A Conversation for Ask h2g2
What news story has caught your attention today.
Yelbakk Posted Jan 22, 2015
Yeah, well, I was just using the term "soul" in a metaphorical meaning. Or something. Old-fashioned, like. As is "SOS" - save our souls. Which does not make sense, because you really want the bodies to be saved by other ships, right? If you do believe in souls, what good would a ship be to save yours? If your alleged soul wanted saving, you would not send a morse-code message via radio, would you?
I used "soul" to mean "person" anyway.
What news story has caught your attention today.
Recumbentman Posted Jan 24, 2015
All religious language is metaphorical.
Those who contest that statement are doing what Berkeley called "addressing the will rather than the understanding".
I have no trouble in talking about souls without ascribing independent survival, or indeed any life, to them. Neither has arch-atheist Dan Dennett: he is delighted to quote an Italian newspaper report of a talk he gave, paraphrasing him as saying "Yes, we have a soul, but it's made of lots of tiny robots."
http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/191761-some-years-ago-there-was-a-lovely-philosopher-of-science
What news story has caught your attention today.
Baron Grim Posted Jan 25, 2015
Due for release this year, 70 years late, a documentary filmed by Alfred Hitchcock of the Holocaust.
http://www.theguardian.com/film/2014/jan/10/unseen-alfred-hitchcock-holocaust-documentary-screening
What news story has caught your attention today.
Baron Grim Posted Jan 25, 2015
Here's a link to the BBC/PBS 1985 version.
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/camp/view/
I'll wait for the new release.
What news story has caught your attention today.
Pink Paisley Posted Jan 25, 2015
The first Leon Brittan Touched my Todger stories have hit the Sunday red-tops.
PP.
What news story has caught your attention today.
hammondorgan Posted Jan 25, 2015
But what about the UKIP MEP who has defected to the Tories? There must be a joke in there somewhere or the Tories are really hard up! Honest I'm no John Humphries but I could have told Mr Bashir as a UKIP politician in Europe his prospects didn't look great, the Monster Raving Loony party would have been a better option! You have to query the guy's decision making faculties, he should do well under Cameron.
What news story has caught your attention today.
Pastey Posted Jan 25, 2015
It's more his reasons for going back to the Conservatives. He left them originally because he thought that UKIP would be better with their stand on Europe, but has gone back because he now believes that the Conservatives have changed their stand to be more in keeping with what he believes. I don't see a problem there.
What is interesting though, is as he was organising his "defection", UKIP started what looks seriously like a crude and dodgy smear campaign to try and discredit him, and not the party.
Yay for something new in politics
What news story has caught your attention today.
hammondorgan Posted Jan 25, 2015
Discrediting a UKIP politician? You couldn't make it up, Farage was saying something like his party cronies had said they wouldn't touch Mr Bashir with a bargepole, Cameron's not that fussy obviously, when Tories and UKIP are interchangeable it's time to vote Labour, or Green of course which is an increasingly popular option I see.
What news story has caught your attention today.
Pastey Posted Jan 26, 2015
Labour politicians have also been defecting to UKIP. The those three are the same party with different colours, they're all in it for themselves.
What news story has caught your attention today.
swl Posted Jan 26, 2015
^^^^ This
Politics is a career and many politicians go with whatever party offers them the best chance of getting elected. Switching parties is no different to switching employers from Shell to Esso for them.
What news story has caught your attention today.
hammondorgan Posted Jan 26, 2015
I've just been reading 'a Green spokeswoman' has said that they would scrap the Army and laws on illegal immigration, you can't say they don't offer an alternative! Oh, and dig out those old Drachmas, they might be back in fashion soon.
What news story has caught your attention today.
Pastey Posted Jan 26, 2015
Can't remember a Green spokesman ever saying they'd scrap the army, but I do remember them being accused of it often, but never with any evidence.
What news story has caught your attention today.
Pastey Posted Jan 26, 2015
In fact: http://policy.greenparty.org.uk/pd.html
"PD204 The defence budget needs to be adequate to ensure security, but no more so."
There's no policy of scraping the army, the policy is to stop invading other countries, and to build trust to try and stop the need/desire for war.
What news story has caught your attention today.
Recumbentman Posted Jan 26, 2015
Stop invading other countries -- now there's a cost-cutting idea!
What news story has caught your attention today.
SiliconDioxide Posted Jan 26, 2015
The army are already green, except when they are invading deserts of course.
What news story has caught your attention today.
Recumbentman Posted Jan 26, 2015
Did you hear about the army driver? Lost his khaki ...
Key: Complain about this post
What news story has caught your attention today.
- 16661: Baron Grim (Jan 22, 2015)
- 16662: Yelbakk (Jan 22, 2015)
- 16663: Baron Grim (Jan 22, 2015)
- 16664: Recumbentman (Jan 24, 2015)
- 16665: Baron Grim (Jan 25, 2015)
- 16666: Baron Grim (Jan 25, 2015)
- 16667: Pink Paisley (Jan 25, 2015)
- 16668: hammondorgan (Jan 25, 2015)
- 16669: Pastey (Jan 25, 2015)
- 16670: hammondorgan (Jan 25, 2015)
- 16671: Pastey (Jan 26, 2015)
- 16672: swl (Jan 26, 2015)
- 16673: hammondorgan (Jan 26, 2015)
- 16674: Icy North (Jan 26, 2015)
- 16675: Pastey (Jan 26, 2015)
- 16676: Pastey (Jan 26, 2015)
- 16677: Recumbentman (Jan 26, 2015)
- 16678: SiliconDioxide (Jan 26, 2015)
- 16679: Recumbentman (Jan 26, 2015)
- 16680: Pastey (Jan 26, 2015)
More Conversations for Ask h2g2
- For those who have been shut out of h2g2 and managed to get back in again [28]
4 Days Ago - What can we blame 2legs for? [19024]
4 Weeks Ago - Radio Paradise introduces a Rule 42 based channel [1]
4 Weeks Ago - What did you learn today? (TIL) [274]
Nov 6, 2024 - What scams have you encountered lately? [10]
Sep 2, 2024
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."