A Conversation for Ask h2g2

This thread has been closed

Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1181

swl

Yeah, sorry. I was flicking between Wikipedia and the Asian Times.


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1182

Jordan

* No reference, that is, aside from the wikipedia article itself:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literacy#Examples_of_highly_literate_cultures_in_the_past


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1183

Jordan

smiley - doh I just noticed where you posted the reference, immediately after the post.

Read the whole thread before posting, Jordan! smiley - headhurts


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1184

swl

Following that logic would lead an outside believer to think Europe was highly literate in Latin throughout the Dark Ages. However, it was a literacy limited to monks and a highly select priviledged few.


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1185

Jordan

Not quite, SWL. The article only mentions an edict specific to Islam.

If I recall, during the Dark Ages and beyond, Christian holy texts were considered suitable only for those well-educated enough to understand them. That was the very reason they used the Latin (even if the Vulgate was so-called "common" Latin).

I seem to remember something about St. Columba running a Bible College during his pennance on Iona; so far as I am aware, this was the only significant attempt in that period to introduce the common people to the book they were supposed to be following.

smiley - space—Jordan


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1186

anhaga

Here's a little something for both sides of this discussion to have a look at: http://www.muslimrefusenik.com/index.html



Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1187

AnarchistDuck


<>

if your 'morals' allow you to dump all these things together; i'm all for immorality. let us destroy each other and be off with it if we're incapable of being more sensible.


Removed

Post 1188

AnarchistDuck

This post has been removed.


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1189

DA ; Simply Vicky: Don't get pithy with me!

<< Some feel that 'traditional' marriage is either (or both) rape and prostitution. Should books glorifying marriage be banned?>>

What an odd opinion! Marriage can be either very good or very bad, but it needn't involve rape, or prostitution!


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1190

AnarchistDuck


I guess that was about marriages built on financial concerns [not too rare unfortunately] or against the wish of bride.


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1191

AnarchistDuck


By the way i'm puzzled as to why my post disappeared. How do i find out? I'm sorry but i don't remember anything offensive in it.


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1192

toybox

I would also like people who yikes something to post just afterwards some kind of explanation of what was deemed offensive. It may turn out that offense was only caused by some awkward phrasing after all smiley - erm (and in any case, the original poster can also rephrase his opinion in some amended way).

smiley - stout


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1193

AnarchistDuck


Indeed. Because i genuinely am sorry if it was offensive and am curiuos as to why exactly it was.


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1194

anhaga

Sure, Della, the feeling that marriage is either slavery or prostitution is, as you put it, an odd opinion, in the sense that it is not the majority opinion. It's not my opinion, either, BTW.

I refuse to believe, however, that New Zealand is such a backwater as to leave you unaware that such 'opinions' are not terribly far out of the mainstream of feminist thought.


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1195

DA ; Simply Vicky: Don't get pithy with me!

<>

Of course I knew about that, I just can't agree...


Why isn't the BBC showing me stories about child brides?

Post 1196

The H2G2 Editors

Hello all,

We've become increasingly concerned about many of the posts in this thread, which seem closer to religious baiting than informed debate.

As a result, we have taken the decision to lock the thread in order that we can consider the situation over the weekend.

h2g2 Editors


Key: Complain about this post