A Conversation for The Quite Interesting Society

QI :- By Gad sir

Post 1

bobstafford

It was taken by gad and joe together but joe got the glory.

What when and where am I on about...

Loads of points here but loads more smiley - bluelights


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 2

KB

Iwo Jima.

Should I award my own smiley - bluelight?


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 3

Icy North

No idea, Bob, but 'by Gad' obviously derives from the oath 'by god'. In the same way we get wods like 'gadzooks' (God's hooks - or nails on the cross).


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 4

bobstafford

No not yet... Not daft enoughsmiley - winkeye


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 5

bobstafford

Way off Icy But +1 for the oathsmiley - smiley


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 6

Taff Agent of kaos

what ho

there sir , there down yonder valley

there lies your target, the russian guns(pointing down wrong valley)

charge of the light brigade

"never trust a man in a cardigan"

smiley - bat


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 7

Feisor - -0- Generix I made it back - sortof ...

Is it biblical?


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 8

Yarreau

The coffee prevailed?

Will this get me my very first claxon? smiley - smiley


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 9

bobstafford

No, No and No


Taff is however in the right area but that's like saying London's in Europe no points but no smiley - bluelight so far


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 10

Mrs Zen

The only two things that spring to mind are Cromwell's advice to his troops (the New Model Army?) to trust in god and keep their powder try and Uxbridge's exchange with Wellington at Waterloo:

Good Gad, I've lost my leg sir!
Good Gad, so you have sir!

None of which have anything to do with Joe.

B


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 11

bobstafford

Not even close
Initially I was thinking of a blue light .............. smiley - smiley


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 12

Clive the flying ostrich: Amateur Polymath | Chief Heretic.

I wondering if 'gad' has another derivation.

I find myself wondering about 'gad-flys', those 'fault-finders', social critics and provocateurs who irritate and trouble by asking awkward questions.

Since the term was used by Plato to describe Socrates in "The Apology", (grated via translation I'm not sure what original Greek was) and has been used to describe figures such as Ghandi and Oscar Wilde, I don't see how the word can be originally derived from 'god's oath' unless this came later.

A2334197

I wouldn't be surprised if 'gad' and 'gad' are in fact homonyms with different linguistic genealogies and appear in other contexts like 'gadget' or 'gadroon' although, raiding my copy of the OED, the best I can find is 'gad' is an archaic expression meaning 'on the move' (hence the buzzing, hovering, biting association of the gad-fly' of Greek oration and gadget is actually French. (gachette)


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 13

Mrs Zen

As in "gadding around".

How interesting.

B


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 14

Mrs Zen

Ok.

Straight question. Was "it" a military objective, such as a town or a gun emplacement or a bridgehead?

B


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 15

Clive the flying ostrich: Amateur Polymath | Chief Heretic.

Exactly. smiley - smiley


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 16

Mrs Zen

Simulpost, Clive?


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 17

Clive the flying ostrich: Amateur Polymath | Chief Heretic.

I don't think so. smiley - erm


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 18

Mrs Zen

I'm confused again. (Easily done). Are we looking for a military objective, or aren't we?


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 19

Yarreau

This reminds me of Hilary and Norgay, who for many years was never even mentioned because he was "just" a sherpa...

So, was the fact that Joe got the glory and Gad didn't racially motivated, or, more broadly speaking, was it due to their nationality?

Unless Gad is short for Gaddh... no, I didn't say it, stop waving that claxon!


QI :- By Gad sir

Post 20

bobstafford

Yes ben well done for pointing everyone in the right direction +3 smiley - smiley a military action smiley - ok


Key: Complain about this post