A Conversation for Ask h2g2

WHY...?

Post 1

Moonhogg - Captain Coffee Break

...does Goofy walk on two legs, wear clothes, and talk, while Pluto walks on four legs, wears nothing but a collar, and barks? Both are supposedly dogs?

Sorry, it just popped into my head...


WHY...?

Post 2

Serephina

because theyre cartoons n things like that don't matter? smiley - erm


WHY...?

Post 3

Icy North

That's because Pluto's recently been reclassified.


WHY...?

Post 4

Gnomon - time to move on

Because Goofy is a horse?


WHY...?

Post 5

Icy North

Has anyone blamed 2legs yet?


WHY...?

Post 6

Serephina

Nope, I blame 2legs


WHY...?

Post 7

Xanatic

I´d imagine that many of the characters in Disney are sort of evolved versions of known animals. So Donald, Scrooge and such are to ducks what humans are to monkeys. That and the fact it is just a cartoon.
I think Goofy is a dog though, they did have a character who was a horse and he looked different.


WHY...?

Post 8

Researcher 188007

Have seen 'Stand by Me' recently, by any chance? smiley - winkeye

Damn fine film smiley - smiley


WHY...?

Post 9

Moonhogg - Captain Coffee Break

Not seen that one. Should I?

(Sort of missed the relevance of that - I'd probably understand it if I saw the film. Never mind)


WHY...?

Post 10

Kerr_Avon - hunting stray apostrophes and gutting poorly parsed sentences

Goofy's defo a dog. He's got floppy ears. Not a very smart dog though, so maybe in the Disney world the evolved dogs haven't got as far as the ducks and the mice.

smiley - ale


WHY...?

Post 11

Hoovooloo


smiley - applause for post 3!

SoRB


WHY...?

Post 12

Gnomon - time to move on

I'm glad to hear that Goofy is a dog. I was never sure, because he looks about half way between a dog and a horse.

Goofy and Donald Duck are Mickey's equals. They talk, they do things. Pluto, on the other hand, is Mickey's pet, so he has to be more pet-like. He's enthusiastic, but basically dumb.


WHY...?

Post 13

KB

Is Pluto an over-bred pedigree dog, and Goofy one which has enjoyed more genetic variation?


WHY...?

Post 14

Kerr_Avon - hunting stray apostrophes and gutting poorly parsed sentences

I dunno what Pluto's supposed to be. He looks like an underweight labrador.

smiley - ale


WHY...?

Post 15

2legs - Hey, babe, take a walk on the wild side...

Its genetic madness gone correct...


WHY...?

Post 16

Wilma Neanderthal

>> Its genetic madness gone correct... <<

smiley - online2long I almost understood that! smiley - yikes


WHY...?

Post 17

2legs - Hey, babe, take a walk on the wild side...

It kinda made sense to me... a couple hours ago... Not so sure now though smiley - cdouble


WHY...?

Post 18

Moonhogg - Captain Coffee Break

Alhocol hleps to untredsand it... smiley - cheers


Key: Complain about this post