A Conversation for Ask h2g2
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
hygienicdispenser Posted Apr 11, 2012
Vastly over-rated? Paul Weller and Morrisey. They've both done reasonable stuff but nothing to deserve the adulation they receive. Especially Weller.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
Edward the Bonobo - Gone. Posted Apr 11, 2012
@Sho:
Lou Reed:
Well you may know the bit from Trainspotting:
'All the Velvet Underground's solo stuff was shite.'
'Some ae Lou Reed's stuff wis no bad.'
'Aye - but no bad's no good enough.'
Well...maybe. If we take post-VU Lou Reed as separate (while acknowledging the Velvets' greatness, right?) then I'll admit there's a case for prosecution. But in his defence:
- Transformer
- New York
- Songs for Drella.
And you gotta admire the chutzpah of a man who played 'Metal Machine Music' live in its entirety.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
Edward the Bonobo - Gone. Posted Apr 11, 2012
@hygeinic:
So why is it that Smiths lyrics keep leaping unbidden into my head?
I'll tell you what you are. You're just a jumped up pantry boy who never knew his place!
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
hygienicdispenser Posted Apr 11, 2012
I sometimes have the lyrics to Agadoo leap unbidden into my head. Doesn't mean it's any good.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant Posted Apr 11, 2012
"Beethoven. I still think the man is incredibly good, but could have done with a good editor" [Vip]
He would never have tolerated any kind of editor. His "Andante Favori" is extremely self-indulgent, with at least six endings and a refusal to call it quits. He threw temper tantrums if anybody dared to distract him during his piano recitals. Apart from that , I think he *is* very overrated. Alas, the patina of generations of adulation by critics has settled over his symphonies. Wagner's comment that the Ninth Symphony was "a tragic but necessary mistake" doesn't get much attention nowadays.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
Orcus Posted Apr 11, 2012
The Stones surely did stop about 30 years ago. They haven't actually made a new song since then at least.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant Posted Apr 11, 2012
"All opera. Mozart" [Hoovooloo]
All 400+ years of opera? Isn't there even one that you sort of like? Just curious.
Ah, Mozart. Thirty-five short years on this planet, enduring shortsighted bosses like Archbishop Cooloredo, shivering in the cold while waiting for his aristocratic employers to let him in for his recitals. Do you know what effect the cold has on the desterity of a pianist's fingers? It's not pretty.
Well, here's the thing about Mozart: he didn't *know* that he wasn't going to have a long life. What musicologists call his "mature" works would be regarded as "early" works had he lived to be sixtyor seventy. So, yes, much of his symphonic output *does* deserve to be called overrated. Again, he wrote almost 50 symphonies before dying at 35. Brahms, who wrote four, didn't write his *first* symphony until he was about fifty.
So, yes, people expect too much from a young Mozart, and pretend that they see greatness where it probably wasn't present. I think that that has more to do with us than with Mozart himself.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant Posted Apr 11, 2012
"Why did nobody say 'Bob, you write some good lyrics, and you're OK with an acoustic guitar... your voice is a bit whiny and nasal but people seem to not hate it too much... but for the love of Bod, put DOWN the harmonica and back away from it and never, EVER pick it up again.'" [Hoovooloo]
I agree completely. Thank you for that!
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant Posted Apr 11, 2012
In my opinion, the most overrated musician/composer/showman of our time is Andrew Lloyd Webber.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
Edward the Bonobo - Gone. Posted Apr 11, 2012
Well there's a certain degree of objective evidence on one side of the argument...
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
Edward the Bonobo - Gone. Posted Apr 11, 2012
"All opera. Mozart" [Hoovooloo]
All 400+ years of opera? Isn't there even one that you sort of like? Just curious. [paulh]
Now...I personally don't like opera. But in this case I'm quite prepared to entertain the notion that it's me that's wrong. Various people who I respect insist that opera is good - not just good but *very, very* good.
My best guess is that I don't like opera...yet. But maybe I'll get around to liking it some day.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant Posted Apr 11, 2012
"My best guess is that I don't like opera...yet. But maybe I'll get around to liking it some day." [Edward the Bonobo]
That's fine, Ed. People who live in English-speaking countries don't have more than a handful of operas in their own language to appreciate. If you asked an Italian-speaking person, the reaction might be different.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
toybox Posted Apr 11, 2012
Is the text really that important in operas?
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
Edward the Bonobo - Gone. Posted Apr 11, 2012
Well I think the main problem with me is that I don't really like pre-20thC classical music. My entry point would possibly be 'Peter Grimes' or 'The Death of Klinghoffer' or some such.
Since I'm currently reading Doris Lessing, I'd quite like to hear 'The 'Making of the Representative for Planet 8'
I'm not so keen on tunes you can hum.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant Posted Apr 11, 2012
"Is the text really that important in operas?" [Toybox]
I was going to write a long post about this, but here's my point in a nutshell: opera is a hard enough sell without having linguistic hurdles to scale. Handel, great though he was, never could interest the masses in Italian opera in English-speaking England. Benjamin Britten wrote English-language operas, but he was no Handel. So, the U.K. is not exactly a hotbed of opera interest, but Italy may well be.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
quotes Posted Apr 11, 2012
Frank Zappa? Impossible to overrate. Even if you don't like the music, his legacy as a pioneer is second to none, and he's been ahead of the game in so many things it's hard to know where to start. How about the 'mash up'? He was doing that in the mid 70's. Or multi-tracked drums? And influence...I take it you've heard of Sgt Pepper? Well Paul McCartney is on record as saying it was the Beatles' "Freak Out" (Zappa 1966).
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
Edward the Bonobo - Gone. Posted Apr 11, 2012
Hmm. But then there's a school of thought that Sgt Pepper is overrated. Surely the cognoscenti go for Rubber Soul?
I haver between finding The Beatles overrated and not. I get fed up of people lauding them as the bestest and onliest band ever...but then I hear some of their stuff and think 'Actually...that's rather good.' But I certainly think they're at their best when they're reining in the experimentation a bit. Boundaries! Boundaries!
In fact...one reason I like them is because they were *not* the unique innovators some believe them to be. They started out playing white boys' version of R&B and then became part of the interplay of music in that period. Music is at its best when everyone is ripping one another off.
A couple of years ago I found myself drinking (etc) with some Norwegians. The bar was playing some really cheesy Norwegian folk-pop. Then The Beatles came on.
'I'm from Liverpool originally, so for me this counts as folk music. I WIN!!!'
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
Edward the Bonobo - Gone. Posted Apr 11, 2012
>>Is the text really that important in operas?
I believe there's a school of thought that says if you could understand what they were singing about you wouldn't be able to take it seriously.
In general I have no problem with music sung in a language I can't understand. However - it would be nice to think that an English libretto could combine well with the music to make something greater than the sum of their parts.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant Posted Apr 11, 2012
"I [hover] between finding The Beatles overrated and not. I get fed up of people lauding them as the bestest and onliest band ever...but then I hear some of their stuff and think 'Actually...that's rather good.' But I certainly think they're at their best when they're reining in the experimentation a bit" [Edward the Bonobo]
I have a CD of the soundtrack for "Yellow Submarine." I treasure it. Anyway, we all have our guilty pleasures. I've known a fair number of musicians. They need to earn a living, just like anybody else. Whether they play their own music or somebody else's the bottom line is that they need their audiences to enjoy their performances on some level. Some of us might scratch our heads when we hear things that musicians/compoers of earlier centuries came out with, but chances are they needed to please the audiences of their times.
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
Vip Posted Apr 11, 2012
I used to get annoyed that John Rutter was so overwhelmingly popular, because I found a lot of his music quite trite and not that deep and interesting. Then, one day, I twigged that he wrote music specifically to be just that, because a) it sold well and b) most church choirs these days can't sing anything complex - they just don't have the numbers and rehearsal time to do it. So he writes for his (paying) audience, and then occasionally lets rip on something bigger and deeper.
There's a composer up in Yorkshire called Tim Knight who writes for a similar kind of audience, because he's run enough parish choirs to know that they need things that can be sung by ordinary people, not trained singers.
Key: Complain about this post
Which famous musicians are seriously over-rated?
- 41: hygienicdispenser (Apr 11, 2012)
- 42: Edward the Bonobo - Gone. (Apr 11, 2012)
- 43: Edward the Bonobo - Gone. (Apr 11, 2012)
- 44: hygienicdispenser (Apr 11, 2012)
- 45: paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant (Apr 11, 2012)
- 46: Orcus (Apr 11, 2012)
- 47: paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant (Apr 11, 2012)
- 48: paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant (Apr 11, 2012)
- 49: paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant (Apr 11, 2012)
- 50: Edward the Bonobo - Gone. (Apr 11, 2012)
- 51: Edward the Bonobo - Gone. (Apr 11, 2012)
- 52: paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant (Apr 11, 2012)
- 53: toybox (Apr 11, 2012)
- 54: Edward the Bonobo - Gone. (Apr 11, 2012)
- 55: paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant (Apr 11, 2012)
- 56: quotes (Apr 11, 2012)
- 57: Edward the Bonobo - Gone. (Apr 11, 2012)
- 58: Edward the Bonobo - Gone. (Apr 11, 2012)
- 59: paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant (Apr 11, 2012)
- 60: Vip (Apr 11, 2012)
More Conversations for Ask h2g2
- For those who have been shut out of h2g2 and managed to get back in again [28]
Last Week - What can we blame 2legs for? [19024]
5 Weeks Ago - Radio Paradise introduces a Rule 42 based channel [1]
5 Weeks Ago - What did you learn today? (TIL) [274]
Nov 6, 2024 - What scams have you encountered lately? [10]
Sep 2, 2024
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."