A Conversation for Ask h2g2

Ironic

Post 1

spebchob

Are any of the lyrics in the song "Ironic" an example of irony?


Ironic

Post 2

queeglesproggit

Absolutely not! I think they're actually paradox-es. My english tutor recently went into great length on this subject, but unfortunately I can't have been listening at the time!

I do have a friend who would quite happily strangler her on site, however, irony/paradox or no.

smiley - tongueout


Ironic

Post 3

Chili

I guess so, wouldn´t make much if not...

Chili, trying to find the lyrics for the song... brb smiley - winkeye


Ironic

Post 4

Chili

Great, just great even if I use preview, I am loosing whole...

Should definitely, drink less, work less, sleep more...

It should read : Guess so, woulnd´t make much sense if not..

Chili, hung over and still looking for those lyrics...


Ironic

Post 5

JAR (happy to be back, but where's Ping?)

Chili: If you find the lyrics, would you post them, or make a link to where the lyrics are? Unless of course, this violates copyrights and such. I just think it would help the discussion...

JAR


Ironic

Post 6

Is mise Duncan

In my opinion, most of them are just downright unfortunate.
As I recall the lyrics go...
"It's like rain on your wedding day,
a free ride when you've already paid,
good advice that you just can't take..."

and then theres a verse something like:
"It's like a traffic jam when you're already late,
a no smoking sign on your cigarette break,
10000 spoons when all you need is a knife,
meeting the man of your dreams and then meeting his beautiful wife"

The bit about the guy in the planbe crash might be ironic - if he's a retired airline safety officer or something....

While we're on (off) the subject - what exactly is Shania Twain looking for in a bloke...?


Ironic

Post 7

All I want for Xmas is a Dukla Prague away kit

Please don't get me started on that Canadian harpy. My mood can be altogether blackened further by her mindless wailings. Couldn't even term the lines she wrote as 'most ingenious paradox'.


Ironic

Post 8

Gnomon - time to move on

The word "irony" has a number of different uses. The most common where I come from is where something happens which would normally be good but in the particular circumstances turns out to be either bad or of no use. The cavalry arriving after the injuns have wiped out the wagon train would be an example. In the song, I believe there's a bit which goes "the free tickets when you've already paid". This is ironic in that sense.

Another sense of the word irony is "an incongruity between the actual resuly and the normal or expected result". This might cover the cases of "the black fly in your chardonnay" and "rain on your wedding day", although here in Ireland, the last one is the expected result.


Removed

Post 9

Chili

This post has been removed.


Ironic

Post 10

queeglesproggit

Shania Twain should be hung, drawn and quartered into tiny tiny little pieces (as should anything remotely related to country & western but that's just my opinion) smiley - bigeyessmiley - tongueout


Ironic

Post 11

All I want for Xmas is a Dukla Prague away kit

Shania Twain? Hopefully a better tailor, but unfortunately, as she's joined the 'Goody Two Shoes' brigade. Altogether now, ' You don't drink, don't smoke, what do you do?.....'


Ironic

Post 12

queeglesproggit

I don't remember the line after that one, my lyrical knowledge is obviously far behind your wealth of information. Though it's nice to see Shania has visited a hairdresser in the last five years.


There ya have it...

Post 13

queeglesproggit

There are a couple that may be ironic, but the majority are either paradox (es? unsure of the plural, is it paradoxi??), coincidence, or just plain misfortune. However, I shall have to return another time, these connections are slowing down to something akin to an arthritic snail, and as I am about as technically proficient as a slightly bewildered slice of lemon, I am unsure as to whether this is due to my PC, h2g2 or the internet in general. Adios smiley - smiley


There ya have it...

Post 14

Chili

Quartering Shania? What a waste, rip out her tongue and vocal chords should be enough...

Chili, loves to watch her videos w/o sound smiley - winkeye


There ya have it...

Post 15

spebchob

What's Shania Twain got to do with it?


There ya have it...

Post 16

Gnomon - time to move on

Particularly since it was Alanis Morisette who sang this song!


There ya have it...

Post 17

spebchob

Now that's ironic! Or is it?
Or is this? - I saw an ad which was a big picture of a zebra. The slogan?
Born to be noticed.
Ironic or just stupid?


Zebras

Post 18

Gnomon - time to move on

The strange thing about the zebra is that it is the only thing in the savannahs with highly contrasting black and white stripes. This should not be a good example of protective camouflage. But in fact a zebra is perfectly camouflaged when standing in front of ... a herd of zebras!


Zebras

Post 19

Chili

Isn´t it ironic, that talking about the lyrics of this song is so boring, that we have made it to zebras, via Shania Twain, in a matter of minutes?

Chili...


Back to the begining...

Post 20

Is mise Duncan

No - it's not ironic..it's just plain suspicious...
Guy drops dead the day after he wins the lottery despite having made it to 98 with all his faculties? Suspicious.
Guy who is afraid to fly takes a plane journey haviong first kissed his kids goodbye and it crashes..and he's not screaming like everyone else? Suspicious.


Key: Complain about this post