A Conversation for The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 1

Phreako

http://www.bbc.co.uk/h2g2/guide/A599619

Please feel free to leave comments or suggestions


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 2

Gnomon - time to move on

A Classic Goo story. smiley - winkeye

This is good. It is the perfect combination of tragedy and comedy. While no doubt it was sad that all those people died, there is something inherently funny about a wave of molasses engulfing a city.

There is one sentence that reads as if you left out the word "not":

"claiming that the acident was caused by a structural weakness but that bomb-throwing anarchists were responsible for the mess"

This should surely be "was not caused by a structural weakness".

There are one or two minor misprints:

Massachusettes --> Massachusetts
municiple --> municipal
ambulences --> ambulances

The phrase "plunged off of the broken tracks" should be changed to "plunged off the broken tracks" as we are using British English in the guide.


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 3

Phreako

Thank you changes being made now


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 4

Phreako

donesmiley - smiley


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 5

Gnomon - time to move on

Reading through it again, I have a question. You suggest that the molasses was cooled by the cold winter air as it moved through the streets, causing it to become more viscous and slower. This suggests that the molasses started out hotter than the surrounding air. But at the end, you suggest the reason it exploded was because the surrounding air temperature rose suddenly from 2 deg F to 40 deg F, which would suggest that the molasses was at ambient temperature.

Was there any other source of heat involved? Was the molasses being heated in the tank to keep it from freezing? Does molasses generate heat if it ferments?


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 6

Phreako

Thank you for pointing that out to me. I believe that the molasses began to congeal later on as the temperature began to drop. It slowed down simply because it just lost its initial momentum as most things tend to do. The slowing down actually had nothing to do with the congealing. The congealing didn't actually come until later on. Perhaps I should correct that part so as not to confuse others.


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 7

Phryne- 'Best Suppurating Actress'

Thankyou Phreako for writing on such a great subject. smiley - smiley
This article should be included because, amongst other reasons, no one believes me when I tell them about it.
You could mention the story that molasses is still supposed to ooze from pavement cracks on hot days... (is this true? A nice postscript nontheless.)


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 8

Phreako

I didn't believe the story the first time somebody told it too me eithersmiley - smiley


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 9

Phryne- 'Best Suppurating Actress'

It does have something Pythonesque about it, certainly. smiley - smiley
And when I first heard it was about the same time that 'Treacle People' was on TV, which didn't help.


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 10

Phreako

smiley - laugh
But it is actually true


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 11

Phreako

It just took me a little while to beleive it though.
I think maybe it is the tale about still being able to smell molasses on hot days and about it seeping through the cracks in the pavement that make it seem like another urban legend.
You know how there is always something like that in urban legends.
Thats why I never like to include that part when I tell people because its not really true and it makes it less beleivable


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 12

Phryne- 'Best Suppurating Actress'

Fair enough. It does seem like a story told by old Boston-dwellers to keep their grandchildren quiet.


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 13

Phreako

I hope the whole molasses flood thing never just becomes an urban legend that nobody believes because unlike the urban legends, this actually happened.


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 14

unremarkable: Lurker, OMFC, LPAS

wow! never heard this one before. didnt believe it at first, gotta admit. I'm a massachusetts native, too. 1919...well heck, thats right after the last time the red sox won a world series... smiley - smiley


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 15

Orcus

All I can say on this entry is:

smiley - footprints

I bet identifying fingerprints of burglars was considerably easier for a while smiley - laugh

A cracking story smiley - ok

smiley - cheers


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 16

Phreako

smiley - laugh


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 17

Mr. Cogito

Great entry. I heard this story when I went to school in Boston. Although it was a horrible tragedy as well, the absurdity of it makes me smile. I really don't see a problem with this getting into the Guide. smiley - smiley


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 18

There is only one thing worse than being Gosho, and that is not being Gosho

I'd give the smiley - ok if it was within my power - I was riveted from beginning to end smiley - smiley One thing I'd work on though is overuse of the phrase "sticky goo". Maybe you could find a few variations such as "glutinous mass of molasses" or "gooey mess" smiley - smiley


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 19

Phreako

good idea
Thankssmiley - smiley


A599619 - The Boston Molasses Tragedy of 1919

Post 20

Marjin, After a long time of procrastination back lurking

Indeed a great story about a tragedy. A manmade version of Herculaneum after the Vesuvius outbreak.
It should have been a certain winner in "Funniest Home movies", if any should have been made.

Like "stickey goo" the word "molasses" itself seems a bit overused, especially in "The path of destruction", but I cannot see immediatly how to replace it.


Key: Complain about this post