A Conversation for Ask h2g2

May 8th. 1945

Post 1

Ancient Brit

Probably the most important day in living history. Recorded as VE Day and celebrated with street parties and dancing in the streets throughout the whole of the Uk. Declared a public holiday.
Why is it no longer celebrated ?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/hi/dates/stories/may/8/newsid_3580000/3580163.stm


May 8th. 1945

Post 2

Orcus

I'm glad we don't celebrate it.

Commemorate it maybe but to celebrate it would be to grossly insult the Germans these days I think. We are supposedly friends now?


May 8th. 1945

Post 3

Icy North

Was it the day after VD day?


May 8th. 1945

Post 4

Superfrenchie

In France there are commemorations, with flowers on the war memorials, pretty much in every town and village, where the officials (often the Mayor, sometimes their Deputy) reads out the names of the people who died in the wars (the World Wars, and sometimes also Algeria and Indochina).
We have those ceremonies on 11th November as well, every year.

I think it's more about remembrance than celebration. Because, let's face it : we won the war, that's true, but how many people did we lose in the process ?
I don't think "all's well that ends well" is true in this instance.
smiley - 2cents


May 8th. 1945

Post 5

Geggs

I guess we are meant to be friends now, but old animosities die hard, don't they?

After all, we are meant to be friends with the French too, but, you know, they're still the French.

It's like this: we went to Legoland a few weeks ago, and while there we looked around the Star Wars exhibit. In there are several dioramas of scenes from each of the six films rendered in Lego. I took several photos of the scenes from the original trilogy, but none at all of the scenes from the prequel trilogy. I have no doubt that a lot of time and effort went into creating those dioramas too, but they are of the prequels, so I didn't take any photos of them. Animosity, see?


Geggs


May 8th. 1945

Post 6

Orcus

smiley - biggrin


May 8th. 1945

Post 7

Superfrenchie

I appreciate your first example, Geggs. smiley - winkeye


May 8th. 1945

Post 8

swl

Never understood the English rivalry with the French. After all, the French invaded, conquered and obliterated the English over a thousand years ago and all we've seen since then is petty squabbles between Frenchmen in parts of Great Britain and Frenchmen on the European mainland.


May 8th. 1945

Post 9

Geggs

After I'd posted I realised that you had SF. The irony was not lost on me.


Geggs


May 8th. 1945

Post 10

Icy North

I think you'll find the official line was that the Norman Invasion was well within net immigration targets.


May 8th. 1945

Post 11

swl

True. It didn't take many Frenchies at all did it?


May 8th. 1945

Post 12

Icy North

It did, until they tried the food.


May 8th. 1945

Post 13

Secretly Not Here Any More

Typical Jock thinking there swl. When we're not German, we're French. It'd be easier if you lot just went back to calling the English "sir."

smiley - winkeye


smiley - run


May 8th. 1945

Post 14

swl

Actually I forgot we annexed you in 1603, so you're all Jocks now.


May 8th. 1945

Post 15

Still Incognitas, Still Chairthingy, Still lurking, Still invisible, unnoticeable, missable, unseen, just haunting h2g2

Why don't we go back to when we were invaded by the Romans and point the finger at Italy?

Or we can just try to address the world as it is..smiley - winkeye


May 8th. 1945

Post 16

Icy North

I blame the beaker people


May 8th. 1945

Post 17

Bald Bloke

Going back to AB's original point...
Probably because the war was still going on
http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/hi/dates/stories/august/15/newsid_3581000/3581971.stm

And we probably wouldn't want to celebrate the atomic bombs.


May 8th. 1945

Post 18

Secretly Not Here Any More

Oh, if that's how the Act of Union worked then I really want a vote on independence! smiley - laugh


May 8th. 1945

Post 19

Ancient Brit

Truly, commemorate would have been a better word. At the time it was seen as a fight for freedom, a war to end all wars, a world war. All within living memory.
There was a United Kingdom, a functioning Commonwealth and world trade.
It was the end of 'our' war against Germany and it's alis. Thankfully America had come to our help, they were attacked by Japan whilst still helping us, naturally our forces stayed with them until the atom bomb struck the final blow for world peace.


May 8th. 1945

Post 20

bobstafford

The Normans were more Viking than French smiley - winkeye


Key: Complain about this post