A Conversation for Sub-editing and the Lost Art of Rejection

Sigh...

Post 1

John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!"

Ah, those were the days... Ah remember when all this were nowt but fields... wennaworralad.


Sigh...

Post 2

Grimethorpe2k1


smiley - biggrin A great bit of cruel humour in its own right. But what do I no? I'm just zis unelevated guy, y'know?

Grime (just visiting).............smiley - whistle


Sigh...

Post 3

John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!"

Hurray! My first visitor.smiley - magic Oh, how I miss composing rejection comments... is there a smiley for wistful...? smiley - spider Can't find one.

JTG


Sigh...

Post 4

Grimethorpe2k1


Congratulations! A visitor well deserved. Pity it was just me though smiley - whistle

Grime smiley - smiley


Sigh...

Post 5

John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!"

Not at all. There are those who might stop by and fail to appreciate my humble attempt to make rejection fun.smiley - erm

Rejection comments were a popular topic at one point. It's been a bit of a disappointment that so few have taken an interest in these. Now, of course, they are just historical curios... if not actual rubbish. But I had such fun composing them, it seems a shame to throw them away.

I suspect that very few, if any, of these actually made it back to the Researchers they were addressed to. The one about 'mostly harmless' and the thinking-cap/racing-helmet was posted on the Sub-eds' news group, with a note attached saying that it was a giggle, but wouldn't/couldn't/shouldn't appear in the official rejection email.smiley - whistlesmiley - moon

JTG


Sigh...

Post 6

Grimethorpe2k1


Glad to hear it, really - just in case I decide to write something suitable for editing ! But they were all fun to read...smiley - biggrin

Grime smiley - ok


Sigh...

Post 7

John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!"

Thanks. smiley - biggrin Not to worry. We don't reject anything, anymore. The moderators free us from concern about seeing naughty words, and Peer Review ensures that everything that falls into a Sub-editors in-tray is wonderful to the Nth degree already smiley - laugh. So editing is simply a matter of sprinkling on the fairy dust frosting and sending it off to join the queue.smiley - wah

JTG


Sigh...

Post 8

Grimethorpe2k1


Bet it were all different wennuworrasaladsmiley - smiley

But The End of the Peer Review seems to be more an End of the Peer Ordeal sometimes smiley - yikessmiley - sadface, what with the Sin Bin an' stuffsmiley - yuk. Still, nobody ever said it would be easy in show business! smiley - smiley

Grime


Sigh...

Post 9

John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!"

In them days, they lettuce toss the badduns.smiley - tomato

Having been subjected to the ordeal of friendly and constuctive criticism, some are less than thrilled smiley - loveblush about having more changes imposed on them.smiley - tongueout

JTG


Sigh...

Post 10

Grimethorpe2k1

Tossing the badduns seems more like a spectator sport these days - like throwing Christians to thesmiley - cat lions smiley - cator something. Where will it all end?

At the Restaurant at the End of the Universe I guess. I'll just go and invest me penny...smiley - whistle


Grime smiley - smiley


Sigh...

Post 11

Grimethorpe2k1


Tossing the badduns seems more like a spectator sport these days - like throwing Christians to thesmiley - cat lions smiley - cator something. Where will it all end?

At the Restaurant at the End of the Universe I guess. I'll just go and invest me penny...smiley - whistle


Grime smiley - smiley


Sigh...

Post 12

John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!"

I'll file the extra copy in the archives... not where they kept the bees on the Ark... not the B Ark.smiley - ufo

It's a shame the Roman empire collapsed before the rematch. History would be much more compelling with an account or two of lions smiley - cat being thrown to the Christians. smiley - hsif

... which makes me wonder why more isn't made of the loaves... not as much, admittedly, as it would if I were a baker. "I will make you a baker of men" smiley - wizard has a decidedly sinister ring to it.

JTG

ps No offence meant to my Christian friends.smiley - flyhi


Sigh...

Post 13

Grimethorpe2k1


"It's a shame the Roman empire collapsed before the rematch. History would be much more compelling with an account or two of lions being thrown to the Christians."

LOL smiley - biggrin


Grime smiley - smiley


Sigh...

Post 14

Grimethorpe2k1


Mind you, I found the bit about the loaves a bit smiley - schooloffish fishy...


G. smiley - smiley


Sigh...

Post 15

John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!"

So, why doesn't fish sandwich smiley - burger figure more prominently in Western culture? Are chips an insidious attempt to slip some pre-columbian viewing habits into the channel guide of our collective unconscious? And, if so, by whom?... and why don't we pronounce that "Wom"?smiley - clown

JTG


Sigh...

Post 16

Grimethorpe2k1


JTG - DON'T PANIC !!! smiley - zen

There are far more questions than answers in life. Luckily I've done some research on these particular ones, and here are the answers you're searching for:

(a) Because the Westerners are too busy riding the range and playing Spanish guitars and yodelling and having gunfights. They also herd or rustle cattle instead of fish out on the prairies and they prefer buns because they've never heard of 'chips' and don't like 'fries'.

(b) No, chips are the things that make computers work.

(c) So 'by whom' doesn't arise.

(d) We don't pronounce 'that' as 'wom' because 'it' would be confusing. 'It' is one of the most confusing words in the English Language already, what with 'its' and 'it's' and 'it' is raining - what exactly would be raining if not the rain? And we don't want to make 'it' worse.


Grimesmiley - smiley


Sigh...

Post 17

John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!"

Thanks. That explains a lot... at least in the sense that -- is a lot of explaining. Thanks for the large, friendly letters, too.

I was under the impression that christians smiley - fish were the chaps who flop about, annoying those nice lions smiley - cat; although there is a connection to white shirts and bicycles that, admittedly, I find a bit confusing, theology being something best left to those who keep the telly going late at night.smiley - fullmoon

As for that two letter source of agro, I've resolved to get by without --.

So, the great contribution made to civilization by the Aztecs smiley - wizard was arteriosclerosis? Computers... evolve quickly... because the chaps who design them... eat chips and die young... and are then replaced by new young chaps.smiley - geek I think I've got --.

JTG


Sigh...

Post 18

Grimethorpe2k1


smiley - biggrin Exactly. Couldn't have put it better meself.

He's got it. By George he's got it smiley - weirdsmiley - ok


G.smiley - smiley


Sigh...

Post 19

John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!"

Rex Harrison, eat you heart out.smiley - biggrin


Sigh...

Post 20

John the gardener says, "Free Tibet!"

Sorry. I've just been Subbing an Entry on Italian pronunciation.smiley - cool


Key: Complain about this post