A Conversation for The Quite Interesting Society

QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 141

Argon0 (50 and feeling it - back for a bit)

Just spotted the relevance of the title...

So its not just a flexing of the boards/shape - it changed shape permanently?

So trousers which get stretched become baggy?

At a guess guns rolling backwards and forwards over the deck would compress the wood underneath, forcing it outwards, which would then impinge on other boards, and thus make either the wood warp, or broaden/stretch the entire deck?

Thom Yorke gets stretched becomes taller?

... No...


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 142

Argon0 (50 and feeling it - back for a bit)

Missed this .....

So, the link is...

Things become stretched/misshapen with time/Use?

Chariot Wheels lose shape over time if just left.
Clothes lose shape with wear/use.
Ship Decks change shape with time/use (shrink or stretch? - I suspect shrink actually).
Queasy Lord Mayor - a big guy originally? Stretched his skin by being big, sick so lost weight, then his skin was stretched and didn't "bounce" aback.
Thom Yorke.... Stretched his.... Didn't "bounce" back?


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 143

hygienicdispenser

As per post 138, the link *isn't* "Things become stretched/misshapen with time/Use?", though it is obviously relevant to a lot of the parts.

Still not there with the mayor or Thom Yorke.


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 144

Argon0 (50 and feeling it - back for a bit)

OK, I really don't know where to start with Thom Yorke..... Is it anything to do with singing/song writing/playing instruments, or it is something about him, how he was brought up, his physical presence (or deformities), etc...

Lord Mayor - we've established he got travel sick in a carriage... Why though - not because something stretched? Was there anything odd about that carriage in particular? Was it because it was going over cobbles?


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 145

gandalfstwin OGGMSTKMBGSUIKWIATA

Was the Lord Mayor's carriage a Sedan Chair, by any chance??

smiley - smiley
GT


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 146

hygienicdispenser

Nope. This is just about a recurring problem with horse drawn state coaches. Think about the answers we've already got.


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 147

gandalfstwin OGGMSTKMBGSUIKWIATA

hd!

You said No to Argon0 in post 130 to no suspension, or wooden suspension.

I thought State Horsedrawns used leather suspension....

smiley - erm
GT


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 148

hygienicdispenser

I wasn't saying no to no suspension, I was saying it's nothing to do with suspension. Sorry for the confusion.


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 149

gandalfstwin OGGMSTKMBGSUIKWIATA

Thinking back, I do seem to remember watching State occasions on TV, and the carriages do seem to sway a lot....

smiley - smiley
GT


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 150

Geggs

If the wheels on the carriage were mis-shapen then that could produce something of a rocking motion, and so create a feeling of sea-sickness whilst on dry land, hence the queasiness of the Lord Mayor, I guess.


Geggs


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 151

hygienicdispenser

Geggs - misshapen wheels. Correct +3.


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 152

hygienicdispenser

A summary:

There are six sections:

1) A queasy Lord Mayor - travel sickness due to distortion of coach wheels

2) Something from Homer - Tip up chariot to take weight off wheels to prevent them distorting

3) Thom Yorke - ???

4) Baggy trousers - clothing can become misshapen with time

5) A chore for the goddess Hebe - remove chariot wheels for same reason as (2)

6) HMS Victory - distortion to deck. Why? What's the nautical term?

And tying them together:

7) What is the link? - ???


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 153

Geggs

I know little of Radiohead, or Mr Yorke, but following the logic of the other parts, is some distortion regularly put on his vocals?? Like that Vocoder thing?

Or has his voice deteriorated over time, and is now distorted from it's original sound?


Geggs


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 154

A Super Furry Animal

Didn't Radiohead have an album called The Bends?

RFsmiley - evilgrin


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 155

hygienicdispenser

Radiohead do use distorted guitar quite a bit, but that's not the answer I'm after.

The Bends!! Why on earth didn't I klaxon that? Damn.
(Not The Bends).


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 156

gandalfstwin OGGMSTKMBGSUIKWIATA

Coleridges 'The Ancient Mariner' has suddenly sprung to mind.....


'Water, water everywhere, the very boards did shrink.
Water, water everywhere but nary a drop to drink.......'


smiley - smiley
GT


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 157

hygienicdispenser


The distortion in the Victory that I'm interested in is not due to shrinkage or swelling of the timbers.


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 158

Rod

>>The distortion in the Victory that I'm interested in is not due to shrinkage or swelling of the timbers.<<

'Waney' is my best guess for a long-term distortion from the effects of repeated flexing of the whole vessel.

(but surely you can't rule out completely those things you say should be ruled out?)


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 159

hygienicdispenser

I've not heard of Waney before, so that's not it. The things that I rule out are the things that are not the answer I'm looking for.smiley - biggrin


QI - Sometimes They Don't Come Back

Post 160

Kilted-biker-in-US

A sneaking suspicion that you purposely stayed away from Star Trek, the high speed mode of travel, Warp. In clothing, the woven cloth has two orientations of fibres, Warp and weft. The warp is the one that would stretch to give baggy knees to a schoolteacher's trouserlegs. Timber does warp after repeated soaking and drying. And Radiohead music ... say no more.


Key: Complain about this post