A Conversation for Steak with Papaya Marinade

Peer Review: A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 1

U168592

Entry: Steak with Papaya Marinade - A9468327
Author: MJ - [server busy, or most likely out to lunch, having a quiet pint - not due back until next Wednesday] - U168592

This is a Flea Market Rescue, Original Entry here: A2803790smiley - smiley

This is my first attempt at a recipe for the EG, so go easy!

(I realise there's a little contention around that recipes may not have a place in the EG, but hey, who am I to avoid contention smiley - winkeye)

MJ smiley - ok


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 2

neongreencat

Seems quite good, but what happened to the 'liquid smoke'?
smiley - biggrin


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 3

AlexAshman

smiley - drool


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 4

AlexAshman

Sorry - that last post wasn't very constructive...

The only thing I can think of is - is there any difference between Hawaiian and Mexican papayas?

Otherwise, good entry smiley - ok


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 5

U168592

smiley - cheers all. It is rather yum smiley - winkeye

The Liquid Smoke disappeared because it's purely found in the US as far as I'm aware, whereas BBQ Sauce is more global, plus Liquid Smoke is a brand name and we can't have it on the Beeb smiley - smiley

Difference between Hawaiian and Mexican? Dunno, I'll find out! smiley - laugh


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 6

U168592

Found out smiley - winkeye and updated the Entry. smiley - ta

MJ smiley - ok


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 7

neongreencat

I hope my comment wasn't too far-fetched, i just noticed the original recipe included the liquid smoke. (somehow the idea of liquid smoke makes me imagine an odd farm scene, smoke trees or somethin')

Don't mean to chitchat on your pr, I should research LS!

Well written, and readable. Nice mention on the latex thing, (who knew?!) The 'I felt fine' in the original was a bit too funny for a realistic warning.

Is the revised recipe one that you know works?

There is no reason to be concerned that the Guide should have recepies, moreover that is the sort of primary detail that a researcher should note! If a Human is ever 'hitching on an unknown world an effective meat tenderixer would be quite helpful.


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 8

neongreencat

Oh, I get it. But liquid smoke and BBQ sauce are hardly interchangeable. More sugar n stuff in BBQ, LS is a black liquid (i wanna say distillate) that tastes like burnt wood smells!


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 9

U168592

neon -

I was worried about the Liquid Smoke thing at first, and having seen the recipe in the Flea Market a while ago, I thought I'd give it a go. Not having Liquid Smoke I indeed substituted the stuff for BBQ sauce. Worked a treat! smiley - drool

I also used canned papaya instead of fresh, and that worked as well smiley - biggrin

Ah, cooking is such a fine art isn't it smiley - laugh

MJ smiley - ok


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 10

aka Bel - A87832164

Hi MJ, nice recipe, I'd say. Don't you think it would be a good idea to put the steak on your list of ingredients ? Maybe suggesting its size/weight? I tend to go through the ingredients list when cooking something new, and have had a bad surprise or two when starting to cook, and suddenly coming across something that hasn't been mentioned before or at all even smiley - groan Can spoil everything.


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 11

U168592

smiley - laugh Bloody good point Bella! smiley - rofl I'll ammend that now!


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 12

aka Bel - A87832164

Oh, and a tiny thing :

suit most peoples tastes - shouldn't it be people's tastes ?

smiley - cheers


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 13

U168592

smiley - cheers I've fixed everything up now I think smiley - smiley

smiley - ta


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 14

aka Bel - A87832164

Looks good to me smiley - smiley


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 15

U168592

Tastes pretty good too smiley - winkeye


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 16

aka Bel - A87832164

If you like beef , I guess it does. It sounds yummy smiley - smiley


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 17

U168592

I suppose you could supplement the steak with pork chops...never thought of that. Might try it one day, if I liked pork. smiley - erm

Of course, it's not for vegetarians at all is it smiley - weird


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 18

aka Bel - A87832164

I'd have to hunt for papayas first, have never seen them tinned here, and seldom fresh smiley - erm


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 19

U168592

smiley - laugh Can just imagine you stalking around the supermarkets, war paint on your face and a spear at the ready, hunting down the ever elusive papaya...smiley - rofl


A9468327 - Steak with Papaya Marinade

Post 20

aka Bel - A87832164

Weeeelll, that's exactly the right picture you got there smiley - blush


Key: Complain about this post