A Conversation for Life, literature, and how to avoid them both (the h2g2 book index)

Misplaced and mispelled Authors

Post 1

Gavroche

Under Science Fiction

Anne McCaffrey probably belongs under Fantasy (unless she's written something other than the Dragonriders of Pern series)

Under Fantasy

Jeany Wurts should be Jenny Wurts, I think. (I haven't read her, but she has co-written a few with Raymond Feist and I vaguely remember seeing her name on the cover...I could be wrong)

Under Humour

Joseph Heller, while his works were definitely humourous, probably belongs under Classics. PG Woodhouse might belong there too.

CS Lewis either belongs under Classics, or Fantasy or SF. (He wrote both fantasy and science fiction and religious essays...so perhaps it is easiest to classify him under Classics)

Under Horror

HP Lovecraft also probably deserves Classics. I consider him as important in the horror genre as Poe.

Under Thriller/Adventure
Delete entirely, and move Crichton to Science Fiction. This might get a few raised eyebrows, but he definitely began as a Science Fiction writer (Sphere, Andromeda Strain) and I think every novel he's written has had some scientific underpinning.

Though perhaps the category shouldn't be deleted, and Ian Fleming should be moved there (James Bond novels)

under General
Piers Anthony -- Should be Fantasy
Madeline l'Engle -- Should be Fantasy
Steven Brust -- Should be Fantasy
Marion Zimmer Bradley -- Should be Fantasy

Under Classics
I guess everybody there belongs there. Personal taste I guess.

it's
JD Salinger
Kurt Vonnegut Jr
and Ernest Hemingway
(and if we have Hemingway, we should include William Faulkner)
and it is Edgar Allan Poe (two A's in Allan)

Poetry
Walt Whitman (One 'T')
Perhaps EE Cummings should be spelt: ee cummings, but that's nit-picky.

I'd move Robert Graves to General. He may have written poetry, but I think he is best known for the novel I, Claudius.

That's it for now. smiley - smiley





Misplaced and mispelled Authors

Post 2

Gavroche

smiley - smiley


Key: Complain about this post

Misplaced and mispelled Authors

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more