A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Will You Be Returning to Middle Earth?

Post 61

Orcus

BTW it's feasible given Tolkein's origins of the dwarves that they might be highly resistant to heat. I might be stretching it a bit but they were created by the Vala Aule to be creatures of the mountains, smelting metal and jewels.

Even if that's stretching it, have you ever watched that Tommy Lee Jones film Volcano? I'm fairly sure he had a tender love moment with the female lead about 3 feet away from a stream of molten lava smiley - laugh I think The Hobbit is positively realistic in comparison smiley - biggrin


Will You Be Returning to Middle Earth?

Post 62

Mol - on the new tablet

I'm not sure Volcano is a completely realistic depiction of what lava can do ...

Mol


Will You Be Returning to Middle Earth?

Post 63

Mol - on the new tablet

Sorry got muddled there, deleted what I'd written and ended up pretty well with what you'd written!

I quite like the idea of heat-resistant dwarves. Although they did burn up quite quickly faced with Smaug.

I'm pretty sure Frodo and Sam should, by rights, have ended up incinerated at Mount Doom. So perhaps Middle Earth lava is different somehow.

Mol


Will You Be Returning to Middle Earth?

Post 64

Gnomon - time to move on

smiley - cool


Will You Be Returning to Middle Earth?

Post 65

paulh, vaccinated against the Omigod Variant

I hope the citizens of Lakeville don't make ashes of themselves.


Will You Be Returning to Middle Earth?

Post 66

Orcus

>I quite like the idea of heat-resistant dwarves. Although they did burn up quite quickly faced with Smaug.<

Ah but dragonfire is the only thing known to be able to consume a ring of power outside mount doom - that's *different*

Good point about Frodo and Sam though smiley - ok


Key: Complain about this post