A Conversation for How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Peer Review: A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 1

swl

Entry: How To Grow Your Own Cigars - A25677309
Author: SWL™ ' - U1775547

I'd appreciate the feedback from any gardeners as I certainly do not have green fingers.


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 2

h5ringer

What a brilliant Entry smiley - applause I never knew that this was possible in the UK.

A small question. In the last paragraph, should it be 'Duty' or 'duty'? The HMRC letter implies the latter.

<> I would have put a comma after 'overnight'.

Again, well done SWL smiley - towel


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 3

swl

I'm not sure if it's 'Duty' or 'duty' to be honest.


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 4

Magwitch - My name is Mags and I am funky.

Why did I know this would be you, SWL? smiley - laugh

Another goody, as ever. A couple of bits and a question or two (can't find much else wrong smiley - sadface)

Under Drying

smiley - birodry them then cure them. ---> either comma after them or 'and'

Just a thought, but can you not dry them in batches in an airing cupboard, or would that not work as well?

Under Rolling your Cigars

smiley - biroat a low heat for about 45 minutes. ---> How low? It's lowest setting or slightly higher - we need to know smiley - winkeye

Why do you need a former? Have you not already 'formed' most of your cigar beforehand?

btw I smoke hand-rolled ciggies (however, they are not rolled on the thighs of nubile Cuban women smiley - smiley)


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 5

swl

Changes and additional explanations added.

I've always been dubious about the idea of hand-rolled on the thighs of nubile Cuban women. For a start, you need a large flat area so I shudder to think of the legs that large, flat thighs are attached to.


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 6

toybox

smiley - cool Entry!

However I'd say the title needs rephrasing: it's not really the cigars which you grow after all.


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 7

toybox

Oh, and you could link to your potato Entry, since tobacco and potato are related plants (both are Solanaceae apparently).

smiley - cheers


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 8

Primeval Mudd (formerly Roymondo)

The duty thing is duty with a little 'd'.


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 9

swl

Thanks chaps smiley - cheers That's allowed me to introduce a little levity into the piece.

We'll see how long it's allowed to stay in smiley - winkeye


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 10

Magwitch - My name is Mags and I am funky.

Ok, smiley - cool

More clarification required (at least from me smiley - silly)

Under Growing Tobacco

smiley - smiley The British climate is ideal for growing tobacco, if you avoid the frosts. --> can you just throw a horticultural fleece over the plant , or is it the roots that are frost sensitive?

smiley - smiley For a good Havana cigar you will not surprisingly need Havana seeds. --> ...not, surprisingly, need...

Under Transplantation

What if you *don't* have a greenhouse? Would a coldframe do in certain areas of the world? would you need to build one? Would closed-end cloches do?

Under Planting

smiley - smiley especially loose and sandy soils but if you have a lot of clay in the plot, ---> comma after soils and also after but

smiley - smileyby mixing in some peat. --> some sand also?

Under Forming

smiley - biggrinThat former thing makes more sense now smiley - ta

Under Rolling Your Cigars

smiley - smileyabout the same temperature as you'd use for warming plates before a meal -->Once again smiley - cheers

Still a damned fine read. smiley - bigeyes



A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 11

vogonpoet (AViators at A13264670)

Super entry, perfect title.

Question: Is the comparison of the EU to the Borg deliberate?? Seems a little bit harsh on EU expansion policy... certainly made me laugh though... problem being the Borg link isn't to an edited entry, so you can't leave it in probably...

Whoa, to much ellipsis smiley - runvp


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 12

swl

Curses!! You spotted it smiley - sadface

Changes made to some of the grammar, clarifications made and ongoing linking is... ongoing.


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 13

vogonpoet (AViators at A13264670)

smiley - smiley Sensual indeed...

I liked the leeches though smiley - ok


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 14

Felonious Monk - h2g2s very own Bogeyman

Have you actually done this? I don't think you have. The reason I say this is because you'd have mentioned that the species of tobacco plant to grow is Nicotiana tabacum, but most commercial seed companies in the UK offer only either N. alata/affinis or N. sylvestris (both of which I have grown). You could probably get away with N. sylvestris as it has huge leaves but you'd get tiny and really crap cigars from N. alata.


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 15

swl

No I haven't FM, thanks for the info. I'll update it later. Any other tips?


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 16

pailaway - (an utterly gratuitous link in the evolutionary chain)


Interesting read smiley - ok

I didn't understand the Ministry of Thievery link though - perhaps it's a UK thing?

smiley - cheers


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 17

lil ~ Auntie Giggles with added login ~ returned


He is refering to our Chancellor and the Treasury Dept.. smiley - biggrin


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 18

benjaminpmoore

How's this one coming swl?


A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 19

Rudest Elf


"How's this one coming swl?" Very well, by the looks of things.

Just a few points:

Drying last sentence: [leaves]

Making A Former 1st line: [While]

Making A Former 1st line: [While]

Rolling Your Cigars 2nd line: (to hand in case it is a little too dry.)?

Rolling Your Cigars 2nd para 5th line: [while]

Legal Note 2nd para 1st line: The linked Entry is not an Edited Guide Entry so it's highly unlikely to be acceptable. There is, however, an Entry that ends with a section on The Borg: 'Cyborgs in Science Fiction A1113788 (Edited)' - What do you reckon?


smiley - reindeer

Legal Note last line: The '2' goes before the full stop.




A25677309 - How To Grow Your Own Cigars

Post 20

benjaminpmoore

Finished SWL or are you still working on this one?


Key: Complain about this post