A Conversation for Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
Peer Review: A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" Started conversation Sep 18, 2004
Entry: Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection - A377552
Author: John-the-gardener, h2g2 Friends of Tibet - A2170982 - U33262
This is based on a collection of stuff that I've kept for sentimental reasons for quite a long time.
It was more or less written backwards, from the middle bit to the beginning, the end having been tacked on just before the title just so that the whole thing stands upright by itself.
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
Gnomon - time to move on Posted Sep 18, 2004
Interesting. I joined h2g2 only a year after it started and there was no trace of this. The present system of Peer Review hadn't yet been introduced, but you still sent entries to be picked. (One of mine got picked in only 23 hours!)
I suspect that this entry will never be picked. It is about h2g2, rather than about Earth. The Post might be interested it.
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" Posted Sep 18, 2004
In the beginning, the idea was that the thrill of having written something should be enough, but, in case it wasn't, you could submit something to be rejected. In practical terms, it doesn't make much difference, of course, since to fail at being rejected is the same as succeeding. The joke soon wore thin, it was felt, and the terminology changed.
I take your point about this being more about h2g2 than about the stuff that isn't h2g2. I hadn't thought about that... not enough, anyway.
Thanks for the comments.
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
J Posted Sep 18, 2004
Hi there
Let’s see.
There’s sort of a precedent for this kind of thing. Spiff wrote an entry on h2g2 footnotes that was accepted, so there’s a precedent for writing about the EG in the EG. Gnomon here recently made a small self-reference in an entry on Blackbirds this week (in a footnote, as I recall). I think you'll have to get italic approval to keep this in PR.
They’ll never let you link to U-spaces by the way... They wouldn’t let someone link to U42 in reference to DNA.
Having said this, I enjoyed this. I read this stuff a while back, when it was more or less just your responses. Very funny
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" Posted Sep 18, 2004
Thanks, Jodan. I hadn't thought about the U links either. To think that I used to do this for a living...
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" Posted Sep 18, 2004
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" Posted Sep 18, 2004
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
Tonsil Revenge (PG) Posted Sep 18, 2004
You want me to showcase it in it's own CAC?
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
Tonsil Revenge (PG) Posted Sep 18, 2004
Actually, on second thought, I think this entry and any others like it ought to be shelved in the Guide under the rubric of Reminiscence.
The time might come when those who were here at the beginning might be no longer with us and I think it would be a sin for people to think that this site just popped into existence.
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" Posted Sep 19, 2004
Any others like it?
The time will certainly come when those of us here now are no longer here. Even h2g2 came from somewhere, just like everything else. Where it came from makes it special.
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
J Posted Sep 19, 2004
How morbid.
(For me at least... I'm not leaving until I die...)
It's nice to see a senior h2g2'er to show it's possible to hang on that long
Also nice to see it was different some time ago. Gives me hope for the future.
Anyway, thanks. I should sleep...
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" Posted Sep 19, 2004
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" Posted Sep 19, 2004
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
Tonsil Revenge (PG) Posted Sep 19, 2004
Central US
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" Posted Sep 20, 2004
So your an hour behind EDT?
A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" Posted Sep 20, 2004
Key: Complain about this post
Peer Review: A377552 - Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
- 1: John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" (Sep 18, 2004)
- 2: Gnomon - time to move on (Sep 18, 2004)
- 3: John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" (Sep 18, 2004)
- 4: J (Sep 18, 2004)
- 5: J (Sep 18, 2004)
- 6: John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" (Sep 18, 2004)
- 7: J (Sep 18, 2004)
- 8: John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" (Sep 18, 2004)
- 9: J (Sep 18, 2004)
- 10: John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" (Sep 18, 2004)
- 11: Tonsil Revenge (PG) (Sep 18, 2004)
- 12: Tonsil Revenge (PG) (Sep 18, 2004)
- 13: John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" (Sep 19, 2004)
- 14: J (Sep 19, 2004)
- 15: John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" (Sep 19, 2004)
- 16: Tonsil Revenge (PG) (Sep 19, 2004)
- 17: John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" (Sep 19, 2004)
- 18: Tonsil Revenge (PG) (Sep 19, 2004)
- 19: John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" (Sep 20, 2004)
- 20: John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!" (Sep 20, 2004)
More Conversations for Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."