A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 1

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

Why do the Norse deities, Greek deities and pagan British deities count for nothing when British legislation is decided.

OK, that's a disingenuous rhetorical question.

What I mean to say is:

What on earth is the justification for giving contemporary religions a say in British legislation?


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 2

hayayfi

Hello smiley - smileyWhat is the justification for not giving them a voice?smiley - winkeye


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 3

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

My sock doesn't like muffins. I trust my sock. Ban muffins.

smiley - winkeye


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 4

Anoldgreymoonraker Free Tibet

Been waiting all day listening to the news what you would have to say and I agree with your first postsmiley - smiley


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 5

Anoldgreymoonraker Free Tibet

Sorry , Morning Roysmiley - ok


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 6

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

Mornin'. I shouldn't be up right now, and soon won't be. Thor told me to sleep....


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 7

hayayfi

Havent the faintest idea what socks and muffins smiley - erm have to do with your posting or is this an in house thing.


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 8

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

Muffin = deity. Socks = gays. It's not an in house thing, just a metaphor.


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 9

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

Oops. Muffin = gays, sock = deity!


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 10

KB

"What on earth is the justification for giving contemporary religions a say in British legislation?"

None - no more than any other pressure group anyway. I don't see why they shouldn't try to influence legislation any more than any other campaigners. Whether they are full of rancid ruminant refuse is another question, of course.


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 11

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

Most pressure groups don't have a presence in the house of lords...


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 12

hayayfi

So not being privvy to english papers does this mean a religious group that does not like gay people is trying to exhert pressure on the way your govenrment forms its lawssmiley - erm


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 13

KB

That's probably true Roy, but I'm sure one or two do. The House of Lords was never supposed to be about equality though.


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 14

kelli - ran 2 miles a day for 2012, aiming for the same for 2013

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6243323.stm

This is what Roymondo is talking about hayayfi. A law has been passed to stop discrimination against homosexuals, religious groups are trying to get it scrapped.

I don't think they have a leg to stand on here, incidentally.


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 15

hayayfi

Why do they want the law scrapped?


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 16

swl

Because it's a fundamental part of their beliefs that they have the right to criticise gays. It's written in their books therefoore the state is impinging on their religious freedom if they're not allowed to preach what their books tell them.


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 17

offsoon

Agreed. Rarely to we here Outrage or any other gay pressure groups insisting on a ban on religious organisations on the grounds that they cause violence and unrest.
(Go-on Mr. Tatchell. I dare you. Please?)


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 18

offsoon

Simulpost.


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 19

hayayfi

But is it a fundemental part of their beliefs I am not ofay with most religions but I have not come across anything to date that says in black and white that you should deprive someone of their rights or verbally assult them because they are homosexual. I know the bible speaks about how God feels about it from a Chirstian perspective but I must have missed the part where He said "go ahead and persecute people I am all for it"!


Theists influensing legislation (UK centric)

Post 20

swl

I think it's in Leviticus where he says gays must be killed. Now no one is saying that Christians want to kill gays, but it's not a particularly healthy starting point.


Key: Complain about this post