A Conversation for The Neptune 'Plant'

Peer Review: A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 1

KB

Entry: The Neptune 'Plant' - A38113409
Author: King Bomba - U891566

It's about time I showed my face in here again. Links will follow, all suggestions and comments welcome.


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 2

Cyzaki

Interesting! I'd never heard of this plant before (maybe because I don't read newspapers or magazines, except for F1 Racing and I don't think it's ever been advertised in there...) but this entry explained it all very well.

One small nit pick:

"They haven't classified it in any botanical category, because quite botanists have no interest in such things"

Perhaps you meant 'quite honestly botanists...'?

smiley - panda


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 3

KB

Oh, thanks for that one. I don't know where it slipped in from. It might have started out as 'quite simply because botanists...'


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 4

Cyzaki

So am I understanding this right if I take it to mean that you think you're buying a plant you never have to water, and you're actually buying the dead skeleton of some algae?

smiley - panda


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 5

Cyzaki

Can you tell I'm really interested by this? I just had a google and a Neptune Plant, complete with insect-repelling properties and its own earthenware pot, can be yours for the low, low price of just £8.99!

To be honest, I'd be much more interested in buying one if they said it was coral-like algae remains smiley - laugh

smiley - panda


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 6

KB

Yes, that's about the size of it. I'm pleased it has tickled your interest Cyzaki! smiley - ok


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 7

Cyzaki

During my googling I read that the Neptune Plant sold to unwitting magazine-readers and internet shoppers is often the by-product of North Sea trawlers, and that it's also called the Air Fern. Also that they are usually dyed green. Don't know if you want to add these snippets to the entry?

As these are skeletons of algae, do they feel soft and plant-like to the touch, or hard like coral?

It's almost making me want one for the novelty value, although I think on the whole I prefer real plants...

smiley - panda


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 8

Malabarista - now with added pony

smiley - laughsmiley - cool

So this is what you've had up your sleeve!

If you want a real "resurrection plant" you're better off with a Rose of Jericho http://www.fisheaters.com/roseofjericho.html

One little nitpick - if I get you right it's not even Sertularia argentea itself that's being sold as a "plant", but its dried - what, husks? (Exo)skeletons?


This scam seems to be similar to "Sea Monkeys" smiley - laugh


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 9

Cyzaki

Nah, Sea Monkeys are great, they're actually alive and they grow and have babies - I had some! I loved watching those shrimpy things diddling around their tank!

smiley - panda


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 10

Malabarista - now with added pony

smiley - laughBut they're just little shrimpy things - the rest is hype! Might as well keep a tank full of water fleas.


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 11

U168592

Can I come to your Water Flea Circus some time Mal? smiley - winkeye

Nice Entry KB, you steered clear of delving into 'other' advertising misnomers, thank you smiley - smiley

There's probably some nit-pickery to be had, but I can't be bothered with that.

Succint, to the point, informative and - well- good stuff smiley - smiley


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 12

Nigel *ACE*

Hello KingBomba smiley - smiley.

It is an interesting entry which I knew nothing about. I feel it will be much easier to understand when you put your links in, perhaps a link with a picture in too will be good smiley - ok.

All the best.

Nigel smiley - cheers


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 13

McKay The Disorganised

Good to see you've weeded out the truth behind this little beauty.

smiley - cider


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 14

KB

A crap pun's never unwelcome with me, McKay. smiley - ok

Right. Links added, including a link to a picture courtesy of the Marine Life Encyclopedia.

Mentioned dying it green and being trawled up from the sea bed.


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 15

Malabarista - now with added pony

Except that it's "dyeing" it green. smiley - winkeye


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 16

KB

You're missing the point, Mal. You're meant to help me with errors in the Entry, not the PR thread. smiley - tongueout


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 17

Malabarista - now with added pony

smiley - whistle


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 18

BeowulfShaffer

I looks goof to me


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 19

BigAl Patron Saint of Left Handers Keeper of the Glowing Pickle and Monobrows

Is that a Freudian slip smiley - erm


A38113409 - The Neptune 'Plant'

Post 20

BeowulfShaffer

no its a I keep breaking my policie against posting at 1am slip
I meant it looks good


Key: Complain about this post