h2g2 The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy: Earth Edition

Always a good idea to click the 'Not for review' button when creating an entry that is not likely to be submitted to any Review Forum

Good idea to subscribe to the forum of any entry you create too, which I don't always do

Traveller in Time viewing far
"And why should it not be suitable for any review forum? I do not mind for anybody to post their comments about it.

Taking the rules for potential edited entries it could be a candidate! It is a real life subject using factual data. Well perhaps there is a tiny bit of fantasy in the 'weather' and 'cloud' naming bit, any suggestions for better fitting words?

Well, admitted, I would not think of having this one edited, however you never know what happens.

Creating entries is a routine for me as well as checking the forum. It should be, as I have written enough of them to get the hang of it."

Well, speaking as a Scout, it certainly wouldn't be suitable for PR, although I can see how it would be favourably accepted in the AWW

However, even when writing an entry I plan to submit to PR, I always make it 'not for review' until I'm ready to submit it (case in point A2318069) because, again as a Scout, we're tired of Researchers submitting other people's entries to PR without first reading TFM

Traveller in Time on top
"Well, I may be lucky then , none of my entries so far has been submitted by anyone .

And I certainly disagree with most scouts on the matter: material for the Edited Guide.
For instance < A2161504 > the first message has all an entry should have.

The first part is brilliant, there is a perfect balance between
'We do not want your garbage here' and
'nice poetry, somebody will appreciate this'
As an entry it could be seen indexed under /communication /messages /rejections, just to give an example.

They have added the second message since the postings.
I think it is more negative not the delicacy of the first one, however it does contain the usefull hint to re move the entry.
"