A Conversation for The h2g2 Doctor Who Group

Dr Who.

Post 321

Orcus

>Then I can find out in what context "Are you my mummy?" caused such hilarity.<

Yes I'm wondering that too and I *did* watch it. I must have popped out of the room for that crucial second. smiley - erm

Who did say it and in what context?


Dr Who.

Post 322

Just Bob aka Robert Thompson, plugging my film blog cinemainferno-blog.blogspot.co.uk

*SLIGHT SPOILER WARNING*

The UNIT fellas and the Doctor go out into the gas, wearing gas masks. The Doctor says "Are you my mummy?", referencing the episode in the first season with the scary boy in a 'gas mask' who went around saying this.
For what it's worth, the UNIT leader's response is "Could you please be serious?!" or something along those lines.


Dr Who.

Post 323

Orcus

Oh, passed me by that one then. smiley - sorry


Dr Who.

Post 324

Orcus

Actually to be fair, I only vaguely recall that one, I might have missed chunks of it so it's perhaps not surprising I didn't get it.


Dr Who.

Post 325

Bright Blue Shorts

If you missed Saturday's episode, you'll be wanting to go here ...
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/page/item/b00b563l.shtml?src=ip_mp


Dr Who.

Post 326

Mister Matty

>Quibblewise ... I noticed that when the Sontaran troops started marching around they are of different heights. Would you expect that with a clone race?

Has it ever been established that they're all clones of the same single Sontaran or that cloning is their way of reproducing? I'd assumed the latter since they clearly don't all look the same.


Dr Who.

Post 327

NPY

Think I read that it's their way of reproducing. Dunno where it started though. They may be clones of one original or a genetically engineered race. Not sure. But think it's definately a reproduction thing.

The "Are you my mummy?" bit was funny. If you haven't seen it, watch it.


Dr Who.

Post 328

A Super Furry Animal

>> Has it ever been established that they're all clones of the same single Sontaran or that cloning is their way of reproducing? I'd assumed the latter since they clearly don't all look the same. <<

In the first part, didn't the smiley - doctor say "you all look the same to me" to chief Sontaran, who riposted with "funny, that's what we say about you"?

RFsmiley - evilgrin


Dr Who.

Post 329

Mu Beta

"Quibblewise ... I noticed that when the Sontaran troops started marching around they are of different heights. Would you expect that with a clone race?"

Yes, you would. Genetic clones would still show environmental variation.

Although, I'm not sure how large a part 'real' science plays in a series where scary stone men inhabit quantum time and muck about with Heisenberg's uncertainty principle.

B


Dr Who.

Post 330

NPY

Well that's the joy of scui-fi. real science can be an influence, but it's not real and you can let it go.


Dr Who.

Post 331

Andy

Are you my mummy

It was reference to The emptychild

http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/episodes/2005/emptychild.shtml


Dr Who.

Post 332

NPY

Was quite a scary episode in a way.


Dr Who.

Post 333

STRANGELY STRANGE ( A brain on a spring )

Actually they are clones in more ways than one. The actress who plays Martha was interviewed last week and said there are only actually around 10 Sultanas and the rest are computer generated copies. I am not greatly overkeen on her as Martha in Who, however she seemed a really pleasant, unasuming person in real life in the interview.


Dr Who.

Post 334

NPY

yeah she does seem really qwuite down to earth in interviews I've seen too.


Dr Who.

Post 335

Secretly Not Here Any More

I was just thinking (I know, dangerous) as I went to work. People on different fora seem to think that all the clone worlds, whatever are the key to the big series finale.

What if they're not? What if we all missed the clue? Like with last series' The Shakespeare Code, I think an important plot point was revealed in the historical episode. TSC had the whole "words = power" bit, thus explaining how millions of people shouting "Doctor" healed The Doctor.

I think that Fires of Pompeii had another clue. "What if Pompeii wasn't a fixed moment in history? What if I killed them?" Meaning that theoretically, the Doc could've saved the people of Pompeii. Well, what if sacrificing the Time Lords to win the war wasn't a fixed moment? What if the Doctor killed them? Maybe he just can't cross his own timeline to save them. Or maybe he can - maybe he crosses his timeline, meets his daughter and it all starts to make sense?

I'm probably wrong, but it's a theory nonetheless.


Dr Who.

Post 336

Giford

I'm still hung up on the soothsayer saying 'there is something on your back'. smiley - huh

Gif smiley - geek


Dr Who.

Post 337

Bright Blue Shorts

"Like with last series' The Shakespeare Code, I think an important plot point was revealed in the historical episode. TSC had the whole "words = power" bit, thus explaining how millions of people shouting "Doctor" healed The Doctor."

Have the producers actually stated that this was part of the storyarc for the season? Or is it just interpretation on the part of viewers?


Dr Who.

Post 338

Giford

btw, has anyone found any websites for the new Season, like the Torchwood House website from a couple of years ago?

Gif smiley - geek


Dr Who.

Post 339

Secretly Not Here Any More

I've never read anything from the producers. I just look at what's on the TV.


Dr Who.

Post 340

Just Bob aka Robert Thompson, plugging my film blog cinemainferno-blog.blogspot.co.uk

I don't think the Shadow Proclamation would have a website.

Maybe a W*k*pedia page, though...


Key: Complain about this post