A Conversation for Guacamole

Peer Review: A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 1

U168592

Entry: Guacamole - A21382779
Author: Uncle Travelling Matt (the Hoopy) Esq. - U168592

Flea Market Rescue.

Original Entry here; A1007290


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 2

Mu Beta

I would make sure you emphasise coriander leaves over coriander seeds.

Secondly, I have never seen a guacamole recipe that doesn't list both chillies and lime juice as a primary ingredient. I would be more tempted to omit the tomatoes.

B


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 3

U168592

Sorted smiley - ok


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 4

Gnomon - time to move on

If Guacamole is a South American specialty, how did it originate with the Aztecs, who were in North America?


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 5

U168592

ah, this old chestnut. I'll amend that to read more as it relates to it's supposed origins. smiley - ok


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 6

h5ringer

>>The pressure of making perfect guacamole<< --> The *secret to* making perfect guacamole


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 7

Icy North



Should read: 5mm (ΒΌ inch)


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 8

U168592

ah, cheers both smiley - ok

In my defence I did put this all together at about 2am this morning...


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 9

Elentari

Good job on the FM rescues, Matt.

"'Roma' tomatoes are perfect for guacamole; lots of outside bits, which is what you want, and what inside there is, is firm."

That sentence goes a bit Yoda at the end.

I think it would make more sense to have Ingredients, then Choosing The Best Avocado, then Method. smiley - smiley


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 10

U168592

Cheers E.

Have fixed up the bad jedi-speak and I agree with the restructuring, so have smiley - ok


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 11

FordsTowel

Hi, Uncle Matt:

A few suggestions for your entry:

* Spoon out your green mush into a bowl...
The stuff scooped out isn't really a mush, or mushy. Probably better to call it the flesh, meat, pulp; your choice.

* The terms Mix and Mixture are used througout
Since the ingredients had to be 'blended', 'pureed' - or, as you write, 'the job of mashing...' - I'd replace a couple of them. To me, Mixing implies just stirring stuff about. Even replace a 'mixture' or two with something like 'concoction', 'pureed heaven', etc.

* Step 3 says that the mix should have a few large chunks of avocado left.
This note should probably be up where you discussing the 'mashing' process. It's just to hard to reverse mash into chuncks if the reader is a step-by-step chef.

* You may want to add a 3rd footnote to the effect that some people never develop a taste for the stuff, whether because of actual flavours or textures.

Anyway, Congrats on finishing another fine entry!

smiley - towel


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 12

U168592

Excellent stuff FT - thank you! (this is the stuff that PR should be about, not spelling nit-pickery, brilliant).

I'll get on to all those point asap, thanks again! smiley - smiley


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 13

U168592

Right, think that's sorted now smiley - ok


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 14

KB

Question for you:

"Avoid refrigerating tomatoes and avocadoes before making your guacamole, as this can alter the final flavour."

Will this still alter the *final* flavour after the final product reaches room temperature, and if so, why? Is the chemical interaction of the various ingredients turned on its head, or something else?


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 15

U168592

dunno, just found that really cold avocadoes made my own gwakka taste a bit tarter. There's probably some chemistry involving long strings of protein rich monosaturated fats, but I'm afraid I can't answer that one form a chemical perspective...


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 16

Mu Beta

I think you'll find it's a ripening enzyme thing. Same as with bananas.

Basically, if you want avocadoes to ripen properly, a warm windowsill is best.

B


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 17

KB

So it doesn't make a difference to the final product, so long as they are ripe to start with?

That was what I was interested in.


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 18

ITIWBS

My own basic guacamole:

Scoop out the contents of the fresh ripe avocado with a spoon, coarsely mash with a fork, add an equal amount of cottage cheese, serve as an entree with corn chips and chili salsa on the side. Eat it by the bowl full.

...or, alternatively, one can use it for a taco or taquito filling or in burritos, etc....


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 19

Cyzaki

Bit of a nit pick - I don't think you need the exclamation marks in the first paragraph.

Good entry though smiley - smiley

smiley - panda


A21382779 - Guacamole

Post 20

FordsTowel

It looks just great, UTM!

I especially like the addition to footnote #2!! smiley - rofl

smiley - towel


Key: Complain about this post

More Conversations for Guacamole

Write an Entry

"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."

Write an entry
Read more