This is the Message Centre for NPY

"Classic" artists?

Post 21

Kaz

Like any song by the Feeling for instance. smiley - grr

Unfortunately I never liked the Feeling to start with (the lead singer's voice gets on my nerves for a start) but I just can't get away from them on the radio. And that flippin song by Kid Rock, where they messed about with two of my favourite songs. I noticed a couple of DJs have been playing the originals of Werewolves Of London and Sweet Home Alabama in protest. smiley - ok


"Classic" artists?

Post 22

T.B. Falsename ACE: [stercus venio] I have learned from my mistakes, and feel I could repeat them exactly.

Re the following,
Coldplay? the music's ok, but Chris martin really micturates me off.
and James Blunt? Rhymes with...


smiley - cheers


"Classic" artists?

Post 23

NPY

Been hearing that "singing Sweet Home Alabama all summer long" song loads on the radio recently. Not that I think it's a bad song, but would be nice to get the original at times.


"Classic" artists?

Post 24

emo_kid- that's meee alright!

I like the feeling but that's me....it's your opinion and you don't have to like them but I just want to say that I like them, I don't like all the other versions of good songs, I don't like the way that a band goes through the trouble of making a song and some lazy smiley - bleep does another vesion of it!! It's highly annoying!!


"Classic" artists?

Post 25

NPY

Don't start me on cover versions!!! Especially bad ones. If you *insist* on doing a cover, you *must* do it well and do justice to the work the composer and original artit did, especially if they're the same person.


"Classic" artists?

Post 26

T.B. Falsename ACE: [stercus venio] I have learned from my mistakes, and feel I could repeat them exactly.

Keltica did a very good cover of Run to The Hills and most people think, those that know of it, that the Pixies cover of Silver is the original version, but it was originally recorded and released by The Breeders. Also a lot of people thinkthat Jimi Hendrixes version of all along the watchtower is the original and best and not, as is blatantly obvious, a butchered mockery of Bob Dylan's original.


smiley - cheers


"Classic" artists?

Post 27

Kaz

I love Jimis version of all along the watchtower. Newton Faulkner's done an ace version of massive attack's teardrop.


"Classic" artists?

Post 28

NPY

Few people do a better version of a song than the original. equally, few can do it justice.

Westlife *really* got on my nerves for constantly doing covers. Not that they did them really badly, but just that there were so many of them. got insane.


"Classic" artists?

Post 29

emo_kid- that's meee alright!

Don't think it was a good version, the only way to enjoy music (I think) is to listen to the *origional* version!! smiley - grr


"Classic" artists?

Post 30

Kaz

What? You don't like all along the watchtower?


"Classic" artists?

Post 31

emo_kid- that's meee alright!

Nah!!


"Classic" artists?

Post 32

NPY

So long as no one actually killed it.


"Classic" artists?

Post 33

emo_kid- that's meee alright!

hhhhmmmmm.....!!


"Classic" artists?

Post 34

Kaz

Have you actually heard it??

...I'm sorry I'm just so flabbergasted, I have never spoken to anyone who doesn't like Jimis version

you're not taking the mick are you?


"Classic" artists?

Post 35

T.B. Falsename ACE: [stercus venio] I have learned from my mistakes, and feel I could repeat them exactly.

I'm not when I say that I much prefer Dylan's original version


smiley - cheers


"Classic" artists?

Post 36

Kaz

Well I like Dylan's too, but I don't think I'd necessarily listen to it out of choice. Even though he automatically gets smiley - cool points for writing it.


"Classic" artists?

Post 37

NPY

Yeah, definately gets points for writing it. Dylan does have his own unique style, doesn't he?


"Classic" artists?

Post 38

T.B. Falsename ACE: [stercus venio] I have learned from my mistakes, and feel I could repeat them exactly.

You mean his writing style or the nasally atonal way he sings?


smiley - cheers


"Classic" artists?

Post 39

NPY

Well both really.


"Classic" artists?

Post 40

emo_kid- that's meee alright!

No i'm not taking the mick, and yes I have heard it before that's why I think it's so smiley - bleep!! No offence it's just my opinion!!


Key: Complain about this post