A Conversation for 20 Childraising rules
- 1
- 2
Very good..
Wand'rin star Posted Feb 22, 2000
Ok-rule 21 added (actually I thought it was too obvious to need inclusion and is much more serious than the others) "Try very hard not to hit your children for any reason. Even if they forget, you will suffer guilt for the rest of your life" I agree with Joanna,though - I don't think it's an area for government interference. I'm assuming we're not talking about raising a bruise here.
Very good..
Wand'rin star Posted Feb 22, 2000
Striking someone else's child is a criminal offence where I come from and much too serious for what I meant to be light-hearted childraising advice.
Very good..
adabsurdum Posted Feb 22, 2000
In Germany we had a strong debate in the last 3 years about whether it should
be forbidden to rape your wife or not. Lots of conservatives argued in the way
above, that the state should not interfere in family affairs. But a crime remains a crime,
even if the victim is a relative. Striking children is a crime, but only if they aren't yours. Silly, isn't it ?
Very good..
adabsurdum Posted Feb 22, 2000
In Germany we had a strong debate in the last 3 years about whether it should
be forbidden to rape your wife or not. Lots of conservatives argued in the way
above, that the state should not interfere in family affairs. But a crime remains a crime,
even and espescially if the victim is a relative. Striking children is a crime in germany,
but only if they aren't yours. Silly, isn't it ?
Very good..
Wand'rin star Posted Feb 22, 2000
Yes, but I think your equation is a good example of reducto ad absurdam.
Very good..
Is mise Duncan Posted Feb 22, 2000
It is also against the law to park in a hospital A&E entrance. This too has nothing to do with the thread. Mad, isn't it?
Very good..
Sho - employed again! Posted Jan 26, 2004
There is a difference between striking a child with a smart tap on the bum/leg to get their attention as they step off the curb into the path of a speeding BMW (in our village the speed limit is 30kph, do you think anyone adheres to that?) and beating them senseless for no reason.
you'll note that it is only parents who administer a slap (and who knows what the child had been doing in the previous hours to lead up to that?) who are approached by "do gooders". The ones who beat up their children are too scary to mix with...
I've noticed that children's behaviour over here in Germany (well, it's a sweeping statement, but why not?) is something I don't accept in my two children: who are to all intents and purposes German. I put it down to the Anti-authoritarian upbringings. No doubt it works for some kids, but boundaries are what works for kids.
If the smack on the legs in the above scenario is what it takes to get Gruesome #2's attention, then a smack on the legs is what she will get.
and no doubt any passing Polizei will arrest me and not the speeding car who will be too far away by then. Possibly mowing down a kid in the next village.
But I digress....
I was sent here (I remember reading this long long ago) by a friend (or two) as we went on an h2g2 nostalgia trip.
Excellent entry!
Very good..
Sho - employed again! Posted Jan 28, 2004
you may still be here, but where is your spear?
I miss that...
Key: Complain about this post
- 1
- 2
Very good..
- 21: Wand'rin star (Feb 22, 2000)
- 22: GVM (Feb 22, 2000)
- 23: Wand'rin star (Feb 22, 2000)
- 24: adabsurdum (Feb 22, 2000)
- 25: adabsurdum (Feb 22, 2000)
- 26: Wand'rin star (Feb 22, 2000)
- 27: Is mise Duncan (Feb 22, 2000)
- 28: Sho - employed again! (Jan 26, 2004)
- 29: Is mise Duncan (Jan 27, 2004)
- 30: Sho - employed again! (Jan 28, 2004)
- 31: Is mise Duncan (Jan 28, 2004)
More Conversations for 20 Childraising rules
Write an Entry
"The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is a wholly remarkable book. It has been compiled and recompiled many times and under many different editorships. It contains contributions from countless numbers of travellers and researchers."