A Conversation for Ask h2g2
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
2legs - Hey, babe, take a walk on the wild side... Posted Jun 30, 2010
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
2legs - Hey, babe, take a walk on the wild side... Posted Sep 6, 2010
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
shagbark Posted Sep 6, 2010
Merriam Webster dictionary pronounces it to rhyme with Don
Dictionary dot com pronounces the food rhyming with moan and the place rhyming with Spoon.
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
A Super Furry Animal Posted Sep 7, 2010
Gosh, how did I miss this conversation?
It's pronounced to rhyme with stone, as any fule kno.
Someone mentioned
>> That's as bad as someone in our office who uses the word pacific instead of specific.. drives me quietly mad! <<
Which gives me the perfect opportunity to post this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c3y0CD2CoCs
RF
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
fords - number 1 all over heaven Posted Sep 7, 2010
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
Gnomon - time to move on Posted Sep 7, 2010
The answer to this depends on where you are, so you should ask people to give their approximate location, and plot all the answers on a big map. I think you'll find there's a sharp dividing line between the gones and the drones.
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
Mu Beta Posted Sep 7, 2010
I also anticipated Post 105 before clicking the link.
The sad thing when I first saw it is that, even before David Mitchell spoke, I was sitting in my wingback chair, rocking back and forth, muttering: "aitch, AITCH"...
B
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
Icy North Posted Sep 7, 2010
The flimsy excuse people give for saying 'haitch' is that the sound should always begin with the letter it's describing.
This leads us to a whole new alphabet, including:
Feff
Haitch
Lell
Memm
Nenn
Quoo
Rarr
Sess
Wubble-you (my favourite)
Xexx
and Yai
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
Gnomon - time to move on Posted Sep 7, 2010
I believe that the correct name for the letter is 'haitch', but I can't prove it, so I'll have to do some research...
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
shagbark Posted Sep 7, 2010
one source said it was originally from
Heth: the fence, It was a "deep throat" (pharyngeal) consonant. The Greeks used it for the vowel eta (H), but the Romans used it for H.
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
TRiG (Ireland) A dog, so bade in office Posted Sep 7, 2010
It's 'haitch' in the Republic of Ireland, 'aitch' in Britain, and I'm told there's a Catholic/Protestant divide in the North.
I don't know about other English-speaking areas or the USA.
I'd rhyme /scone/ with /gone/, but my accent is weird. I think most people around here would rhyme it with /lone/.
And I agree with 2legs: savoury scones can taste excellent with cheese. My mother sometimes bakes them with little bits of cheddar in the mix.
TRiG.
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
2legs - Hey, babe, take a walk on the wild side... Posted Sep 7, 2010
Savory scones should always* be made with some cheese in the mix; a bit* of grated parmazan, and a bit of good strong chedder, and then some chedder to 'top' it no prizes for what I'm going to bake tommorrow alongside fresh bread...
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
Icy North Posted Sep 7, 2010
The OED doesn't even acknowledge the 'haitch' pronunciation used, as you say, in Ireland. I'm frankly surprised.
I've just been reading about this fascinating letter: "Its power is that of a simple aspiration or breathing, with just sufficient narrowing of the glottis to be audible before a vowel."
So, the next time you hear that aspirate, you can say, knowingly, "I heard your glottis narrow just there".
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
Br Robyn Hoode - Navo - complete with theme tune Posted Sep 8, 2010
Haitch is apparently common and a sign of trying to sound educated. Them wot had a grammer school education say it 'eightch' (I find 'aitch' makes it too high and short. It's a longer, smoother sound in my head).
I know this because my mummy told me. Grammar schooled and very good at English, mater.
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
AgProv2 Posted Sep 8, 2010
Get around it by buying Chorley Cakes.
Delicious.
Ap, one step nearer leaving premod?
Hidden
AgProv2 Posted Sep 8, 2010
Chorley Cakes - lots of juicy raisins in a case of thin shortcrust pastry;
Eccles Cakes - lots of raisins encased in a skin of puff pastry.
Or maybe vice-versa.
The advantage is there's only one way of pronouncing either and it spres fighting.
AP - another step nearer leaving premod.
Key: Complain about this post
Big Question. Scone pronounced to rhyme with Gone or with Drone?
- 101: 2legs - Hey, babe, take a walk on the wild side... (Jun 30, 2010)
- 102: shagbark (Jul 1, 2010)
- 103: 2legs - Hey, babe, take a walk on the wild side... (Sep 6, 2010)
- 104: shagbark (Sep 6, 2010)
- 105: A Super Furry Animal (Sep 7, 2010)
- 106: fords - number 1 all over heaven (Sep 7, 2010)
- 107: Gnomon - time to move on (Sep 7, 2010)
- 108: Mu Beta (Sep 7, 2010)
- 109: shagbark (Sep 7, 2010)
- 110: Icy North (Sep 7, 2010)
- 111: shagbark (Sep 7, 2010)
- 112: Gnomon - time to move on (Sep 7, 2010)
- 113: shagbark (Sep 7, 2010)
- 114: TRiG (Ireland) A dog, so bade in office (Sep 7, 2010)
- 115: 2legs - Hey, babe, take a walk on the wild side... (Sep 7, 2010)
- 116: Icy North (Sep 7, 2010)
- 117: Br Robyn Hoode - Navo - complete with theme tune (Sep 8, 2010)
- 118: AgProv2 (Sep 8, 2010)
- 119: AgProv2 (Sep 8, 2010)
- 120: fords - number 1 all over heaven (Sep 8, 2010)
More Conversations for Ask h2g2
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."