A Conversation for 24 Lies a Second

Sirius - and other actors

Post 1

Catwoman

Sirius is NOT Stephen Fry.
And I think they're going to have to cast an unknown (as long as it's a good one) because the closest we can get with actual well-known people is Ralph Fiennes.

Quick explanation here, for the unobsessed (in the order they were mentioned):
Maggie Smith = McGonagall
Richard Griffiths = Uncle Vernon
Julie Walters = Mrs Weasley
Richard Harris = Dumbledore
Mark Williams = Mr Weasley (why is he the bloke off the Fast Show? it confuses me)
Miriam Margolyes = Prof Sprout
Jason Isaacs = Lucius Malfoy (with elf hair)
Robert Hardy = Cornelius Fudge
Julian Glover = Aragog (no, not in a big spider suit)
Shirley Henderson = Moaning Myrtle
Robbie Coltrane = Hagrid
Alan Rickman = Snape (<yay&gtsmiley - winkeye
Christian Coulson = Tom Riddle (nudge nudge, he's cute)


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 2

Swiv (decrepit postgrad)

y'never know - Fiennes has just done a film with J.Lo, surely he could be persuaded that Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban is a step up?


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 3

Catwoman

Definitely a big leap up in terms of quality of co-stars.


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 4

Swiv (decrepit postgrad)

*balances Daniel Radcliffe on scales opposite J.Lo*

*scales tip, slightly*

yep - he doesn't come off too badly!


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 5

Catwoman

*was thinking of Maggie Smith etc, Alan Rickman (I love him), y'know, the cool people*


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 6

Swiv (decrepit postgrad)

LOL

actually, for the first time I think it's a shame that Lockhart only lasted one book!

smiley - smiley


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 7

Catwoman

I know, you want to see him in the film (whereas in the book you just wanted him to go away, as soon as possible)


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 8

Swiv (decrepit postgrad)

I do have different reactions to the characters in the films than in the books though - I find film Percy far less infuriating, and film Snape more likeable (he's always fascinating, but in the books it's in the hating way...)


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 9

Catwoman

True.
I love Hermione anywhere though.
And there should be more of the Weasley twins.


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 10

Swiv (decrepit postgrad)

I don't really like movie-Hermione too much.
Well - she emphasises to me why Ron really is my favourite

*mourning the loss of "Seriously Evil Wizard coming through" line*


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 11

Catwoman

When was that line?
And about who?


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 12

Swiv (decrepit postgrad)

'twas a Fred and George line, when Harry is thought to be the Heir of Slytherin.


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 13

Catwoman

Gred and Forge, lovely.
I don't believe they gave away the Marauder's Map though. (It is useful for the kids to have it, but why would they not keep it?)


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 14

Swiv (decrepit postgrad)

well, I guess they knew all the passages, and were willing to take their chances with detentions!
Plus, it's a nice Christmas gesture to Harry.


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 15

Catwoman

Yeah, nice xmas gift all right. (I want one for christmas)

(and a castle)

(and a godfather who can turn into a dog)

(and an invisibility cloak)

(and a knife that can cut through worlds)

(oops, and a mind that can keep on the same subject for more than 5 seconds)


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 16

Swiv (decrepit postgrad)

smiley - laugh

and an elven dagger that glows,

and a mithril vest

and a bow and arrow

and some lembas (gotta be better for you than Quality Street)


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 17

Catwoman

Lembas? Think of the calories. (I saw FotR with lembas in it!)
smiley - choc is nice, anyway.

(I wouldn't mind being descended from an elf or two, and a maiar, so then I'd live for a very long time)


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 18

Swiv (decrepit postgrad)

and have really long straight hair (always wanted that - probably since mine won't do it, not nohow...)


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 19

Catwoman

*is aiming for fairy princess hair at this very moment, but not the straight kind, due to having hair that doesn't know what the word straight means*


Bets against Stephen Fry

Post 20

Swiv (decrepit postgrad)

mine doesn't curl prettily either... and now it's in the shaggy growing out phase

*pulls face in mirror*


Key: Complain about this post