A Conversation for AGG/GAG - 1

Bookmark

Post 1

Gone again

This is little more than an expression of interest in (abd support for) what you're trying to do. smiley - smiley It also means that a link to this page will appear on my home page, and I'll be able to find you again!

Pattern-chaser

"Who cares, wins"


Bookmark

Post 2

~ jwf ~ scribblo ergo sum

smiley - cheers


Bookmark

Post 3

Post Team

Another one!
smiley - cheers

shazz smiley - magic


Facts! Don't talk to me about...

Post 4

Gone again

OK, this is me introducing my favourite hobby horse - the insistence of the Guide guidelines on entries being "factual". smiley - cross

Philosophically, it can be shown that virtually nothing is factual, but that's a bit too dry for RL usage! smiley - smiley Nevertheless, there are many major topics - religion and politics to name but two - that cannot be discussed under the existing guidelines. Well, I suppose one could write "B. Eelzebub founded the Church of Satan on 12th February 1473", in the style of a typical history book (i.e. tedious and not very informative), but what use is that? smiley - doh

I believe that such topics, about which nothing substantial can be said without expressing an *opinion* (gasp! smiley - winkeye), belong in the Guide. I assume you lot agree? Or do you have a different agenda?

Pattern-chaser

"Who cares, wins"


Facts! Don't talk to me about...

Post 5

The Ghost of Polidari

Just floating by to bookmark and make the point that's been made 1000 times before:

Earth : Mostly Harmless
What's the best way to get a drink from a Vogon? Stick your fingers down his throat.

That was the thing about the original guide, and what was said about it in the book's introduction - it wasn't a book based on fact but a book that could be wildly inaccurate on occasion, (or silly, or stupid, or strange, or make no sense what-so-ever). When people come here they kind of know that...


Facts! Don't talk to me about...

Post 6

Martin Harper

I have to agree - we should split the guide into Life, The Universe, Everything, and Everything Else. Well, I reckon anyway... smiley - smiley


Key: Complain about this post

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more