A Conversation for h2g2 University Project: Forgotten Heroines

Peer Review comments-Caroline Chisholm

Post 1

Azara

This is a very interesting entry! smiley - applause

I think it would be worth including here that Caroline Chisholm is generally considered to be the model for Mrs Jellyby in Dickens' Bleak House.

One small point:
"Archibald's grandparents were Scottish and were educated landowners. However, they had lost their money and land due to politics." "Due to politics" is supiciously vague--were they by any chance Highlanders involved in the 1745 rebellion? I think it would be worth pinning down that point.

smiley - cheers
Azara
smiley - rose


Peer Review comments-Caroline Chisholm

Post 2

echomikeromeo

Hey Azarasmiley - smiley

I hope the author won't mind if I go ahead and deal with these points.

I added in the bit about Bleak House in a footnote. I'm not sure about whether Archibald's family was directly involved in the 1745 rebellion, but, being a Highland family, they would have been impacted by the Highland Clearances of the 17th and 18th centuries, so I'll put that in.


Peer Review comments-Caroline Chisholm

Post 3

echomikeromeo

Oops - I meant 18th and 19th centuries.


Peer Review comments-Caroline Chisholm

Post 4

Sea Change

Successful use of a colon! I am so easily amused sometimes. smiley - biggrin

The second use looks fine, but would perhaps be a bit more readable if it were "concessions. She" instead.


Peer Review comments-Caroline Chisholm

Post 5

echomikeromeo

I'm particularly glad you like it, Sea Change, as I pride myself on my good grammar. The second use has been changed.


Peer Review comments-Caroline Chisholm

Post 6

U168592

I'm sure the author will be happy you deal with the points too emr smiley - winkeye

I'll drag her online at some point smiley - tongueout

MJ


Peer Review comments-Caroline Chisholm

Post 7

Calliopes_Sleepy Face

He dragged me online.

Azara thanks for the interesting point about Mrs Jellyby. I am actually watching the BBC incarnation of Bleak House at the moment and enjoying it, so that is an interesting note.

I am also unsure about Archibald's grandparents. Unfortunately information about Archibald is annoying vague and I had little reference material to work from.

I am so glad that Echomikeromeo has edited these pieces, I am sure she will have noticed that my spelling and grammar is atrocious! So many thanks to her! And also thanks to her for responding in my absence!

Thanks for the comments!

smiley - fishsmiley - hsif


Peer Review comments-Caroline Chisholm

Post 8

Calliopes_Sleepy Face

EMR

One little thing I have just noticed. Maybe I am just being picky but the Caroline Chisholm School in Northampton is listed on the side as 'a school in Northampton'.

I feel this should be given its correct name in this referenced links part. I believe it can be done like this a school in Northampton

Thanks

smiley - fishsmiley - hsif


Peer Review comments-Caroline Chisholm

Post 9

echomikeromeo

Oops! And me who's so careful about TITLE tags, too!

Fixed.


Thread Moved

Post 10

h2g2 auto-messages

Editorial Note: This conversation has been moved from 'Caroline Chisholm - The Emigrants' Friend' to 'h2g2 University Project: Forgotten Heroines'.


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more