both Gdansk and Szczecin(on the German border) went:
WS:Sprechen sie Deutsch? Pole: Nein
I got canny and switched to :
WS Do you speak English? Pole:Zprochem, WS:Perhaps Deutsch? Pole:Ja,naturlich.
In Bulgaria I actually taught some of the time in German, but outside the classroom nobody "understood" it. Did better with miming and the words for "Sorry, I don't speak Bulgarian, I'm English"WWII casts a long shadow smiley - star


Long term residents

Post 5738

Wand'rin star

may be interested to know that the web page referred to in 5723 mentions 'dugs baws' in the introduction. Is one of you responsible for it under an assumed name? smiley - star


Long term residents

Post 5739

Teasswill

It may be true that there are less dialects on the continent, but they do exist. Some German friends of ours have commented how folk in Northernmost Germany are relatively unintelligible to those in Bavaria.


Long term residents

Post 5740

Gnomon - time to move on

The Irish language, Gaelic, has three main dialects. These use entirely different vocabulary as well as pronunciation although the grammar is almost exactly the same.


Key: Complain about this post