A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Is the phrase "the XXXX is the Antichrist" offensive?

Post 41

Hoovooloo

Justin is of course free to come to the entry in question and protest that he's been misrepresented - if he thinks that. And if he does think that, I'd reconsider the content of the entry, or at least dispute it with him.

But I don't think he would be in any way offended, or feel that I've misrepresented his belief in any way. I think he'd stand behind every single thing he's said. You can call him many things (and I have), but inconsistent is not one of them. If he's said something here, it's because he believes it.

Collecting quotes on a particular subject to demonstrate a particular opinion is a normal technique of debate, and satire. Private Eye do it all the time.

If it did make anyone uncomfortable to have the accurately reported expression of their opinions collected in one place, then surely that is a pointer that perhaps they ought to rethink those opinions. Which is, of course, the point.

I for one would be quite happy for anyone to collect (if they could be bothered) non-misrepresentative quotes of things I've said. I'd find that quite instructive, in fact, as an external view of how I come across...

H.


Is the phrase "the XXXX is the Antichrist" offensive?

Post 42

Narapoia

I consider myself fortunate not to have encountered Justin in my few months on hootoo.
I've read your entry, and I found it most instructive.
Far from seeing you as some kind of a pariah, hoovooloo, I think you've done the community a service, and the fact that you've been required to change something, but have been allowed to report on the circumstances, shows that the system is working.
Don't push it too far and deprive the rest of us of your contributions.


Is the phrase "the XXXX is the Antichrist" offensive?

Post 43

The Ghost of Polidari

Quite right. Based on what you put I went looking for some of Justin's posts.

Haven't stopped smiley - laugh since.

Bless him!


XXXX

Post 44

Chronicargonaut

XXXX- are we talking bout Castlemaine XXXX Lager? If so, then it definitely IS.smiley - biggrinsmiley - laugh


XXXX

Post 45

Trout Montague

Anyone fancy a game of 7-card pope-stain?


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more