A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Where does space start?

Post 1

Special Agent Poops

This has been making me curious. Where exactly does the earth's atmosphere end and space begin? How many feet above sea level is it? And how did scientists find this out, if anyone knows...


Where does space start?

Post 2

The Groob

Try http://liftoff.msfc.nasa.gov/academy/space/atmosphere.html


Where does space start?

Post 3

Mu Beta

I suspect it's too much of a gradual thing to be exactly verified.

The exosphere is the upper part of the Earth's atmosphere and consists of mostly hydrogen molecules, which decrease in density as you go further away. However, you could define that as space. The Americans, when they flew their X-15 tests, called it sub-space.

B


Where does space start?

Post 4

Researcher U197087

Pedantry alert!

The earth is a constituent of the space-time continuum, and is thus, space, as is everything in and on it. You can't be outside of space, you are it! You are awash with the stuff of stars, a bubble of energy burped from your antecedents and, for a limited time, blessed with the opportunity to experience and determine your path in the continuum and relate with other burps. To say you are outside of space is to forget your place.

Excuse me smiley - blush now I have to go to work. smiley - sadface


Where does space start?

Post 5

Mu Beta

And in next-week's Spot The Geek competition...

B


Where does space start?

Post 6

Special Agent Poops

smiley - smiley
Well that link is quite good, thanks for that. As for being a burp, that makes me think of lunch...

I guess for arguments sake we are technically IN space as a planet, I was just wondering how NASA knew how far they had to make shuttle blast off to before it escapes the earth's atmosphere


Where does space start?

Post 7

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

I remember someone asking me "How far do you think you'd have to travel to 'officially' be in space?", and being surprised when he told me it was about the distance from London to Northampton, or 60 miles.

I've no idea whose 'official' measurement that is smiley - erm


Where does space start?

Post 8

Mu Beta

The Ordanance Survey? smiley - biggrin

B


Where does space start?

Post 9

Still Incognitas, Still Chairthingy, Still lurking, Still invisible, unnoticeable, missable, unseen, just haunting h2g2

Between some people's ears.

Incog.


Where does space start?

Post 10

Galaxy Babe - eclectic editor

smiley - musicalnote We are stardust smiley - musicalnote


Where does space start?

Post 11

xyroth

I think it is the point where your orbit won't decay due to atmospheric drag. as this changes with space weather, it varies a bit, but around 60 miles sounds about right.


Where does space start?

Post 12

Wejut - Sage of Slightly Odd Occurrences and Owlatron's Australian Thundercat

According to posting 4 (which I agree with, but it made me think - yes scary I know) does that make space God?
smiley - magic


Where does space start?

Post 13

Mycroft

There's no clear definition in international law defining where space starts (or rather where a nation's sovereign airspace ends), but all parties to discussions seem to agree that it should be set at somewhere between 100km and 110km.

And from http://www.inesap.org/bulletin20/bul20art08.htm#t13 there's this:

"The US Air Force (USAF), for example, uses 80 km as the altitude required for the award of 'Astronaut Rating'. Soviet delegates to the United Nations repeatedly called for a figure of '110 km or less'. During ascent to orbit, NASA's space shuttles complete their main engine burn at an altitude of about 84 km, and NASA uses 400,000 ft (122 km) to define 'entry interface' when returning shuttles first begin to encounter aerodynamic forces."


Where does space start?

Post 14

Special Agent Poops

Yeah, I thought there would have to be a certain point where shuttles would have to make sure their heat sheilds were working, and they were at the right speed and angle etc. as we well know from the recent crash of Columbia.

But why do the US and the Russians have different "measurements" of where this point is?
Is it just an old Cold War thingy?


Where does space start?

Post 15

Wejut - Sage of Slightly Odd Occurrences and Owlatron's Australian Thundercat

Or is it an imperial versus metric problem?
smiley - magic


Where does space start?

Post 16

turvy (Fetch me my trousers Geoffrey...)

That was how NASA lost that Mars Orbiter (I forget which just now).

Metric - NASA
Imperial - MacDonald Douglas

At least I think it was that way round...?

*wanders off, mumbling to self about bl**dy foreign measurements and the Cubit*

http://www.sover.net/~rc/deep_secrets/index.html
turvysmiley - blackcat


Where does space start?

Post 17

Special Agent Poops

I think that was how the first Boeing 737 almost crashed, coz they had just converted from using pounds of fuel to kilograms and they didnt do the conversion right and ran out of fuel!

Heres something fun - tell an American or Canadian how much you weigh in stone, they usually get really baffled about that


Where does space start?

Post 18

xyroth

yes, that's what happened.

and when they ran all the other pilots through the simulation, they all crashed.

it was made into a film for tv called "Freefall: Flight 174"


Key: Complain about this post