A Conversation for The Highlander Franchise and Phenomenon
Peer Review
Mr Prophet (General Purpose Genre Guru) Started conversation Jun 19, 2001
This article has now entered peer review, where it has been received with total silence. If you like it - or even if you don't but have constructive comments - why not make them over in peer review, and keep my poor entry from disappearing without trace.
The Prophet
Lucky You ! ! !
Monsignore Pizzafunghi Bosselese Posted Jun 19, 2001
... starting to claim after two days of silence...
May I draw your kind attention to this?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/h2g2/guide/A487253
After going through some similar experience and making up my mind, I thought it was time to do something, devoted lots of time to trawling through Peer Review and finally (after some months) applied to become a Scout, so here I am. You seem to be a professional critic, so how about /you/ giving feedback to others?
Bossel, Scout
Lucky You ! ! !
Mr Prophet (General Purpose Genre Guru) Posted Jun 20, 2001
Heh-he; OK, I confess. I got an uncanny swiftness of positive feedback on my Ninja article (I put it forward about a fortnight ago and it's pending) and as a result, I've become addicted to feedback. Prior to that, I hardly ever looked at Peer Review, I must confess, but I've been going more and more often, and not just to check on my own stuff.
Sorry if I came off as whiny, but it struck me; is there any other way for people to know that an entry they're reading has been entered into peer review? I ask because I think that it would be good to have something like that. Particularly, it came to mind because someone commented that they read my article on Elizabeth Bathory and thought that it had already been edited.
The Prophet.
Lucky You ! ! !
Monsignore Pizzafunghi Bosselese Posted Jun 22, 2001
No, there's no way of telling that an entry is under Peer Review, other than a note within the entry, or a posting (eg: 'Peer Review') hanging off from the entry.
Recommended and Edited entries /are/ discernible: recommended ones show a 'recommended' in the upper right corner, Edited ones have two name fields, like:
written and researched by:
ABC
Edited by:
XYZ
Key: Complain about this post
Peer Review
More Conversations for The Highlander Franchise and Phenomenon
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."