A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 1

Clive the flying ostrich: Amateur Polymath | Chief Heretic.

I've just been reading the comments on the BBC webpage for the story relating to the identification of the remains of King Richard III: the last Plantagenet King of England.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leicestershire-21063882

Now that we've dug 'im up, should he get a state funeral and a spot in Westminster Abbey? - he is a royalty after all

Discuss.


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 2

Alfster

Should Richard III get a state funeral? Nah, he's still got the hump about being buried under a car park in Leicester.


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 3

paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant

It's a tricky business, figuring out where to plant a Plantagenet.smiley - tongueout


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 4

Mr. Dreadful - But really I'm not actually your friend, but I am...

A hearse! A hearse! My kingdom for a hearse!


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 5

~ jwf ~ scribblo ergo sum

smiley - rofl

smiley - ok
~jwf~


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 6

swl

Incidentally, did they find a horse?


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 7

paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant

"Incidentally, did they find a horse?"

Why? Is one missing?


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 8

U14993989

The entire site including the bones of Richard III was nearly lost to Victorian building development. His feet and lower legs were torn away and obliterated with the sinking of Victorian foundations. It seems that luck played a part in preventing the rest of the skeleton being obliterated.


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 9

Rod

>>A hearse! A hearse! My kingdom for a hearse!<< Mr D

smiley - snork


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 10

Sho - employed again!

I think they should have him interred in Yorkshire where he belongs.


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 11

U14993989

I think after they have finished all of the analysis, preserved his DNA for future cloning, and digitally recreated his face and body after processing the CT scan data, they should
a) build a "Richard III" museum over the car park
b) his bones should be returned to the site and be the centre piece of the museum.
c) build a theme park next to the museum
d) nothing should be sent to london

It will help to create a bit of local commerce away from London, and an attraction for overseas visitors and investors.


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 12

Sho - employed again!

he's staying in Leicester as far as I can tell


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 13

swl

He should be laid to rest beside his wife Anne Neville in Westminster Abbey.


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 14

paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant

smiley - doh

Well, of *course* he should be next to his wife. She's been lonely a *long* time. smiley - senior


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 15

U14993989

>> He should be laid to rest beside his wife Anne Neville in Westminster Abbey <<

Firstly I don't think there is any logical reason to place two sets of 500 year old bones next to each other apart from "convention"
Secondly Anne Nevilles bones could be removed and sent to Leicester as part of my proposed Richard III Museum
Thirdly: I am not sure of the connection between Westminster Abbey and Royalty --> some say Richard III was unfairly overthrown by by the "imposter" Henry Tudor and so shouldn't be placed next to these "usurpers" tudors at Westminister Abbey (assuming that's where they are buried)


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 16

Secretly Not Here Any More

"some say Richard III was unfairly overthrown by by the "imposter" Henry Tudor and so shouldn't be placed next to these "usurpers" tudors at Westminister Abbey"

Not in Lancashire they bloody don't.


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 17

Sho - employed again!

they're wrong. smiley - tongueout

and he should go to York minster...


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 18

U14993989

I forgot to add the add following to my argument
Fourthly: finders keepers losers weepers.


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 19

U14993989

>>Not in Lancashire they bloody don't.<<

Indeed, twas a bloody affair.


Should Richard III get a state funeral?

Post 20

clare

smiley - space
WRONG !! USURPERS ALL !! Boadicea claims Brittania!!

For tea and country, all arise !!

smiley - tea




Key: Complain about this post