A Conversation for Those Who Can't Edit, Critique

Just walking the dogs

Post 1

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

Dear ZachsMind, I was out walking the dogs and happened upon your fine article. I would like to extend to you an invitation to
visit my home page. I have posted an article on the 'Curate's Egg' which, in a way, says much the same things as your article. From my page I also offer group trips for people waiting to be abducted by aliens and trips to pacific islands for the religious. Often served are beautiful kumquats, an interesting fruit, you eat the peel and throw away the fruit, and much, much, more. Occassionly chocolate smiley - fish are available. My door is always wedged half open for visitors. Perhaps we shall see you sometime later this year. As always Loonytunes


Just walking the dogs

Post 2

Zach Garland

Lovely page. Personally I don't tend to wait for the aliens to abduct me. I have more important things to do. They know where to find me. The curate egg thing is a very good point. It took my brain a while to wrap itself around the idea, but that's just because I'm slower than mollasses. Very good point.


Just walking the dogs

Post 3

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

As Vegiman pointed out to me another similie would be: One bad apple ruins the other apples. One bad paragraph could ruin an otherwise fine entry.


Just walking the dogs

Post 4

Zach Garland

I'm not sure if that's a similie. I think a similie is something like: "her hair shone like the noonday sun and her eyes were as if the night sky were encompassed within them."

Or maybe that's metaphor? I can't tell anymore.


Just walking the dogs

Post 5

Jim Lynn

A simile is an expression comparing something with something else, usually using 'like' or 'as'.

A metaphor is a figure of speech in which an expression is used to refer to something that it does not literally denote in order to suggest a similarity

(thanks to http://www.dictionary.com for the definitions and the correct spelling of 'simile'.


Just walking the dogs

Post 6

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

Thank-you for the English lesson. If everybody knew things like that then editors would be like fully clothed figures of fun in a Caligula movie.


Just walking the dogs

Post 7

vegiman:-)

Thanks to Jim:
for the www.dicornhairy tip. I will use it as my speeling is not what I would like it to be.

Any chance of a spell checker added to the forum editors. NO NO say's Jim pulling his hair out,"don't you think I have enough to do".

vegimansmiley - smiley


Just walking the dogs

Post 8

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

Adds his tiny voice to the call for a spell check option


Just walking the dogs

Post 9

Zach Garland

I'd like to vote against the spell checker. This thing is slow enough to load on my machine at home as it is. A spell checker would just slow things down more. Besides, spelling errors gives a more personalized feel to the whole place and just adds to the fun!


Just walking the dogs

Post 10

vegiman:-)

Yes I suppose you are right in that respect. But to the self conscious like myself, it would be a great help. A spell checker could be incorporated with the "Preview Message" and highlight unrecognised words. This would not slow the rest of the program down.

I always seem to see spelling errors and mistypes just after I post the darn thing. vegimansmiley - smiley


Just walking the dogs

Post 11

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

We would never agree on which English dictionary the spell-checker was based on. American, British, Australian, New Zealand. South Africa, Tonga, Canada, or maybe to make it real interesting Mandarin Chinese.


Just walking the dogs

Post 12

vegiman:-)

My TWO PENNUTH
At:
http://www.h2g2.com/P120565
vegimansmiley - smiley


Just walking the dogs

Post 13

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

I submitted one for you to critique team


Just walking the dogs

Post 14

vegiman:-)

Hey something is going on at:
http://www.h2g2.com/P130852
Join in on the CRITIQUE FUN RUN and excersise your brain, you don't even have to leave your seat.

I Would Appreciate Everybody spreading the word around.

vegimansmiley - smiley


Just walking the dogs

Post 15

Lonnytunes - Winter Is Here

Spreading it like vegemite Vegiman


Just walking the dogs

Post 16

MacDaddy of Nothing in Particular

hello, had a scan of your convo after submitting(dont like those connotations already)to the edidtors a fairly important piece of literature re cooking pies whilst drunk. Had a look at editorial
in the thoughtfully provided & intrinsic search thingy, & ended up here. Good ideas (SPESHALLY THE SPELLCHEKA 4ME)
Is it really that bad, I mean in terms of submitting-no reply-undefined criteria etc. Bugger,I thought it was really fun to become
a "researcher" for the book I've always cherished.
As for someone who han't really had time nor inclination to go into chat rooms its ah...different 2be typing so much but as I said i like the concepts expressed in your tetatet. Keep up the forum. it,s apparently been weeks since you last posted, & check out the recipes 4 drunk carbon based lifeforms entry i've scribbled just so it says that someones been there.after all in space no one can here you and you've only got 30 seconds or so until you get improbably picked up.cheers. ps. vegeboy, your not from oz are you?


Just walking the dogs

Post 17

vegiman:-)

Na Me Old Cobber.

Check out my page by clicking on my name at the top of this post - you will see where I am from.

As for your article - if you want it proof read by other researchers then enter it in the Critique Fun Run - info also on my page. If you get lost, say Hi on my page and I will try and assist. Oh did I say pop over to my page - I've forgotten.
Catcha vegimansmiley - smiley


Just walking the dogs

Post 18

Zach Garland

A lot has happened since I wrote that piece, MacDaddy. Vegiman is admittedly THE man to talk to regarding the Critique Fun Run. You can get the support and community interaction that will help improve your future guide entry submissions there.

AFTER I wrote that piece about field researchers critiquing each other, Mark Moxon put into effect a project that he hoped at the time would solve h2g2.com's backlog problem regarding submitted guide entries. He recruited me and nine other field researchers to operate as SubEditors. Our job is to go through the backlog and help fulfill the promise h2g2.com made to its participants. I must admit it feels good to be a part of that.

When I wrote "Those Who Can't Edit, Critique" I didn't know that less than two weeks later I'd be editing myself. I quickly ran short on time to make the critique fun run thing happen. Vegiman and many other very resourceful field researchers took the idea I had and made it happen, and I am very grateful for that. It's hard to believe that was three months ago. It's flashed by like a whirlwind.

I just wish I had had time to be a more integral part in the development of the Critique Fun Run, but things just went topsy turvy. For me it's now, "Those Who Can't Critique, Edit."

Life has a way of keeping me off balance. smiley - smiley


Key: Complain about this post