A Conversation for Ask h2g2

So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 1

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

From http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/tv_and_radio/3153117.stm

"The Sci-Fi Channel in the United States has cancelled an Arnold Schwarzenegger day after the star announced his intention to run for governor of California.



Instead of Terminator 2, The Running Man and Conan the Destroyer, viewers will see a day of California disaster movies."

smiley - laugh


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 2

Researcher Eagle 1

smiley - laugh

But as an American, I think we have the capacity to understand irony perfectly!

For instance, there's a blackout that is affecting milions of Americans and Canadians in the northeastern section of North America. In those areas they have cancelled Renaissance faires for the weekend. In other words, due to a lack of electricity, they have cancelled events celebrating a time when there was no electricity.

smiley - laugh


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 3

Hellycub

I think it's more sarcasm that Americans don't get.
And Lord God, once I met an American who thought people in Ireland actually believed in Lepruchauns and that we have mud floors and live in huts... I mean COME ON!


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 4

Baconlefeets

i don't believe all americans don't get irony, i think a lot of them probably do, but that stereotype of americans is always at the forefront of everyones minds


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 5

Hellycub

What about the stereotype of Irish people? I mean we've had electricity for quite a few years now you know...


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 6

lazy like panda cat

"So I heard about the famine. That must have been awful for you guys."
Seriously.


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 7

Baconlefeets

everyone is stereotyped in one way or the other, but if a person can't see past that then they're just being ignorant and not thinking for themselves. that goes for anyone too


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 8

Researcher Eagle 1

Well, this is one American who knows some history, understands irorny, 'gets' sarcasm, has a good sense of humor and has at least some respect for most people. Please take it to the "What's Wrong with Americans" thread if you want to keep it up, guys? Please?


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 9

aonemantidalwave

Right, I've got a tale to tell about an American!
I'm half yank myself and have until recently had an affinity for our cousins across the pond.
But this morning the last tie was severed.
What happened I hear you mutter into your Baileys.
Well...
I recently posted a comment on Ain't It Cool news that basically stated that the way America was at the moment a movie of Superman (truth, justice and the American way and all that) would be slightly inapporpriate.
So, I open my mailbox (virtual not literal) this morning to discover a superman superfan insulting me all over my hotmail account. I will not repeat the language as it was truly foul, I'm a big believer in blue language but this went way too far.
Anyway, I mailed him back a couple of flippant replies, nothing serious, a bit of 'aren't you a bit old for this sort of thing...etc', his messages got nastier and nastier resulting in him accusing me of having sexual intercourse with goats!
Well,. I started to get a bit irked. Suddenly I noticed that his language was peppered with very American stylings (colour spelt wrong that sort of thing), so decided to have a bit of a poke at his homeland.
He virtually crumbled in front of my eyes. From being 'big man on campus' he turned into a whining little tosser. "Bulls*** man" he basically declared. "you're just jealous because we're the superpower. At least our leader has balls, you are jealous that 9/11 didn't happen to you!!!" (EVERYTHING I have just written came from this arse). I was unrepentant however and kept nibbling at his weakspot. In the end, he blocked me out of his account and hasn't e-mailed back. One in the eye for Uncle Sam. Proving that while Yanks may have irony (Simpsons...etc), they can't take a joke about themselves.
Sorry, this was a really long post but I wanted to get it off my chest.

No-one is going to read this are they..?
Hello?
Anyone.

...I'll let myself out.


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 10

Researcher Eagle 1

You exchanged e-mails back and forth with an dumb, infintile, immature (probably teenaged) guy who happened to be an American. And you got him more and more upset by mocking his country until he snapped and began ignoring you.

Oh, yeah, you're a real hero.


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 11

Queeglesproggit - Keeper of the evil Thingite Avon Lady Army and Mary Poppins's bag of darkness..

Oh there's plenty of british people I've come across like that smiley - biggrin

Fab link though Gosho smiley - ok


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 12

Baconlefeets

aonemantidalwave: you may be getting some more emails, sorry


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 13

aonemantidalwave

Hey, hey, hey. Hold it Han!
I didn't trade any insults with me until he went to far and then I let him have it. If you can't laugh at your own country what can you laugh at.
And he said he was 22...it wasn't you was it?


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 14

Fathom


Perhaps he was just kidding with his first e-mail and it was you who took the bait.

F


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 15

Researcher Eagle 1

If you're talking to me,

1. I can laugh at my own country with the best of them (especially the city where I live). I just get tired of people who incessantly rip the USA and when I finally start getting annoyed, suggest I have no sense of humor.

2. I'm 25 (3 months from 26).

3. My favorite superhero is Green Lantern.

4. You're supposed to be bigger than to quibble with trolls or you're no better than they are.


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 16

aonemantidalwave

You have a point I guess.
Still, good story though wasn't it?
...and the main reason i can't get on with Americans at the mo is because They are going to be responsible for the end of the civilised world.


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 17

Researcher Eagle 1

What, all 280,000,000 of us?


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 18

Hellycub

Yup (well, what are you doing to stop it?)
I suppose we'll see when the next Presidential election comes around


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 19

Fathom


What civilised world?

F


So it's true that Americans don't 'get' irony

Post 20

aonemantidalwave

I blame Bush and his sucsessor (thats spelt wrong isn't it?) Arnold Schwarzenegger. Americans have done some great things. Bill Hicks. John Coltrane. David Lynch. Don't get me wrong. But you have to admit, isn't it a little bit embarassing to have that jarhead as president. Particularly when he is hellbent on destruction.
Another great American, Hunter S Thompson said in an interview recently that he thought Bush jr was being controlled by Bush sr. A terrifying thought to be sure.


Key: Complain about this post