A Conversation for Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Peer Review: A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 1

Superplonker

Entry: Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart - A703603
Author: Superplonker - U190439

I thought this'd make a nice addition to the Games section. This is my first entry, so I appologise for anything that I've done wrong.


A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 2

Wayfarer -MadForumArtist, Keeper of bad puns, Greeblet with Goo beret, Tangential One

i'd agree that it'll make a nice addition, and, don't worry, you've done a great job!smiley - ok(please don't be discouraged by the rather lengthy remainder of the post; changes can be made quite easily.)

however some minor points(there are always *some* aren't there?smiley - smiley):

1)"...make their way towards the wall at which the wall at which “it” is waiting", i'm thinking you meant "..make their way towards the wall at which “it” is waiting"? only typo i've found.

2)first person: i know, you've stayed away from it pretty well, yet references to 'the author' tend to look sort of odd and therefore discouraged. intances:
a)"...to pick “it", in the author’s experience..." could perhaps be changed to "...to pick "it" is generally for each..." or "one way in which to pick "it"..." , something like that.
b)"The author recommends..." "The following rhymes are recommended for..." passive sentences are generally preferable to 'the author' as they more easily avoid first person.
c)"The author suggests the following amendments..." "the following are possible amendments.."
d)much under the 'Is that it?' header. not sure what you can do with that.

that's it. remember, 'the author' phrases are really more of a last-ditch, i-really-can't-work-this-in-any-other-way kind of thing, and to be avoided almost as stringently as "I".

just know this one will get snatched up quickly, and, hope you'll write more for us...(i keep hoping one day we will have a smiley for that *hope hope*)


A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 3

Wayfarer -MadForumArtist, Keeper of bad puns, Greeblet with Goo beret, Tangential One

oh and there also seems to be some sort of problem with the title, smiley - huh probably one of those characters that doesn't display properly all the time.


A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 4

Superplonker

Many thanks!

I'll see if I can make those changes.smiley - biggrin


A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 5

Superplonker

There, done. Thank you for the advice, I did deem to go over board with "the author" phrases. I think I saw this in one entry and liked it.

I have left in a first person perspective in the last paragraph but only as a means of giving some explanation of where the idea came from.

smiley - biggrin


A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 6

Wayfarer-- I only wish I were crackly

smiley - ok

ok, but be warned, there's a fair chance it'll be edited out... you might put it as a quote instead, with you as the 'quote-ee'(?).

oops, 'the wall at which the wall at which' is still in there...


A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 7

Superplonker

There, I think I've done as much as I can do now. I guess I just sit back and wait now, eh?


A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 8

Wayfarer-- I only wish I were crackly

smiley - ok


A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 9

Evil Zombie Strider

Good entry. smiley - ok I know I played this game under a different name, but I can't remember it... Oh well.

smiley - footprints


A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 10

Wayfarer -MadForumArtist, Keeper of bad puns, Greeblet with Goo beret, Tangential One

you moved it?! smiley - yikessmiley - cry


A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 11

Wayfarer -MadForumArtist, Keeper of bad puns, Greeblet with Goo beret, Tangential One

disregard previous post pleasesmiley - blush


A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 12

Wayfarer -MadForumArtist, Keeper of bad puns, Greeblet with Goo beret, Tangential One

glak. and that, my friends, is *exactly* why we're supposed to close off threads...


A703603 - Foxy – A Playground Game For The Young At Heart

Post 13

Wayfarer -MadForumArtist, Keeper of bad puns, Greeblet with Goo beret, Tangential One

and why it's a good idea to think before postingsmiley - erm


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more